link
Countless patients suffered avoidable deaths at Aberdeen royal infirmary. If John Swinney required surgery there tomorrow, would he have any concerns? (S7F-00079)
Official Report · Chamber
First Minister’s Question Time
link
Countless patients suffered avoidable deaths at Aberdeen royal infirmary. If John Swinney required surgery there tomorrow, would he have any concerns? (S7F-00079)
link
I would not have concerns, because our clinical professionals are undertaking good work in the national health service across the country. We should have confidence in them to undertake their roles, which carry significant responsibility. I encourage people to be confident in the delivery of NHS services in Scotland, and specifically in NHS Grampian.
link
That did not answer my question. Patients and their families across north-east Scotland are deeply concerned. Aberdeen royal infirmary whistleblowers have been raising the alarm about avoidable patient deaths since at least 2014. Why were they ignored by John Swinney’s Government?
link
On a number of occasions, over a number of years, where concerns have been expressed they have been pursued by NHS Grampian and a range of external bodies. I appreciate and acknowledge the depth of concern about the situation in NHS Grampian.
What I said to Parliament last week and what the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Care set out to Parliament on Tuesday are mechanisms designed to put in place the steps that are necessary to ensure that patient confidence can be at its highest level. I assure Parliament that the individuals that we have put in place have an obligation to ensure that it is the case. The Government will give everything that we need to give to ensure that confidence can be assured.
link
Those whistleblowers were ignored not only by his Government: First Minister John Swinney was warned—personally and in writing—not only once or twice but at least three times, and did nothing. Why is that?
link
Where issues of clinical practice are raised with ministers, the appropriate area of the Government takes up those issues with the relevant bodies and gives the relevant advice to the individuals who have raised the concerns.
On wider questions about the performance of NHS Grampian, the Government has intervened, as I recounted to Parliament last week, on different occasions during the past few years, in particular during the spring of 2025, when we escalated the supervision of NHS Grampian and put in place additional measures to ensure that improvement in its performance was rigorously pursued. That led to the establishment of the Healthcare Improvement Scotland review and its report, which I addressed in my answers to questions in Parliament last week.
As a consequence of all of that, the performance of NHS Grampian and the legitimate issues about patient safety that Russell Findlay raises can be pursued through the changes that we required to be made in the leadership of NHS Grampian. Those steps are necessary to ensure that the issues with performance and legitimate concerns are properly addressed.
link
This is what John Swinney’s Scotland looks like: patients have died, families were lied to, whistleblowers were destroyed and failure was rewarded. Highly paid NHS Grampian bosses were not held to account; they were protected and promoted. Why does he think that that perverse culture is acceptable?
link
I do not, in any way shape or form, think that that type of culture is acceptable. In my answers to Michael Marra last week, I made clear my determination for the culture of leadership in our public services to be one that addresses areas of failure, inadequate performance and, in the NHS specifically, issues that involve patient risk. There has to be a culture of openness to ensure that that is the case. That is the culture that I expect to be in place, and that is the culture that the health secretary and I will insist on in our dialogue with the national health service.
link
John Swinney’s answer is completely detached from reality. Senior whistleblowers have exposed a deep-rooted culture of dishonesty, denial, arrogance, incompetence and cover-ups on an industrial scale. That rotten culture has been imposed by this rotten Scottish National Party Government. It contaminates Scotland’s public bodies. How can anyone believe that John Swinney will fix the problem when he is responsible for creating it?
link
I can only set out to Parliament my commitment to the approach that I am determined to take to ensure that our public services are open with the public and address performance issues so that we can confront them.
If the Government had not, for example, intervened in NHS Grampian to ensure that there was supervision of its performance, Mr Findlay might have a point. The Government acted in relation to last week’s report by Healthcare Improvement Scotland, the independent inspectors who carry out those reviews to satisfy the Government whether issues need to be addressed, and we have required leadership changes to be made in NHS Grampian. Mr Findlay might have a point if the Government had not taken that action.
I hope that the steps that we have taken, first by intervening in NHS Grampian and then by acting on the conclusions of the report from Healthcare Improvement Scotland, will give people confidence that the Government will act where there is poor performance and that individuals will be required to act to address that performance.
Alex Cole-Hamilton now has five minutes for questions and answers.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.