First, I agree with Malcolm Chisholm. We need more direction, particularly in trying to pull the evidence together. The way in which we have received evidence has been bitty, and it has been hard to keep track of what we have heard and the conclusions that, as individuals, we have come to. We must discuss whether the committee can come to collective decisions, and we should do that early in the new year, before we lose the thread of things. I suggest we have a pulling-together meeting as early as possible in the new year.Secondly, I understood that we were going to discuss the frequency of meetings today. I do not know whether members have come to conclusions on that, but it would be worth while to discuss whether we should have meetings fortnightly or weekly.Thirdly, it would be useful to have some indication of which requests for briefings are still outstanding. Several requests have been made, one of which I would like to see on the committee's agenda before the end of March, from the Scottish Refugee Council. Changes are scheduled for April 2000, and it would be useful for the committee to hear about the impact of those before they are made. I request that that briefing be slotted into the agenda before the end of March.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Shona Robison only · show everyone- Kate Maclean Lab 21
- Shona Robison SNP 7
- Michael Matheson SNP 7
- Malcolm Chisholm Lab 6
- Tommy Sheridan SSP 3
- Martin Verity Committee Clerk 3
- Johann Lamont Lab 3
- Marilyn Livingstone Lab 3
- Michael McMahon Lab 2
- Jamie McGrigor Con 1
Shona Robison’s contributions
7 contributionsThe request was made two or three meetings ago.
Yes.
No. I suggested that we should try to take evidence from the Scottish Refugee Council before the end of March, so that the committee would be aware of the impact of the legislation for which this Parliament is responsible. I suggested the opposite of what Michael McMahon understood: I would prefer to have that organisation's input sooner rather than later.
I would like to respond to Johann's initial point. Because equal opportunities is a reserved matter, I feel that it would be in the interest of this committee to push the parameters as far as possible. If, sometimes, that means highlighting the inadequacies of the current framework, perhaps we need to do that.In our work, we have to strike a balance between reacting to the legislative programme and being proactive on our own initiative. For example, the issue of statistical data collection is not going through Parliament, but we may wish to highlight it. Another issue might be that of refugees and the changes that will come in from April. This committee may take a view on that and may want to initiate something on that issue. I hope that we will not concentrate solely on reacting to the legislative programme. If we do so, we will miss a number of proactive opportunities.
A number of them raised the issue of refugees and asylum seekers.
That is right. At issue is whether we switch to weekly meetings or, as Johann has suggested, beef up our fortnightly meetings and hear more evidence at them. At the speed that we are going, we will not get through everything with fortnightly meetings. That would be a pity.
In this meeting
Everything on 14 Dec 1999 →- Scottish Parliament Equal Opportunities Committee Tuesday 14 December 1999 (Morning) Committee business · 2
- “Improving our Schools” Committee business · 44
- Work Programme Procedure · 56
- Social Partnerships and Research Needs Committee business · 10
- Progress Reports Evidence session · 91
- Correspondence Committee business · 15
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.