PE1691, which was lodged by Christopher Hampton, on behalf of the steering group of Bowman’s View, calls for a review of the Title Conditions (Scotland) Act 2003,
“which prohibits a change of factor in the estate unless agreement is obtained by a two-thirds majority of owners in the estate, particularly in terms of the impact of that requirement on residents of sheltered accommodation.”
We last considered the petition in November 2018, when we considered submissions from the Scottish Government, the Law Society of Scotland and the Scottish Law Commission. Members will recall that those submissions did not directly support the action called for in the petition. The Law Society did not have a view on what an appropriate majority should be to implement a change of property factor, suggesting that it was a matter for the Parliament to determine. The SLC indicated that it had no plans to carry out a review of the legislation as it pertained to the petition. The Scottish Government was clear that it had no plans to consult on changing the law on this issue.
We invited the petitioner to respond to those submissions. Unfortunately, we did not receive a response from the petitioner until the beginning of this week. Members have a copy of the email that the petitioner sent to the clerks, in which he expresses dissatisfaction with the current position. He refers to the existing legislation as
“well-intended”
but
“unfortunately patronising and naive”.
He states that the steering group of Bowman’s View has
“sadly experienced incomprehension and wilful obstruction from certain authorities”.
Members will note that the petitioner says:
“Neil Findlay MSP has been made fully aware of the situation and intends to raise the matter at parliamentary level.”
Do members have any comments or suggestions for action? Given that the petitioner has stated that he will go to his local MSP, the issue may well be taken out of our hands. There is probably a strong case to close the petition under rule 15.7.
