Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Glue Traps (PE1671)

Thursday 20 June 2019 Public Petitions Committee About 10:00–10:15 Petitions 48 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

48 contributions
Angus MacDonald SNP The Deputy Convener · Falkirk East
link

The first continued petition is PE1671, on the sale and use of glue traps, which was lodged by Andrea Goddard and Lisa Harvey on behalf of Let’s Get MAD for Wildlife.

At our previous consideration of the petition in December 2018, we agreed to invite the Pest Management Alliance to give evidence at a future meeting, and representatives of the PMA are here to give evidence today. I welcome Dee Ward-Thompson of the British Pest Control Association, John Hope of the National Pest Technicians Association and Tom Bell of the Royal Environmental Health Institute of Scotland. Thank you for attending this morning. You have an opportunity to provide a brief opening statement of no more than five minutes, after which we will move to questions from the committee.

Tom Bell Pest Management Alliance
link

Good morning. The plan is to give a very brief introduction, if that is okay. The PMA acknowledges the potential for cruelty to be caused to target and non-target species by the use of sticky boards. However, we recognise the need to protect public health if an imminent risk presents itself, and we look forward to informing the process.

Angus MacDonald SNP The Deputy Convener · Falkirk East
link

Thank you. In your submission of November 2018, you acknowledged the proposals that were put forward by the petitioners with regard to the code of practice and indicated that you would consider a potential redraft of the code, with a particular focus on the training aspect. Can you advise the committee whether that has been done? If so, when do you expect it to come into effect?

Dee Ward-Thompson Pest Management Alliance
link

The revision is still on-going. We have looked at making some revisions, particularly around the reasons why or when glue traps could be used. However, we are still in the process of drafting that document, so we do not have a final document today.

With regard to the training, we are looking at developing a training course—again, that is in progress at the moment—that people would be able to take online or in a classroom. However, I should note that the Royal Society for Public Health level 2 award, which is currently the base qualification that we use for pest control, covers the use of sticky boards, so it is being covered.

Angus MacDonald SNP The Deputy Convener · Falkirk East
link

Do you have a timeline for that and also a timeline for the code of practice?

Dee Ward-Thompson Pest Management Alliance
link

The code of practice should be ready soon. John Hope can perhaps say more about that.

John Hope Pest Management Alliance
link

We looked at the code of practice in light of the petition, which makes various points that make sense. However, we wanted to see whether any recommendations came out of this committee meeting today with regard to what you think should be done. We did not want to issue a new code of practice and then end up in a situation where we had to send out another revision quite quickly. Work is in progress on the code of practice, and I would say three to four months would be the maximum time we would need to develop that.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

As I understand it, the code applies or will apply only to organisations and pest controllers who are members of the PMA. How binding do you think that the code will be?

Dee Ward-Thompson Pest Management Alliance
link

The code has been around for a long time. The PMA comes together whenever there are any significant issues or subjects that we feel strongly about and in relation to which we think that the industry should come together as a group. We are made up of the various pest control associations, the Chartered Institute of Environmental Health, REHIS and a group called the national pest advisory panel. We wrote the code of best practice a very long time ago. The original version was published around 2010, when we realised the importance of making sure that these products were used safely and only when needed, and decided to give guidance and assurance that that was taking place within professional pest management.

All of our members in the different associations sign up to the pest management codes of best practice. We currently have only three, and it is important that all of our members adhere to them. We issue them when people become members and follow that up through an audit process, which shows that, genuinely, all of our members adhere to any code of best practice that the organisations sign up to. We do not watch all of our members all the time, but we can say that professional pest controllers will follow the codes of best practice that are set down by the organisations and the PMA.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

What training and oversight do you propose putting in place to ensure compliance?

Dee Ward-Thompson Pest Management Alliance
link

With the code of best practice?

Dee Ward-Thompson Pest Management Alliance
link

I can speak only for our organisation, but when all members join they are taken through all of the codes of best practice and there is online training that they can do, which is specifically in the code of best practice. We have continuing professional development within the pest management industry. We have a CPD scheme that is only on pest control—it is not a broad subject CPD; it is all on pest control. There will be CPD courses and webinars on all of the codes of best practice that we have. I think that John Hope’s association does something similar.

John Hope Pest Management Alliance
link

Yes. I think that it would be fair to say that the vast majority of members of both associations—in fact, I would say virtually all of them—adhere to that code of best practice when it comes to glue boards. As Dee Ward-Thompson says, the code of practice has been around for a number of years, and it is well entrenched within the pest control industry.

We have a robust system for dealing with complaints on anything that comes to us with regard to our members. I have dealt with one complaint in the last 12 months, which I upheld. We went through a process of dealing with that individual member, which involved retraining and readvising them, and we followed that up with a subsequent visit. We have a robust process in place, and I am sure the BPCA also does. As I say, the code is well entrenched.

Where the code is not so well entrenched, though, is in relation to the availability of the boards to amateur users. Boards that are provided by pest control suppliers will have the code of best practice printed on the back of them. The staff of the various pest control companies that buy those products will have gone through training to use those products. As Dee Ward-Thompson said, the base qualification that we use is RSPH level 2, although we are looking at a new training programme specifically for glue boards. However, no such controls exist when it comes to the amateur use of boards. You would only have to go on Amazon or eBay or any of those various platforms to be able to buy boards and use them however you like. That has always been a big concern for us. However, for professional users, the code is well entrenched and we use the boards properly.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I was going to ask about the pest controllers who are not members and those amateur people who are trying to carry out pest control. You cannot ensure adherence in relation to them. Would you advocate that glue boards should be used only by those who are professional pest controllers and members of your organisation?

Dee Ward-Thompson Pest Management Alliance
link

I agree 100 per cent.

John Hope Pest Management Alliance
link

Yes, I totally agree.

Dee Ward-Thompson Pest Management Alliance
link

I totally agree.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

I would like to pick up on that point. The cabinet secretary had intended to introduce restrictions on the sale and use of glue traps. You mentioned Amazon, which brings up the issue of online sales. Is it only somebody who is aware of the code of practice and is a specially trained practitioner who can purchase glue traps, or can anybody purchase glue traps? Is there anything in place to prevent those who are not trained from purchasing glue traps?

John Hope Pest Management Alliance
link

The professional pest control provider market will have certain customers who have accounts with them that are from pest control companies. There are no restrictions in place at all on a member of the general public purchasing glue traps online or even from a market stall.

10:15

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Do you believe that there should be something in place?

John Hope Pest Management Alliance
link

With regard to the amateur market, certainly.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Has the PMA looked at controlling that?

John Hope Pest Management Alliance
link

To be fair, that is quite difficult for us to control. We deal with the pest control suppliers on a regular basis and there are discussions around providing glue boards only to professional users. It is fair to say that all the suppliers have come on board, which is why, as I say, the code of practice is printed on the back of their boards. However, the boards that you buy from a market stall will not have that code of practice printed on them, and people do not know how to use them. The petition is right in saying that those boards do have the potential to cause suffering. I have been in this industry for nearly 30 years and I would argue that the people who work in the industry do not have any agenda to cause suffering—in fact, the absolute opposite is true. We are in a world now where there are restrictions on many products.

There are difficulties in relation to controlling rodents these days. I know that I am going off your question, but the point that I am trying to make is that there is a need to keep these products for public health use. There are difficulties now around rodent control with regard to tolerance to cereal baits and behavioural resistance to bait boxes and the like. We need to keep the armoury that we have, providing we use it properly, which is why the PMA recognises that we need to have controls over these measures. That is why we brought in the code of practice in the first place.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

To respond to that, I think that irresponsible use is devaluing what the PMA is setting out to do with in the code of practice. I find it quite horrific that people who do not how to use the traps are able to use them.

With regard to a revision of the code of practice, you said that you wanted to wait and see what happened here today and to find out how the committee would guide you. I am not an expert, so I do not think that I will be able to guide you, but I wondered who you will consult to shape the code of practice. Who will you bring on board to allow you to make the approach more robust, if that is what you are after?

Dee Ward-Thompson Pest Management Alliance
link

We have already consulted. We have been in consultation with various organisations, including the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs and Natural England, and we are also speaking to representatives from Wales and Scotland and Northern Ireland, because we cover all of those within our membership base. It is always difficult when you are trying to rewrite something that has been in place for many years and has worked effectively. Sometimes, you can get to the point where you make it too big and it is no longer a code of best practice and has become a guidance document. It is quite a lengthy process, and we are trying to ensure that we do not make it too wordy, which might mean that people do not follow it.

We will probably end up having two documents, because a code of best practice sets out what you must do—“You shall do this and you shall not do that”—whereas guidance is more about the how. As I say, the PMA has only three codes of best practice, because there are only three subjects that we feel strongly enough about that we think that we need to have a code of best practice on them, and we want to keep them nice and short. As I say, I think that we will end up having additional guidance that will explain the approach to people.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Is the code of best practice given with the product at the point of sale? I know that you cannot track that online. Obviously, there are instructions, but is a code of best practice available to those people who are not trained and using it irresponsibly?

Dee Ward-Thompson Pest Management Alliance
link

Responsible sellers—that is, manufacturers of the products—will supply a printed copy of the code of best practice, but lots of sellers will not and there will be no controls at all. That is one of the biggest issues with the amateur market—anybody in this room could buy the products and have them delivered by tomorrow from China, America or anywhere, because there are no controls at all.

The pest management industry has always been self-regulating. The campaign for responsible rodenticide use—CCRU UK—has voluntary codes on the sale and use of rodenticides used to keep antivitamin K-actives. That is self-stewardship. The use of aluminium phosphide is through stewardship by voluntary means and by working with an organisation called BASIS RAMPS—RAMPS stands for the register of accredited metallic phosphide schemes. The PMA’s stewardship is through a very stringent code of best practice, but it is all voluntary. If amateurs can gain products, you will always have the issue of controlling point of sale, which I think will be very difficult.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Mr Hope spoke about having one complaint in the past year. Have any practitioners ever been struck off because of the irresponsible use of glue traps?

John Hope Pest Management Alliance
link

I have been in post for about 12 months, so I cannot answer for what has gone before, but, to the best of my knowledge, no one has been struck off, and certainly not in the past 12 months. I think that striking people off and removing them from an association can be counterproductive—it is far better to work with people and retrain and educate them rather than send them down a road to oblivion, where they will continue to practise but without any potential repercussions. As Dee Ward-Thompson said, we are not a regulated industry, but we are good at self-regulation.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

I have one last point, which rounds off what I have been talking about: under what circumstances should glue traps be used? Do you think that that is specific enough in the code of conduct? Is there a clear message?

John Hope Pest Management Alliance
link

I understand where you are going with that question, and I understand what the petition is saying. The code of best practice demonstrates—dictates—that glue boards should be used only as a last resort when all other control measures have failed, or if there is an imminent risk to public health. I can give you various examples of that—the obvious one would be a mouse or a rat getting into to somewhere such as a hospital operating theatre and you, the customer or the pest controller do not want to wait two weeks for anticoagulant baits to start working. In that situation, I would advocate their use.

As I said, I have been in this industry for about 30 years and have probably used glue boards about 10 times, so they are not commonplace. I would not like to be in a position where they were removed from our armoury as a last resort. That is all they are ever used for.

Angus MacDonald SNP The Deputy Convener · Falkirk East
link

I will stick with the code of practice for a bit longer. We understand that it was revised in 2017. How many times has it been revised since 2010 and what motivated the 2017 revision?

Dee Ward-Thompson Pest Management Alliance
link

I think that there have been three revisions in total. As with most codes of best practice that are done through the PMA, we have a revision process. We look at all our codes of best practice annually, so revisions are just a natural progression. I do not think there was any particular reason that prompted the revision—it was just part of the normal process.

Angus MacDonald SNP The Deputy Convener · Falkirk East
link

The petitioners’ submission of September 2018 provided a range of suggested improvements to the code. You have acknowledged those comments, but which or any of the suggestions might feature in the revised code? Have you contacted the petitioners directly to seek their views?

John Hope Pest Management Alliance
link

No, we have not contacted the petitioners directly. We will take on board the various aspects of that submission, but, as Dee Ward-Thompson said, we do not want to make it overly cumbersome. On the inclusion of various potentially emotional statements about suffering, I think that that issue is, again, something about which our members are fully aware. In that context, I reiterate that there are no controls in place at all in the amateur use market.

Angus MacDonald SNP The Deputy Convener · Falkirk East
link

Would it be possible for you to provide a copy of the redraft of the code of practice so that the petitioners and the committee can look at it? I think that it would be helpful if we could have sight of it at an early stage.

John Hope Pest Management Alliance
link

Yes, absolutely. We will continue to work on redrafting it. My view is that it is comprehensive, but we will take on board the petitioners’ points of view. As soon as we have carried out a redraft, we will more than happily send you a copy before it goes to submission to the general pest control population.

Angus MacDonald SNP The Deputy Convener · Falkirk East
link

Okay. What is the timeline for that?

John Hope Pest Management Alliance
link

If we say three to four months, would that be reasonable, Dee?

Dee Ward-Thompson Pest Management Alliance
link

Yes.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I think that we would all agree that, in general, pest control should be left to professional pest control management.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

It is not obligatory to be a member of the PMA in order to practise pest control. Therefore, someone who has no intention of following that code of practice, would not become a member of the PMA. That is a big hole. If we are really going to close a loophole, we would have to ask the Scottish Government if it is prepared to legislate, otherwise those who are non-compliant with the code of practice can continue doing what they are doing with no recourse. I totally understand where the petitioners are coming from and would support their approach, but how do we enforce that? The only way that I can see of doing that is through legislation that would require users of glue traps to have membership of a body. I do not know where we would go with that, convener.

Angus MacDonald SNP The Deputy Convener · Falkirk East
link

That can be considered, but I think that we need to reflect on the evidence that we have taken this morning and discuss further actions at a future meeting. However, clearly, we are keen to see the finalised code. Ideally, if that is done within three months, that would be all well and good, but I suggest that we reserve the option to invite back the PMA to present the finalised version to the committee, possibly in November or December, if the draft were provided by October. Clearly, we would need a copy of the code and the redrafted version in advance of that. Do members agree to discuss the petition further at a future meeting?

Members indicated agreement.

Angus MacDonald SNP The Deputy Convener · Falkirk East
link

Thank you very much for giving evidence this morning—it is much appreciated. We may or may not see you back here at some point in the not-too-distant future. Thank you.

10:28 Meeting suspended.

10:31 On resuming—

  1. 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 1
  2. 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 7
  3. 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 24
  4. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 48
  5. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 34
  6. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  7. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  8. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 10
  9. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  10. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 11

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.