Agenda item 2 is the consideration of continued petitions, the first of which is PE1408 on updating pernicious anaemia and vitamin B12 deficiency understanding and treatment. We last considered the petition on 25 May and, at that meeting, agreed to reflect on the evidence that we heard from the Minister for Public Health and Sport and Scottish Government officials, and to consider a note by the clerk at a future meeting. The clerk’s note provides a summary of that evidence session.
Do members have any comments or suggestions for action?
I am struggling to think of where else we could get evidence from. We have taken a lot of evidence on the petition and I do not think that any more evidence sessions are required. The issue is what we do with the evidence.
Do members think that we could take evidence from anywhere else? Angus MacDonald has been involved with the issue for longer than anybody else. Does he have a view?
When I was reading through it, I thought about the extent to which the conversation is now more of a detailed clinical debate. It is not about the medical profession’s level of awareness of the issue; rather, there is a dispute about the right approach. I wonder whether the petitioner has managed to highlight something quite important that is now being looked at. I know that she remains unhappy with what has happened but, realistically, is there anything else that we could do?
I am new to the issue, so I had to read through the papers several times. It seems that the conflict about how the guidelines should look and whether they should be rewritten exists within the profession. The information appears to be there, so the issue is about how it is understood and translated. It seems to be an internal debate for the profession to make sure that general practitioners and other clinicians all understand what is available. I do not know whether the clerk can enlighten me about that. By the time that I had read to the end of the papers, I had the feeling that the petitioner had highlighted the lack of understanding of the guidelines. In going through this work, people had taken the time to look at and think about it, which I guess is what the convener is referring to.
A short-life working group has been established, which the petitioner is asking to speak to. Dr Alistair Hart has said that the group’s work is at an early stage and that a request for a meeting would be premature. I wonder if an assurance that she would be able to contribute to its thinking and its work would be of use?
Perhaps a wider level of commitment would be that the group would take evidence from patients and sufferers and people who had something to contribute, in which the petitioner would obviously be a leading person.
Could we write to the Government to point out that the petitioner feels that none of her requests has been met? She talks about parietal cells not even being acknowledged.
We could point out that the committee is not sure how much more evidence can be taken, but we could ask that the Government keeps the petitioner updated on developments and keeps her in the loop on the on-going work and group work.
Rather than closing the petition now, we recognise that our work is done, to a large extent, and ask that the group will liaise with the petitioner at a reasonable point and that the Government will keep her and the people that she represents informed.
For the record, I pick up your point about Dr Alistair Hart and the request by the petitioner for on-going liaison. His response was that the short-life working group activity is still at an early stage and still to be fully scoped. I would have thought that an early stage was an ideal time to speak to the petitioner, rather than later on. It might be an idea to suggest that to the group.
That suggestion might satisfy the petitioner’s sense that there is miscommunication about her concerns.
Do members agree that we are coming to the point where there is not much more that we can do, but that we recognise the importance of the issues that have been highlighted? We ask that the Scottish Government keeps the petitioner informed and we look for an assurance from the group that it would want a discussion with the petitioner. Angus MacDonald makes a strong point that a discussion would be useful and valuable at the early stage.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.