PE1631 is on child welfare hearings. We last considered the petition in May, when we agreed to write to the Scottish Government and the family law committee of the Scottish Civil Justice Council. The committee sought to establish the cost of implementing digital recordings of child welfare hearings. The Scottish Government estimated that the cost would be about £390,000, with additional on-going running costs. Regardless of the costs, the Scottish Government’s view is that it would be inappropriate to record child welfare hearings because they are not structured as evidential hearings, so there is a risk that to do so would increase their formality.
The petitioner stated in her response that the Scottish Government’s cost estimate seems to be prohibitively expensive, and that child welfare hearings should not be measured only in terms of costs. The petitioner also highlighted that child welfare hearings are recorded at the proof stage and questioned why that could not be the case for ordinary child welfare hearings.
The committee also sought to establish whether the pro forma that is used in children’s hearings to produce a record of proceedings could be adapted for use in child welfare hearings. The Scottish Government confirmed that there is scope for that pro forma to be adapted.
In its submission, the family law committee of the Scottish Civil Justice Council highlighted that a sub-committee has been set up to take forward work on case management, including consideration of ways in which to achieve greater continuity in how child welfare cases are handled. The Scottish Government is represented on the sub-committee and will provide an update to this committee after the sub-committee has reported to the family law committee on 23 October 2017. Do members have any comments or suggestions for further action?
10:45