PE1646, by Caroline Hayes, is on drinking water supplies in Scotland. We first considered the petition on 25 May, when we agreed to write to the Scottish Government, Scottish Water, the Drinking Water Quality Regulator, the Scottish Environment Protection Agency, NHS Highland and the Water Industry Commission for Scotland. It is encouraging that they have all provided submissions, which are included in our meeting papers.
The committee sought to establish whether the protocols in the regulatory regime are sufficiently robust, and whether there is any conflict of interests in the regime. The submissions clarify responsibilities under the framework and say that there is no conflict of interests. The Drinking Water Quality Regulator’s submission included a background note on the specific local issue that led to submission of the petition.
In response to our request for comments on the concerns that are raised in the petition about potential health impacts, NHS Highland provided a summary report of the local investigation that was conducted by its health protection team. The summary report identifies “anecdotal opinion” of an increase in health impacts, for example skin complaints, but notes that there is a
“lack of evidence of any increased prevalence”.
The petitioner reiterates in her submission concerns about disinfectant by-products that are associated with chloramination, and asks how Scottish Water monitors those by-products.
We have had a substantial response from the various groups and people to whom we wrote. Do members have any comments or suggestions for further action?