Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Tuesday 14 December 1999 Equal Opportunities Committee Procedure 56 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Showing Kate Maclean only · show everyone

Kate Maclean’s contributions

21 contributions
Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

We now move to our next item. All members have a copy of the work programme report that was sent out last week. Do members have any initial questions on that report? We have received many requests from members to hear briefings from various organisations, and it has been difficult to keep up with the legislative timetable. We thought that it would be a good idea to get a firm idea, at this meeting, of whom we are going to hear briefings from and in what order we will deal with issues.

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

That would cause me no difficulty, but it is up to the committee to decide what it wants.

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

I asked the clerks to go through the minutes and record all the outstanding briefings. I was not aware that there were any others.

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

I have requested that the Equal Opportunities Committee be formally slotted into the consultation process. At the moment, it is not, and it is difficult for us to get a timetable. We are dependent on the good will of other committees to let us go and give evidence. We are not slotted in formally. I hope that a report about that will be brought back to the next conveners meeting, which would make things much easier for us, as we would be notified at the same time as lead committees or other committees that are notified. We must bash on with education. We are not the lead committee, but we will have to get all the stuff together. The only experience I have of producing such a report is from the Justice and Home Affairs Committee, in which there was a discussion on all the evidence that we had received. A draft report was then produced, which was discussed a couple of times before we eventually came up with the report that was to be published. That is the way in which this committee should proceed. Our report should be given directly either to Parliament or to the lead committee. As the situation is still not clear, we must proceed on that basis, on education, so that we can feed in at stage 1 rather than wait any longer. I hope that that will be done early in the new year. You are right that the process has been patchy, and that it is difficult to see how we fit into it. We missed stage 1 of the Adults with Incapacity (Scotland) Bill, although Malcolm Chisholm is right—the main point that we wanted to make was fed in anyway. That was through good luck. We must get our position sorted out.

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

No. When the committee has discussed that, if anyone is to be notified the clerks can do that.

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

I do not think that that was what Shona Robison was suggesting. Was that what you were suggesting?

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

I ask Johann Lamont to speak, as she has been waiting for a while. I will then allow other members to rejoin the debate.

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

We are reacting, Shona, to the evidence that we took initially from the main equality organisations on their priorities.

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

I would have to look back at the minutes, but I do not think that those issues were raised as being among the major concerns of most of the organisations.

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

I said earlier that that would come back to the committee and that we would then produce a draft report.

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

If committee members are happy to have longer meetings, we can fit two or three evidence sessions into one meeting to cover specific committee issues as well as everything that relates to the legislative programme. That is not a problem.

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

Although equality legislation is a reserved matter, we still have a lot of power to change things. I would have thought it far more important for the committee to suggest amendments in Scottish legislation that address the problems of discrimination in all groups.

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

At a conference that Nora Radcliffe and I attended in Edinburgh, the lesbian and gay community made it clear that it is very happy about such issues as Jim Wallace's statement on the Adults with Incapacity (Scotland) Bill and with some of the steps that the Parliament has taken on section 28 of the Local Government Act 1988.

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

I am not saying that we should not do that, only that it should not dominate our programme.

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

We will come to some agreement on at least the first few meetings. Shona, you wanted to raise the issue of the frequency of meetings?

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

Some groups that have requested to be heard by the committee are still outstanding. It would be fairer to them if we could at least—

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

Some have been waiting for quite a while.

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

I am happy with that. Is there anything else that members want to slot in on 1 February? The meeting on 18 January will be entirely taken up by our consideration of bills, which will probably take up some time on 1 February as well.

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

We might have the information by then.

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

At least we know what we are doing in the first two meetings of the year.I will ask the clerk to write to organisations that are waiting to give briefings to the committee. I know that the City of Edinburgh Lesbian Gay Bisexual and Transgender Community Safety Forum wants to come. I spoke to someone from that group on Saturday. We should write to them to say that they will be called to give evidence at an appropriate time.Are we agreed that our agenda for 1 February should include the equality unit, the Scottish Human Rights Centre and the education bill?Members indicated agreement.

Kate Maclean Lab The Convener · Dundee West
link

We will have a timetable by the first week in January. The reporters groups are unlikely to meet more than once before then. I have no problem with the reporters groups meeting anyone they want to and reporting to the committee when there is time.

  1. Scottish Parliament Equal Opportunities Committee Tuesday 14 December 1999 (Morning) Committee business · 2
  2. “Improving our Schools” Committee business · 44
  3. Work Programme Procedure · 56
  4. Social Partnerships and Research Needs Committee business · 10
  5. Progress Reports Evidence session · 91
  6. Correspondence Committee business · 15

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.