PE1731, which is on permitting audio recording of local government public meetings, was lodged by Tom Taylor. The petition calls on the Scottish Government to amend the Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973 to permit audio recording of all public council meetings by members of the public.
Since our last consideration of the petition, we have received submissions from the Minister for Local Government, Housing and Planning and the petitioner. The minister advises that the Government does not believe that there is a significant risk, following experiences in England and Wales, or that there is any justifiable need for additional safeguards, and that it would be amenable to directing officials to progress the amendment. That is a very positive response.
I am struck by the difference between what a device for recording events looked like in 1973 and what one looks like now. As somebody who had an old-fashioned tape recorder, I think that people would be appalled if we started whipping those out at public meetings. However, the world has moved on so much—the capacity to record things discreetly is significant now, and we all have such devices at our hand. The minister has indicated that there is no reason why the change should not happen. The matter seems simple to me, but I call members to speak.
We no longer need to press “record” and “play” at the same time.
I agree with the convener. When the committee first considered the petition, there was talk about who would be able to record, and about how some councils webcast some meetings live, which allows people to go back and check things, while others do not, which has created a disparity. There was initially a worry about sensitive and confidential information, but local authorities hold meetings behind closed doors when they cover matters that pertain to staff contracts or other sensitive information.
I am absolutely delighted to hear the minister’s response and will be happy to close the petition under rule 15.7 of standing orders. I congratulate the petitioner on their success. There is no need for the committee to have another reply from the Government, but it might be pertinent for us to send a short note or letter to ensure that the Government is taking the steps that are identified in the petition.
I agree with Gail Ross. However, having been a councillor, I know that there is a right to go into private session. That facility is available to councils anyway, so I have no problem with the change.
As the minister said, times have moved on and technology has moved forward, so I see no reason why we should not close the petition.
We have made some progress. It would be good to send a note to the Government to make sure that it does what it has said it will do. It is right to close the petition.
There is clearly general agreement that we should close the petition. We acknowledge the progress and we welcome the indication from the Scottish Government that it wants to take the issue forward. We agree to write to the Scottish Government to say that it is on that basis that we have agreed to close the petition.
We thank the petitioner very much for their engagement with the committee. If they feel that progress has not been made, there is the opportunity for them to return to the matter in a year. The response has been very positive for the petitioner; I hope that they recognise that they have secured progress.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.