Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Tuesday 14 December 1999 Equal Opportunities Committee Procedure 56 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Showing Johann Lamont only · show everyone

Johann Lamont’s contributions

3 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

We can easily balance both the matters that we believe are important and the matters that we absolutely must address. If a clear timetable is laid out for us of the matters that we must address, and there are spaces, we might fit in other matters as soon as we can. Malcolm Chisholm is right in saying that we should have more idea of what we are going to address at each meeting. That would free up space to include, as early as possible, issues such as that which Shona Robison has mentioned.The committee must not only listen to evidence; it must be seen to use that evidence in some way. It would dangerously undermine the committee if it looked as though organisations were always coming to give us information, but there was no consequence of that. I was disappointed—and I say this to our SNP colleagues here—that the equalities debate focused on what this committee could not do and on its weaknesses. We all agree that this committee can do very positive things. We are charged with ensuring that what we can do will be as effective as possible and that any weaknesses, such as not having a timetable or not being clearly slotted into a structure, are addressed. We must ensure that we lock ourselves into the formal system so that the kinds of deadlines that we have missed in the past will not be missed again. If we are going to meet only once a fortnight, we must accept that our meetings will be very full, and we must make a commitment to a full morning's work.We will have to consider formally how the work of the sub-groups can be fed back to the committee. In the sub-group on women, we have discussed what we will do with the information that we have gathered on women as offenders and on women as vulnerable witnesses in the justice system. Committee members may want to wait until I can give a fuller report, but we should recognise that that work has to tie into the work of the committee at some stage. The committee should hear more than just a brief report.To give a good example, Professor Sheila McLean of Glasgow University has produced a report on the whole issue of women offenders, and I feel that the committee, and not just the sub-group, should have the chance to explore those issues with her. We will need to decide when to do that. The best time may be during the meeting on violence against women, which could then be linked to the question of justice. We must be aware that the meetings of sub-groups have a purpose, which is to pull information together in the medium term and to go to the appropriate places where work can be done. The work of the sub-groups should not be allowed to drift.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

It is not particularly helpful to get into a debate about the limits of what the committee can do. That will only undermine our work. One of the big lessons of mainstreaming is that equality issues should not get discussed simply as a separate category headed "Equality".One problem in the past was that we talked about equality only when discussing equality legislation. If it is talked about within the context of a health bill or a housing bill, or in relation to transport or education, that will make a bigger difference. People who have argued for mainstreaming recognise that. That is not to say that equality legislation is not important. However, we should not be put in the position of focusing on what this committee cannot do when there is a massive amount that it can do. If people have given evidence to the committee, our task is to ensure that that evidence is fed into the system.The weakness so far is that we have not been located at the centre of the timetabled programme. Something should be done to rectify that, and the convener has taken it up. People come to this committee with important things to say. After we have listened to them, we must ensure that we do not simply react to legislation but feed the evidence that we have heard into legislation in a positive way.There is nothing wrong in having the spine of our timetable determined by the legislative programme. However, alongside that we should be working in areas in which we may be arguing the case for legislation to be brought forward at a later stage. That is part of our role. Although we do not initiate legislation, we can suggest it to bodies, such as the Justice and Home Affairs Committee, which can. We can also influence the Executive to add legislation to its programme.This timetable is designed to ensure that we do what we can as efficiently as possible, that we do things when we have to and that the broader issues that Shona Robison was talking about slot in alongside that work. It is wrong to say that we must choose one or the other. We accept that issues can be bumped up the agenda. We are certainly not in the business of operating as gatekeepers in the equalities debate. We would not exclude people from coming here to give evidence if they thought that that was important.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

My argument for retaining fortnightly meetings is that the sub-groups have an important role to play. We could use the space and time that fortnightly meetings provide us with to progress the work of the sub-groups. If there were evidence that we were falling behind, we would have to revisit that decision. However, I would be happy if we had a beefed-up fortnightly meeting and work was also being driven forward by the sub-groups. I am as conscious as Shona is that we do not want the timetable to slip so much that we are not able to get through our business.

  1. Scottish Parliament Equal Opportunities Committee Tuesday 14 December 1999 (Morning) Committee business · 2
  2. “Improving our Schools” Committee business · 44
  3. Work Programme Procedure · 56
  4. Social Partnerships and Research Needs Committee business · 10
  5. Progress Reports Evidence session · 91
  6. Correspondence Committee business · 15

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.