The next continued petition for consideration today is PE1671, on the sale and use of glue traps. The petition, lodged by Lisa Harvey and Andrea Goddard on behalf of Let’s Get MAD for Wildlife, calls on the Scottish Government to ban the sale and use of glue traps and boards in Scotland.
Since the petition was previously considered in January 2020, we have received a written submission from the Scottish Government and two written submissions each from the Pest Management Alliance and the petitioners. Those submissions are summarised in our clerk’s note.
There has been some progress with the petition; the issue of animal welfare has been recognised and professionals have made arguments about pest control. It is clear that people have engaged seriously with the concerns that have been flagged up. I invite views from members and call Maurice Corry first.
Thank you, convener. Some of the detail in the petition is disturbing. It is important to protect our wildlife. My view is that we should write to the Scottish Government for clarification on the action that it has undertaken with the Animal Welfare Commission to give us peace of mind on a possible code of practice to govern the use of glue traps in Scotland, as I believe that that is missing. We should do that before we take the petition any further.
I agree with Maurice Corry. I think that the petition should stay open, because even though the Scottish Government has indicated that it would need legislation to enforce a ban, parliamentary time is very short just now and I do not think that any new bills will be introduced.
Animal welfare is an emotive subject. I agree that the Animal Welfare Commission should be looking into the issue. From what we have been reading, we need to get some points over to the Scottish Government. I thank everyone who has sent evidence to the committee as that has been very useful. If we are going to have an Animal Welfare Commission, we need to make sure that its remit is as wide as possible, and I would like to see glue traps included in that.
David Torrance is right; there is no possibility that any new legislation could be introduced before the end of this parliamentary session. Any new legislation would have to be lodged in the next parliamentary session. I am flexible as to whether we keep this petition open or close it with a recommendation to write to the Scottish Government about including a ban on glue traps as part of the Animal Welfare Commission’s remit. I will go with the majority view, but I am happy to close the petition with a recommendation to the Scottish Government on that basis.
I think that the petition has had an impact on people. Maybe some folk had read about the issue, but I did not know anything about it. The petitioners and the professionals are arguing about whether there is a specific need and whether the guidance is strong enough. I am not convinced, in what remains of the parliamentary term, as to what the Public Petitions Committee can do, even though we recognise that that tension has to be resolved in some way. As David Torrance rightly says, if it is to be resolved through legislation, that would not be introduced until the new session of Parliament. There is therefore an opportunity—I am sure this will happen—for animal welfare campaigners to have conversations with individual parties on what will be in their manifestos on the issue. Maybe that will resolve the issue of whether legislation will be taken forward. That is an area of opportunity for the petitioners.
10:30
My view is that we should close the petition, but we should write to the Scottish Government saying that we think that the commission should look at the issue and that there should be a code of practice to govern the use of glue traps in Scotland and to flag up that that should be part of the commission’s remit.
Is Tom Mason back online? I do not think that he is yet. Do other members have a view on the suggestion that we close the petition but make the recommendation, which I think is reasonably solid, on the question of what the role of the commission should be on the issue?
I totally agree with that. Could we copy that letter to the cross-party group on animal welfare? That would ensure that it would have sight of what is happening and could follow that up for us.
That is a very practical suggestion that I think people would agree with. I will call Tom Mason if he is back online, but if not, we will have to make a decision and move on.
I agree with the recommendation that you describe. I am happy to close the petition, but we need to make sure that the Government progresses the issue in a satisfactory manner.
I think that colleagues are agreed to close the petition under rule 15.7 of standing orders, but we will write to the Scottish Government making a recommendation in relation to the role of the animal welfare commission and flag up to the cross-party group that it is an issue that the committee has considered in some detail. To repeat my earlier comment, there is nothing like an election to concentrate the minds of parties on individual issues that they may want to put in their manifestos.
We agree to close the petition. We thank the petitioners for their engagement with the committee. I am conscious that the other stakeholders have been very rigorous in their submissions, which has helped the committee in its deliberations. Maurice Corry wants to come in.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.