Parliament Workbench
Data: Votes to 18 Nov 2026

Vote · 30 Nov 2011

Public Sector Pensions

Amendment Motion S4M-01440.1 Lodged by Gavin Brown Con
Defeated by 46
18 For 64 Against 0 Abstained 46 Did not vote

What this amendment would do

This vote was on a Conservative amendment (S4M-01440.1) to the SNP’s motion (S4M-01440). It was defeated, so it did not change the motion. The final vote on the motion was carried 63–18.

If agreed, the motion would read:

That the Parliament recognises and appreciates the valuable work done by Scotland's public sector workers; notes the importance of pensions that are affordable, sustainable and fair
140 words removed by S4M-01440.1and believes that long-term pension reforms must be taken forward with consent and in partnership; registers its strong opposition to the UK Government’s decision to impose a general levy on pension contributions and considers this to be a cash grab for the purposes of deficit reduction rather than a move to secure the long-term sustainability of public sector pensions; regrets the fact that UK ministers appear to be relishing the prospect of strike action, which will cause major disruption and inconvenience to ordinary members of the public across Scotland; condemns the UK Government’s threat to cut Scotland’s budget by £100 million next year alone, on top of drastic cuts to Scotland’s budget, if the Scottish Government does not implement the UK Government’s immediate levy on pensions contributions, and calls on the UK Government to reverse its short-term pensions cash grab.
S4M-01440.1 Conservative ; notes that the UK Government’s pension reform proposals are based on the independent review conducted by Labour’s former Secretary of State for Work and Pensions, Lord Hutton, which concluded that there was a clear case for change; believes that reform is inevitable because people are living longer and that these proposals will mean that most public sector employees will see no reduction in the pension that they receive at retirement, that any employee within 10 years of retirement will see their pension protected with no change in the age that they can retire and no change in the amount of pension that they will receive when they retire; believes that these reforms strike a fairer balance between what employees pay and what other taxpayers have to pay; regrets that the strikes are going ahead today while negotiations are still ongoing and in light of the new offer put forward by the UK Government; further notes the Scottish Government’s submission to the Hutton inquiry via the Scottish Public Pensions Agency, which proposes a number of options, all of which would have had the same or worse results for employees and is astonished that it proposes as one of its options a change to a defined contribution scheme, and criticises the Scottish Government for producing far-reaching proposals that would penalise employees while at the same time grandstanding against the UK Government’s proposals for reform.

Worked out by this site by applying the amendment to the motion as lodged. It is not an official text.

The amendment as lodged

leave out from "and believes" to end and insert “; notes that the UK Government’s pension reform proposals are based on the independent review conducted by Labour’s former Secretary of State for Work and Pensions, Lord Hutton, which concluded that there was a clear case for change; believes that reform is inevitable because people are living longer and that these proposals will mean that most public sector employees will see no reduction in the pension that they receive at retirement, that any employee within 10 years of retirement will see their pension protected with no change in the age that they can retire and no change in the amount of pension that they will receive when they retire; believes that these reforms strike a fairer balance between what employees pay and what other taxpayers have to pay; regrets that the strikes are going ahead today while negotiations are still ongoing and in light of the new offer put forward by the UK Government; further notes the Scottish Government’s submission to the Hutton inquiry via the Scottish Public Pensions Agency, which proposes a number of options, all of which would have had the same or worse results for employees and is astonished that it proposes as one of its options a change to a defined contribution scheme, and criticises the Scottish Government for producing far-reaching proposals that would penalise employees while at the same time grandstanding against the UK Government’s proposals for reform."

All amendments to S4M-01440

  1. S4M-01440.1 Conservative Gavin Brown Defeated vote, 18–64
  2. S4M-01440.2 Liberal Democrat Willie Rennie Defeated vote, 18–64

How the parties split

Every party voted as a bloc
PartySplitForAgainstAbst.AbsentMajority
SNP 0 64 0 4 ✗ Against united
Lab 0 0 0 37 did not vote
Con 13 0 0 2 ✓ For united
LD 5 0 0 0 ✓ For united
Green 0 0 0 2 did not vote
Ind 0 0 0 1 n/a

Party is the MSP's party on the day of the vote. Majority is how most of the party's voting MSPs voted.

Every MSP

128 MSPs

For (18)

Against (64)

Did not vote (46)