The final petition for consideration is PE1647, by Angus O’Henley, on protection for all employees in NHS Scotland. We previously considered the petition on 25 May.
The submissions that have been received from the Scottish Government, the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service, the Health and Safety Executive and the British Medical Association Scotland all consider that the existing legislative framework provides the protections that are requested by the petition, whether under existing common law and statutory offences, or specifically within the terms of the Emergency Workers (Scotland) Act 2005.
The BMA Scotland, however, considers that an extension of the legislation, as requested in the petition, may act as a deterrent, and that a potential benefit of adding non-medical staff to those who are protected under the 2005 act might be to raise the profile of assaults on receptionists, porters and auxiliary staff, for example—although it also considers that that could, equally, be achieved through education. Education is identified by the Scottish Government as a
“priority area of focus at this time”,
along with “enforcement of existing legislation”. The petitioner acknowledges the protections that are available under common law, but considers that a
“specific offence with a statutory sentence … may well deter would be assailants from attacking all NHS employees and volunteers”.
Do members have comments or suggestions for further action?