PE1709, which was lodged by Claire Mooney, is on installing closed-circuit television cameras and providing full-time social work support in all additional support needs schools.
Following our meeting on 22 November 2018, a range of written submissions have been received, including a response from the petitioner. The Scottish Government’s submission outlines a number of safeguards that are in place to protect young people. However, the petitioner feels that despite such safeguards, children attending additional support needs schools can “fall through the cracks”.
In their responses to the petition, both UNISON and the National Association of Schoolmasters Union of Women Teachers Scotland say that they do not support installation of CCTV cameras in schools. UNISON is of the view that doing so could foster a
“culture of blame/punishment”.
Concerns were also raised around possible infringements of human rights relating to privacy, as well as general data protection regulations implications.
A number of submissions suggest, as an alternative, that further investment is required in staff and training as a means of ensuring protection of children in additional support needs schools. In the view of the Scottish Secondary Teachers Association:
“CCTV cameras cannot be a replacement for the range of educational staff but as an added technological advancement in addition to staff in making schools a place of safety for both pupils and staff.”
The Scottish Government submission confirms that use of CCTV and the delivery of social work are statutory responsibilities of local authorities.
From the written submissions that have been received, there is support for having a social work presence in additional support needs schools. However, the importance of multi-agency working in school settings was stressed, for example, by NASUWT Scotland.
After our previous consideration of the petition, we agreed to investigate international examples of CCTV being used in similar settings in other countries. A Scottish Parliament information centre briefing has been provided and is included in our papers. The briefing highlights that there are few documented examples of CCTV being used specifically in schools that support children with complex additional support needs. The closest examples could be found in the USA, Australia and India.
Do members have comments on or suggestions for action in relation to the petition?
