Some of the points that I was going to make have been made by Malcolm Chisholm. I am particularly concerned that, if we are to produce a stage 1 or stage 2 report, we should have time scales that we must work to. We must know when that work must be completed, so that we will have an idea of when it must be submitted to either the lead committee or the ministers. I am confused about when that is meant to happen.In pulling together the evidence that we have received, we must move quite quickly. The issue of monitoring statistics, and having a schedule for that, was raised today. The Commission for Racial Equality has offered to assist us with that, and the question is whether we should accept that assistance. If we produce a report, we may make reference to that, but if we do not submit what we want to have included in the report, we may lose out. We need time to return to organisations, to ask whether they can consider issues and get back to us with ideas of what they want to be included in our report. I would welcome an opportunity, early in the new year, to sit down and consider the evidence that we have received, so that we can prioritise the areas in which we may require further assistance.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Michael Matheson only · show everyone- Kate Maclean Lab 21
- Shona Robison SNP 7
- Michael Matheson SNP 7
- Malcolm Chisholm Lab 6
- Tommy Sheridan SSP 3
- Martin Verity Committee Clerk 3
- Johann Lamont Lab 3
- Marilyn Livingstone Lab 3
- Michael McMahon Lab 2
- Jamie McGrigor Con 1
Michael Matheson’s contributions
7 contributionsThe committee cannot operate in a political vacuum of Scottish Parliament business. Most issues are reserved matters and we will have to react to events at Westminster. For example, Disability Scotland and the Scottish Trades Union Congress gave a presentation on the disability rights commission. Those organisations are concerned about the Scottish representation on that issue, and, although we have no control over that area, they wanted the committee to examine that specific issue. The majority of disability matters touch on issues that are very often reserved. Although we can try to prioritise issues that relate to the legislative programme, we cannot operate in a vacuum and kid ourselves that we can ignore decisions that will be taken at Westminster.
There is no doubt about that.
No one is disputing that. However, we have to recognise that decisions taken at Westminster will have a clear impact on the issue of equality in Scotland and that the committee has a responsibility to examine such matters. For example, the CRE in Scotland is concerned that the Race Relations Act 1976 has not been changed and has key recommendations on that issue. There is no time to deal with that at Westminster, but there is time here to do so. We have to investigate such issues when necessary.
I do not think that that should happen either, but the fact should be recognised.
There is a slight problem for the reporters groups. The disability reporters group asked for organisations to be brought to the committee to give evidence. The problem is finding time for that. Should we pick up other issues and bring more information to the committee? Or should the reporters groups go to meet organisations? That has to be clarified if we are to meet fortnightly. Because we want to hear evidence on a large number of issues, it could take some time to get to the evidence.
We should keep the issue in mind when we deal with timetabling.
In this meeting
Everything on 14 Dec 1999 →- Scottish Parliament Equal Opportunities Committee Tuesday 14 December 1999 (Morning) Committee business · 2
- “Improving our Schools” Committee business · 44
- Work Programme Procedure · 56
- Social Partnerships and Research Needs Committee business · 10
- Progress Reports Evidence session · 91
- Correspondence Committee business · 15
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.