Vote · 19 Feb 2013
Tuition Fees
Defeated by 45
35 For
80 Against
0 Abstained
13 Did not vote
What this amendment would do
This vote was on a Labour amendment (S4M-05652.2) to the SNP’s motion (S4M-05652). It was defeated, so it did not change the motion. The final vote on the motion was carried 67–13.
If agreed, the motion would read:
That the Parliament believes that access to higher education should be based on ability to learn, not ability to pay and will not introduce upfront or backdoor tuition fees.S4M-05652.2 Labour ; recognises the continuing underrepresentation and higher dropout rates at universities of students from lower income backgrounds; notes that part-time and postgraduate university students have to pay fees; further notes with concern that the financial settlement for universities in this spending round has coincided with cuts to college budgets; believes that the long-term sustainability of university funding beyond 2014-15 needs to be addressed; recognises that maintaining the funding of Scotland's universities could lead to cuts elsewhere; rejects the funding model prevailing in England; notes that the report of the Scottish Government-commissioned Independent Budget Review Panel stated that 'a debate needs to be had on whether those who can afford to pay might be invited to do so, thus allowing better targeting of those in most need'; supports the view of the Commission on the Future Delivery of Public Services that 'contentious issues must be considered openly and transparently, rather than in the current polarised terms', and supports the establishment of an independent commission on further and higher education in Scotland.
Worked out by this site by applying the amendment to the motion as lodged. It is not an official text.
The amendment as lodged
leave out from “and will” to end and insert "; recognises the continuing underrepresentation and higher dropout rates at universities of students from lower income backgrounds; notes that part-time and postgraduate university students have to pay fees; further notes with concern that the financial settlement for universities in this spending round has coincided with cuts to college budgets; believes that the long-term sustainability of university funding beyond 2014-15 needs to be addressed; recognises that maintaining the funding of Scotland's universities could lead to cuts elsewhere; rejects the funding model prevailing in England; notes that the report of the Scottish Government-commissioned Independent Budget Review Panel stated that 'a debate needs to be had on whether those who can afford to pay might be invited to do so, thus allowing better targeting of those in most need'; supports the view of the Commission on the Future Delivery of Public Services that 'contentious issues must be considered openly and transparently, rather than in the current polarised terms', and supports the establishment of an independent commission on further and higher education in Scotland."
All amendments to S4M-05652
- S4M-05652.2 Labour Hugh Henry Defeated vote, 35–80
- S4M-05652.1 Conservative Liz Smith Defeated vote, 13–102
How the parties split
Every party voted as a bloc| Party | Split | For | Against | Abst. | Absent | Majority |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SNP | 0 | 60 | 0 | 5 | ✗ Against united | |
| Lab | 35 | 0 | 0 | 2 | ✓ For united | |
| Con | 0 | 13 | 0 | 2 | ✗ Against united | |
| LD | 0 | 4 | 0 | 1 | ✗ Against united | |
| Green | 0 | 2 | 0 | 0 | ✗ Against united | |
| Ind | 0 | 1 | 0 | 3 | n/a |
Party is the MSP's party on the day of the vote. Majority is how most of the party's voting MSPs voted.
Every MSP
128 MSPsFor (35)
Lab 35
- Jackie Baillie
- Claire Baker
- Richard Baker
- Jayne Baxter
- Claudia Beamish
- Neil Bibby
- Sarah Boyack
- Malcolm Chisholm
- Helen Eadie
- Mary Fee
- Patricia Ferguson
- Neil Findlay
- Rhoda Grant
- Iain Gray
- Mark Griffin
- Hugh Henry
- James Kelly
- Johann Lamont
- Lewis Macdonald
- Ken Macintosh
- Hanzala Malik
- Jenny Marra
- Paul Martin
- Margaret McCulloch
- Margaret McDougall
- Michael McMahon
- Siobhan McMahon
- Duncan McNeil
- Anne McTaggart
- Elaine Murray
- John Pentland
- Dr Richard Simpson
- Drew Smith
- Elaine Smith
- David Stewart
Against (80)
SNP 60
- George Adam
- Clare Adamson
- Dr Alasdair Allan
- Colin Beattie
- Marco Biagi
- Chic Brodie
- Keith Brown
- Margaret Burgess
- Aileen Campbell
- Roderick Campbell
- Willie Coffey
- Angela Constance
- Bruce Crawford
- Roseanna Cunningham
- Graeme Dey
- Nigel Don
- Bob Doris
- James Dornan
- Jim Eadie
- Fergus Ewing
- Linda Fabiani
- Joe FitzPatrick
- Kenneth Gibson
- Rob Gibson
- Christine Grahame
- Jamie Hepburn
- Adam Ingram
- Colin Keir
- Bill Kidd
- Richard Lochhead
- Richard Lyle
- Kenny MacAskill
- Angus MacDonald
- Gordon MacDonald
- Mike MacKenzie
- Derek Mackay
- John Mason
- Michael Matheson
- Stewart Maxwell
- Joan McAlpine
- Mark McDonald
- Christina McKelvie
- Aileen McLeod
- Fiona McLeod
- Stuart McMillan
- Alex Neil
- Gil Paterson
- Shona Robison
- Michael Russell
- Stewart Stevenson
- Kevin Stewart
- Nicola Sturgeon
- John Swinney
- Dave Thompson
- David Torrance
- Maureen Watt
- Paul Wheelhouse
- Sandra White
- John Wilson
- Humza Yousaf
Con 13
Green 2
Ind 1
Did not vote (13)
Lab 2
Con 2
LD 1