Parliament Workbench
Data: Votes to 19 Nov 2026

Vote · 4 Mar 2015

Privacy and the State

Amendment Motion S4M-12491.1 Lodged by Dr Richard Simpson Lab
Defeated by 5
60 For 65 Against 0 Abstained 2 Did not vote

What this amendment would do

This vote was on a Labour amendment (S4M-12491.1) to the Liberal Democrats’ motion (S4M-12491). It was defeated, so it did not change the motion. The final vote on the motion was carried 65–60.

If agreed, the motion would read:

That the Parliament notes the Scottish Government’s consultation on amendments to the National Health Service Central Register (Scotland) Regulations 2006
67 words removed by S4M-12491.1and the concerns of privacy campaigners about those proposals; believes that these issues merit full parliamentary scrutiny, and therefore calls on the Scottish Government, to report back to the Parliament on its response to the consultation before outlining the further steps that it intends to take on this matter, consistent with its adherence to privacy principles and the Local Electoral Administration and Registration Services (Scotland) Act 2006
S4M-12491.1 Labour ; notes the concerns of the British Medical Association Scotland and the Royal College of General Practitioners that sharing personal information registered for health purposes with the government for the identification of income tax payers in particular would seriously undermine trust between doctors and patients, with the result that patients may feel reluctant to seek medical help from their doctor; notes also the concerns of privacy protection campaigners such as Liberty, Big Brother Watch and the Open Rights Group that allowing information to flow between health and tax agencies sets a dangerous precedent; believes that NHS identification should only ever be used for other purposes with express and informed consent; recognises the need for identification of all citizens who will be required to pay tax in Scotland; believes that the current proposals should be halted, alternative options should be sought and that the Scottish Government should consult further, and further believes that any future proposals should be subject to full parliamentary scrutiny and primary legislation.

Worked out by this site by applying the amendment to the motion as it stood after the amendments agreed before it. It is not an official text.

The amendment as lodged

leave out from "and the concerns" to end and insert "; notes the concerns of the British Medical Association Scotland and the Royal College of General Practitioners that sharing personal information registered for health purposes with the government for the identification of income tax payers in particular would seriously undermine trust between doctors and patients, with the result that patients may feel reluctant to seek medical help from their doctor; notes also the concerns of privacy protection campaigners such as Liberty, Big Brother Watch and the Open Rights Group that allowing information to flow between health and tax agencies sets a dangerous precedent; believes that NHS identification should only ever be used for other purposes with express and informed consent; recognises the need for identification of all citizens who will be required to pay tax in Scotland; believes that the current proposals should be halted, alternative options should be sought and that the Scottish Government should consult further, and further believes that any future proposals should be subject to full parliamentary scrutiny and primary legislation."

All amendments to S4M-12491

  1. S4M-12491.2 SNP John Swinney Agreed vote, 64–61
  2. S4M-12491.1 Labour Dr Richard Simpson Defeated vote, 60–65
  3. S4M-12491.3 Green Patrick Harvie Not put to a vote (worked out by this site: never called at Decision Time: not selected or not moved)

How the parties split

Every party voted as a bloc
PartySplitForAgainstAbst.AbsentMajority
SNP 0 64 0 0 ✗ Against united
Lab 37 0 0 1 ✓ For united
Con 14 0 0 1 ✓ For united
LD 5 0 0 0 ✓ For united
Green 2 0 0 0 ✓ For united
Ind 2 1 0 0 n/a

Party is the MSP's party on the day of the vote. Majority is how most of the party's voting MSPs voted.

Every MSP

127 MSPs

For (60)

Against (65)

Did not vote (2)

Lab 1
Con 1