Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

A83 (Rest and Be Thankful) (PE1540)

Thursday 20 June 2019 Public Petitions Committee About 10:15–10:45 Petitions 34 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

34 contributions
Angus MacDonald SNP The Deputy Convener · Falkirk East
link

I welcome again Jackie Baillie and Maurice Corry, who have stayed for consideration of PE1540, on a permanent solution for the A83. The petition was lodged by Douglas Philand and calls on the committee to urge the Scottish Government to ensure that there is a permanent solution for the A83 at the Rest and Be Thankful, so that that lifeline route is not closed because of landslides.

Following our previous consideration of the petition, on 6 December 2018, we received a written submission from the Scottish Government. The submission confirms that the Government has conducted a programme of engagement and consultation, including work on the A83, as part of its review of the national transport strategy, which is expected to be published by the end of 2019. The submission also confirms that the Cabinet Secretary for Transport, Infrastructure and Connectivity intended to meet Argyll and Bute Council in early 2019 to discuss the emerging vision, outcome and policies of the strategy and what they mean for Argyll. The submission explains that work on tree planting to reduce the risk of landslips at the Rest and Be Thankful was due to begin in early 2019.

Do members have any comments or would you like to hear from the local members first?

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

I would like to hear from our local representatives.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

I will go first, as I know quite a lot about this. I was elected in 2012 as a councillor on Argyll and Bute Council, and I was the vice-convener of the roads committee. The situation has been going on for a very long time.

As late as yesterday, I had some photographs taken of the Rest and Be Thankful, and, as of last night, no tree planting had taken place at all. In fact, in the area of forestry that the submission referred to as going to private sale, the “for sale” board is still up at the bottom of the glen, so there is no movement on that. There are some issues with the Forestry Commission in relation to harvesting the trees at the bottom of the glen, which is at the beginning of the Rest and Be Thankful, because there are real concerns about hydrology if people start taking those off the hill, which we identified in 2012.

I will give you a bit of background. Way back in farming times—those people among us who are farmers will probably know this better than me—there was an allocation of hillside for the local farmers. Their cattle and sheep would go on to the sides of the Rest and Be Thankful, and, by going around and contouring, they stamped in the soil, forming a barrier on all slides. There are no sheep or cattle on the hill any more—that is not encouraged—so there is a fundamental natural problem. Furthermore, once the forestry people harvest their trees, they completely change the hydrology, so the water situation gets worse. That is why there is a dilemma. There is no use in the Government hiding behind various studies and reviews or in yet another review digging holes. I will come to that in a minute. That is not the solution. Unless you pile up the hill with cattle and make up for those lost years, you are not going to solve the problem. There has to be a dramatically different situation.

The council considered a couple of major options. One was to cover the road with the Swiss type of avalanche guards, like an open tunnel, so that the debris would slide over and down. However, the worry was that the rock might give way, and there is a sheer drop on the left of the road as you go up, so that option was ruled out. The other option was the blue option, which was to take the road on the south side of Glen Croe, through the forestry ground. Permission has been granted to take it from Ardgartan up to the top of the connection where you turn left and go down to Lochgoilhead, and on up to Inverary. The cost of that option was £40 million. I gather that the spend on what the council is currently doing is not far off £60 million. Jacobs is there, and we still have single-file traffic, with delays of up to 15 minutes. That is non-summertime traffic, so you can understand why people are getting frustrated.

There are continual landslip issues, which is down to a geological problem. It is a fact of life. When I went up there, only three days ago, I could not believe the holes. It is like a massive tooth filling on the side of the hill, and on the other side there is a sheer drop. What is holding it together is the road—I leave that to your imagination. It is quite a serious issue, and I do not think the Government and Transport Scotland have solved it. As a councillor originally, and then as a member of the Scottish Parliament—like my colleague Jackie Baillie—I have been pushing, along with the council, for a solution. Jackie Baillie sits on the task force. I am not blaming her; I am just saying that nothing seems to be happening.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

That is absolutely right—it is not that. I know, from other people who are on the task force, that it is frustrating. I think that Jackie Baillie would agree with me on that.

What is the Government doing, and what is the effect of all of this? The effect is being seen—at point blank—in confidence in economic development in Argyll and the isles. We have a population reduction of 10 per cent, which will be about 9,000 over the next 10 years, and people are making active decisions not to invest in Argyll and the isles. Also, tourists are finding other routes to use, and, once they find another route, they go somewhere else.

The road is a vital link to the isles and to the west coast. It has fish traffic on it, and people from the quarries use it. All the logs from forestry come down that route. Yet, we still cannot get the message through to the Government that it has to do something absolutely dramatic. As I say, there has been no planting of trees, and there are delays to traffic, which is leading to frustration and the possibility of accidents. Once new routes are discovered, people go elsewhere, business is lost, economic development is less attractive and the population will reduce.

The Government clearly has options available to it. It could take the road up the south side of Glen Croe, which, as I said, is the blue option. Another option would be to take the road straight up the middle of Glen Croe and tunnel through the shoulder to the top of the glen, coming out at what is called the devil’s bridge, at the other side, under the lochan. The old hill climb road is not usable any more—it has now been ruled out on health and safety grounds. I have talked to the Royal Scottish Automobile Club about it, and it agrees that that is not an issue for the Parliament any more, so there is no suggestion that we can have nice thoughts about using that road. I know that it is a relief road at the moment, but it is not adequate—it goes back to the time of the ark; it is ridiculous.

My plea to the committee is that the situation needs a radical rethink. We need a radical solution and, if necessary, UK Government help on this. The option of a tunnel would not be cheap, but it has been done in the Faroes. In the Faroes, all the islands have been joined up—the Danish Government has done that beautifully. We want something like that: a very simple tunnel at the top and a road up the middle. I am sure that the Government and the landowner could come to some agreement on the sale of the land. I ask the committee to look at that option, as well as calling for other options and another review by the cabinet secretary.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

The double act continues, for this petition at least. The Rest and Be Thankful is at the edge of my constituency, and the impact on my constituency is significant. The impact on Mike Russell’s constituency—because his constituents need to travel that route—is even greater, and I am sure that he would echo many of the comments that have been made.

I attended the most recent A83 task force meeting, which was held in the last few weeks in Arrochar, where we received an update on progress on stabilising the hillside at the Rest and Be Thankful. The situation is frustrating, particularly for local people. I am not going to rehearse the options that Maurice Corry cited, because I think that that detail is not for the committee. However, he has illustrated that there is a wide range of options that would provide a permanent solution, which is what local people want. They want a permanent solution so that the hillside is not collapsing and blocking up the road every two minutes.

The diversion takes drivers through some beautiful parts of Scotland, but it can take up to 40 minutes. The length of time that it takes is fundamentally damaging to the economy of the local area, and local people are very anxious. We know that it has a severe impact on people both socially and economically. It impacts on people getting to hospital and on ambulances getting through. The road is an important part of the infrastructure and life in Argyll and Bute.

I do know that work is going on. The Scottish transport projects review is now under way, and Government officials held a consultation event just prior to the task force meeting, which was very helpful. They were left in no doubt about the priority that the A83 has—and the A82 as well. The Scottish Government has been working with Argyll and Bute Council to make sure that the road is a priority in the STPR. We need that investment to find a permanent solution, and we are at a critical stage. While the work appears to be moving ahead, I ask the committee not to close the petition but to seek an update from the Scottish Government not only on what is happening with the task force and the interim measures it is taking but on the STPR, because that will be the critical vehicle that provides the investment for the permanent solution.

Angus MacDonald SNP The Deputy Convener · Falkirk East
link

Thank you. Do members have any views?

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

It seems to me that, in a lot of these situations, we are responsible for destabilising the land by clearing it—and for all sorts of other reasons. Do we know what the natural vegetation would be if we had left it alone in the first place? Nature is very good at looking after itself.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

It has always been a forestry area. In other words, there have always been trees on it, and they have been taken off. The south side of the hill, which is where the problem is, is where a lot of cattle and sheep were kept when the farmers used it originally. Now, the farmers are harvesting it but there are no animals—that is the problem. Had it been left alone, or had farming policy been static, I think we would not have had a problem. However, things move on and there were obviously not the incentives to keep the cattle on the hill.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Would you say that the solution is proper planting to stabilise the hillside, and then to leave it alone?

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

I do not know. I have seen some of the rocks that are poised to come down and those that have already come down. It would just take a deluge of rain to bring the whole lot down. That is one of the problems that you have, and you cannot control that. We have been told that it will take 15 to 20 years before the measures have any effect, in which time 20,000 of the population will have gone.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

It is a really frustrating situation. It is really shabby: so many stakeholders are involved, but there has been so little progress. I am not sure—I will need to ask the clerks—but was the petition first lodged in 2014?

Lynn Russell Clerk
link

Yes.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

How ridiculous. You are losing investment, tourism and economic growth—and it is a rural area. It is absolutely disgraceful.

There are so many unknowns. You mentioned the situation with the hillside. Transport Scotland continues to work with landowners to conclude the private sale, but you say that the sign is still up.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Jackie Baillie is on the task force. There does not seem to be much movement there. What urgent action can we call for to bump this up the priority list of strategic transport projects?

10:45

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

In fairness to the Scottish Government, I think that it has recognised the need to find a permanent solution. There have been early discussions with Argyll and Bute Council, and consultants have been brought in. We recognise that, when Transport Scotland’s project review concludes, we want to be able to start work straight away.

I am not technical, so I will not comment on what the most appropriate solution would be. I will confine myself to simply expressing the frustration of local constituents, who require a solution. I will leave it to the experts to find out what that solution should be. However, work is under way to ensure that it is treated as a priority the minute the transport review is concluded.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Is there a mechanism in place to ensure that that happens? Everybody wants infrastructure projects, and everybody wants the issues on their roads to be prioritised. How will you make this a priority? What are the criteria?

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

You would need to invite that information from the Scottish Government. My understanding is that it has consultants working alongside Argyll and Bute Council so that the road can be practically one of the first projects out of the stocks, but you would need to confirm that with the Scottish Government.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

It may be possible to write to the council with that question.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

I suggest that you do that, because you might get a different story.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I am interested in understanding where this project sits within the development of STPR 2, which will not report for another couple of years. It would be interesting to ask the Scottish Government whether it sits within STPR 2 or whether it can sit outside it so that something can be done sooner. As I say, it will be another two years before that report is written.

Angus MacDonald SNP The Deputy Convener · Falkirk East
link

It would have to sit outside the STPR, but, as Jackie Baillie has rightly highlighted, the STPR is under way.

The Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform Committee took evidence on the STPR a few weeks ago, and the Government is thinking outside the box. It is looking at building tunnels instead of using ferries in some parts of Scotland, and it is looking at having a 40-year plan. I would hope that the issue is a priority and is dealt with first and foremost, as I share the frustration of the petitioners. It has been going on for some time.

Before the election, in the previous session of Parliament, the committee undertook a site visit to the Rest and Be Thankful. Unfortunately, I could not make it, as I was taking evidence in Skye on land reform on the same day. I was a bit disappointed that I could not get to the Rest and Be Thankful. The situation there has been an issue for some time, and it needs to be drawn to a conclusion. Given everybody’s frustration, are members minded to invite the cabinet secretary to give oral evidence here, to increase the pressure?

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

It is lovely to welcome the cabinet secretary, as you know, and it would very good to get a feel from the Scottish Government of where it is with this particular situation.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Maurice Corry also suggested that we invite evidence from Argyll and Bute Council. Who is on the task force?

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

The council is represented on the task force. Local stakeholders and community councils also attend. It is made up of everybody who is affected by the situation, including the Scottish Government and the operator on behalf of the Scottish Government, Transport Scotland.

Angus MacDonald SNP The Deputy Convener · Falkirk East
link

It is on everybody’s radar. We have the option of contacting the Scottish Government now and asking for an update on the STPR in relation to the A83, as well as for its opinion of how the A83 task force is working and what progress is being made on that and on the hillside planting that was expected to commence in early 2019. Maurice Corry has advised us that there is no sign of anything happening there yet.

Angus MacDonald SNP The Deputy Convener · Falkirk East
link

It would be good to get the photos.

It would be helpful if we could get an update and then have the evidence session with the cabinet secretary. We will get the update over the recess and try to diary the cabinet secretary for an early meeting, perhaps in September. Are we agreed on that course of action?

Members indicated agreement.

Angus MacDonald SNP The Deputy Convener · Falkirk East
link

I thank Jackie Baillie and Maurice Corry, and I thank Maurice Corry for sending his scout out yesterday to check.

  1. 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 1
  2. 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 7
  3. 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 24
  4. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 48
  5. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 34
  6. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  7. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  8. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 10
  9. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  10. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 11

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.