Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Multiple Births (Support for Families) (PE1683)

Thursday 17 September 2020 Public Petitions Committee About 09:30–10:00 Petitions 63 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

63 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Good morning. Welcome to the Public Petitions Committee’s 13th meeting in 2020. This meeting is being held virtually.

The first item on our agenda today is consideration of continued petitions. The first continued petition for consideration is PE1683, on support for families with multiple births, lodged by Jennifer Edmonstone. The petition calls on the Scottish Government to provide better support for multiple-birth families, including both financial and non-financial support.

When we last considered the petition in January 2020, the committee agreed to invite the Minister for Children and Young People to give evidence at a future meeting. Since the publication of our papers for this meeting, we have received a late submission from the Twins Trust, which has been circulated to members.

I am pleased to welcome the minister here today, as well as Scottish Government officials Chris Graham, head of welfare fund and winter benefits policy; and Carolyn Wilson, team leader, supporting maternal and child wellbeing. I invite the minister to provide a brief opening statement before we move to questions.

Maree Todd SNP The Minister for Children and Young People · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you, convener, and good morning to you and committee members.

I start by reiterating our commitment to ensuring that all children in Scotland get the best start in life. We strive to provide the best possible care for all families at all stages of their journey, regardless of their circumstances, using our powers to take action to tackle the deep-seated inequalities in our society.

The petitioner requested some insights into what other countries have in place to support families of twins or multiples. However, it is not particularly helpful to make comparisons with one element of another country’s health and social care system without considering possible differences in its economic and cultural context. Within the United Kingdom, some additional support for parents of multiple-birth children in low-income families can be accessed in Northern Ireland. Similar discretionary support is available in Scotland through the Scottish welfare fund.

The Scottish Government is using its powers for a bold ambition in Scotland, as we are committed to reducing child poverty by at least 50 per cent by 2030. In these even more pressing economic times, we need to focus on providing additional resources to those who have the least in order to even out the playing field and create more equal opportunities for all. Many of the benefits that the petitioner mentions are reserved, which limits our ability to adjust them. That said, the Scottish Government has introduced a new Scottish child payment for low-income families with children under the age of six. Payments will be made at the same rate for every eligible child in a household, including those born in multiple births.

Our best start programme aims to provide the best maternity care wherever women and babies live in Scotland and whatever their circumstances. We recognise that women who are having twins or multiples are more at risk of developing pregnancy-related conditions. Those women will receive extra care to ensure that conditions are identified early and monitored to reduce the risk to mother and babies.

It is recognised that twins and multiple births are also more likely to need neonatal care. That can be challenging for parents, particularly where babies need different levels of care. The neonatal expenses fund is designed to help parents of premature and sick new-born babies offset the costs of travelling to and from hospital and subsistence during the first days, weeks and months of their babies’ lives. If they have twins or multiple babies in different hospitals, they can claim expenses per day for each baby. In addition, families expecting twins, triplets or even quadruplets are eligible to receive a baby box for each baby. I am happy to share that as of Friday, 14 August 2020, we had distributed 145,916 baby boxes to families across Scotland.

We have committed £50 million of investment to perinatal and infant mental health services, providing more targeted support to pregnant women and new mothers to improve their mental health and wellbeing. The Scottish Government also provided funding to enable the Twins Trust to continue to offer free antenatal courses to expectant parents of multiples around Scotland.

I empathise with parents of multiple births, and understand that multiples come with additional challenges. However, it is important to ensure that change is enacted based on appropriate evidence and shared principles. We have invested time and directed resource in particular ways to ensure that all families are supported to give their children the best start in life, so that Scotland’s children grow up loved, safe and respected and so that they realise their full potential.

I hope that that was a helpful opening statement. We are happy to take questions.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you, minister. In your submission of 8 October, you state:

“the Scottish Government has not carried out research to assess specifically the impact of multiple births.”

Since that submission, has the Scottish Government taken any steps to further its understanding of the impact on families of multiple births?

Maree Todd SNP Highlands and Islands
link

No further direct research has been undertaken.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The committee felt that there was a mismatch between the response of the Scottish Government and the concerns that were flagged up by the petitioner, specifically on the experience of and cost to families with twins or other multiple births. Your comment suggests that the mismatch is still there.

The petitioner stated:

“Having multiples is a privilege. However, it is well documented that relationship breakdown, high risk pregnancy, financial worries and post natal depression, to name a few, are more prevalent in families with multiples.”

Does the minister agree with the petitioner that families with multiples are a vulnerable group?

Maree Todd SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Yes, I agree. Our maternity services clearly recognise that high-risk pregnancies are a fact with multiples and that high-risk pregnancies require more support and should be identified early, particularly in the case of twins and multiples. Our recognition of the vulnerability begins before birth.

Additional support is provided through the neonatal expenses fund, which has come in since the petition was lodged and is for travel and subsistence costs for all families who have babies in neonatal units. As I said in my opening statement, where babies form a multiple birth and are cared for in different hospitals, funds are available for families to travel to each hospital. The fund is worth £4 million over four years.

We recognise the vulnerability, but we see it as a spectrum of vulnerability.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

That fund is specifically for where twin babies or multiples have problems at birth and is not for general day-to-day living.

You have highlighted universal provision—the baby box—and targeted provision. Why do multiple births not fall into the targeted provision category? I accept that we cannot specifically target families that are vulnerable, disadvantaged or impoverished. However, given what I have already said, if there is a universal benefit and a targeted benefit, there is a strong argument for the need to target multiple births and to cover more general costs than those linked to what might happen in hospital. Just one small example, which we were given by the Twins Trust from a survey that it undertook, is that, in 35 per cent of families with multiple births, mums simply cannot afford to return to work, because of the cost of childcare, which is a bigger challenge than it would be for a single birth.

Although there is universal and targeted provision, will you consider the strong argument for targeting resources to multiple births, because there is a big difference between one child and multiple children, not just at birth but through their early years?

Maree Todd SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Where having a multiple birth has caused financial hardship, our universal services that are targeted at families who are experiencing poverty will pick that up. We do not see families who have twins or triplets as always being vulnerable—we would not describe 100 per cent of them as vulnerable—but for those who face financial hardship because of multiple births we feel that our universal services are strong, and there are specific services targeted at people who are experiencing poverty that will pick up those families who are experiencing financial hardship.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The petitioner makes it clear that there are differences—for example, instead of one pram and one cot, all of a sudden the family has to get two or three. The parents’ capacity to get organised to get back to work is rationally different. That is not about family income; it is about the impact on families. The multiple births were not planned for or expected before pregnancy. Do you accept that the category of multiple births is a strong argument for provision that addresses that issue?

Maree Todd SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Yes, and you can see that we ensure that twins are accounted for in the Scottish provisions—for example, the best start grant gives an extra payment for twins. The Scottish supports are universal supports that are available for low-income families, and we do not discriminate against parents of twins in the way that the UK system does.

Much of the concerns that are raised in the petition—I read and watched all the evidence that has been taken thus far—relate to benefits that are reserved and employment law, which is also reserved. I am interested to know whether the committee has written to the UK Government about some of the differences that exist. The petitioner speaks regularly about the discrimination related to child benefit, which is a UK Government support. I wonder whether concerns about that discrimination might be better directed at the UK Government.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is something that we could look at, but you have indicated that you have not done any research on the issue. There is no consideration of mitigation of the challenges caused by the UK Government system, which has happened with other benefits, or that we could have a different position. The fundamental question is whether the Scottish Government accepts that there are differences in impacts on families and that having a multiple birth can affect families even if they are not on low incomes.

Gail Ross will ask the next question.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Good morning. The petitioner states:

“Improved support would help families be better off financially, physically and emotionally ... encouraging parents of multiples back into the workplace”.

The convener has touched on that in her opening questioning. Your submission refers to Scottish Government measures to support parents into employment, such as the parental employment support fund that will target priority families, but families with multiples are not specifically included. Do you think that they should be?

Maree Todd SNP Highlands and Islands
link

It is difficult when we target our support in Scotland, because our Scottish benefit system has finite resources, and we have limited fiscal levers and limited opportunities to raise taxes and choose benefits. We have chosen to target those limited resources at the families who are experiencing poverty, to lift children out of poverty, close that gap and address the impact that that early childhood poverty has throughout their lives. That is where we have chosen to direct our resource but, as I said before, we have limited abilities in those areas. Questions about the universal concerns are probably best targeted at the UK Government.

Tom Mason Con North East Scotland
link

Minister, in your submission, you said that, as part of the gender pay gap action plan, the Scottish Government has carried out research into

“the barriers that mothers face when returning to work”.

Based on that research, what barriers are mothers of multiples facing compared with mothers of singles?

09:45

Maree Todd SNP Highlands and Islands
link

The research was published in December 2019 and, although it identified barriers in returning to work that are similar to those cited by the petitioner, such as the cost of childcare, it did not look comparatively at mothers of multiples and mothers of singles. It took evidence from mothers of multiple children, rather than singles, which is slightly different. That said, some of the findings are similar in nature. The reason that more than 80 per cent of the respondents gave for their choice not to return to work was:

“I prefer to look after my child.”

Among the remaining responses, common reasons cited were:

“I cannot earn enough to pay for childcare”,

and

“I cannot find suitable childcare”,

and

“there are no jobs with the rights hours for me”.

One of the things that the Scottish Government is doing to transform the early learning and childcare landscape is the commitment to 1,140 hours of funded childcare, which will be transformative for children in Scotland and for all parents of under-fives. It is a universal entitlement of 1,140 hours for all three and four-year-olds, and for eligible two-year-olds, who, at our last calculations, comprise around a quarter of two-year-olds.

The entitlement to early learning and childcare will look quite like a primary school week, which will make it significantly more straightforward for parents of young children to get back into work. Of course, due to the pandemic, we had to pause the roll-out of 1,140 hours, but the recent data and intelligence that we are getting from local authorities are giving us great cause for optimism. When the 1,140 hours are rolled out, it will save families £4,500 per year per child, which is a significant gain for parents of twins, triplets and other multiples.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

Good morning to you and your team, minister.

I must record my interest. I am a father of multiples. My wife delivered twin daughters—therefore, I know the strains and stresses of multiples births in considerable detail. There are challenges, but there are also tremendous benefits in the glory of having wonderful children around you. We learned to cope. During that time, I was made redundant twice, and things were not easy. I had to go abroad to get work to make sure that I could sustain my family. I fully understand the petitioner’s views.

However, if I may say so, I do not think that it is right to say that reference should be made to the UK Government for further support. The problem is in Scotland—we are dealing with Scotland, and not the UK. I therefore ask the minister to address the issue in that context.

The petitioner has repeatedly said that families who find themselves barely outside the category of low income and who have multiples are particularly stretched by the additional costs of having more than one child at a time. Does the Scottish Government recognise that pressure? What advice can the minister give to families with multiples that are not eligible for the targeted support that is available? I do not want the minister to refer to the UK Government, because we are not talking about the UK; we are talking about Scotland.

Maree Todd SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I agree, and I recognise the pressure. I mentioned the UK Government simply because, when I looked over the evidence sessions, in all the videos and repeatedly in written submissions the petitioner refers to child benefit, which is a reserved benefit; it is the responsibility of the UK Government.

The Scottish Government is absolutely committed to reducing poverty and inequalities. For many years, there has been, and there continues be, a strong inequalities gradient across many social and economic health outcomes. For families that have specific needs, our aim is to reduce that disadvantage through the levers that are available to us. We provide additional best start payments and baby payments for births of multiples, and we are targeting the support that is provided through that and our other devolved benefits at the low-income families who need it most, because our highest priority is tackling child poverty.

There will always be people who fall just outside the eligibility criteria. That would be the case regardless of the level at which eligibility is set. We encourage everyone to apply for the financial support that they are entitled to receive. The money talk team provides advice on benefits and grants to individuals who might be entitled to them, and it gives advice on ways to save and manage money.

Using receipt of the UK Government’s low-income benefits to establish eligibility enables the social security system to confirm eligibility simply and securely. We have overlaid the Scottish social security system on what existed already. Different eligibility rules could be established for people in different circumstances, but that would add a great deal of cost and complexity to the system. One challenge is that user research suggests that the more complicated the eligibility criteria are, the more likely it is that eligible individuals will be discouraged from applying.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

I hear that, minister, but the question is about eligibility and funding. Rather than telling the petitioner to go to the UK Government for that benefit, is it not right that the Scottish Government should address the issue in its own country? If the benefit is required, why not take it on board? That must be addressed.

Maree Todd SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I am merely stating that the child benefit is reserved. Employment law and the challenges with maternity and paternity leave are all reserved. Those issues must be raised with the UK Government.

You are right that we want Scotland to be the best place in the world for children and young people to grow up. We are trying to create a universal system. We are expanding early learning and childcare, which supports families. The Scottish early learning and childcare system is universal, unlike the system in the rest of the UK, which is targeted only at working families. Families in Scotland will be entitled to 1,140 hours of childcare, whether they are working or not. That might support people to study and thereby to improve family income. It might provide support to a parent of twins, or to a mum or dad who is at home all day and requires that level of practical support to look after their children. That will be available to them; it is not available in the rest of the UK, where it is available only to working parents.

We are ensuring that the systems that we are rolling out and that we control meet the needs of all our parents, including parents of multiples.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

You talk about targeting provision, but at the same time you say that there is universal provision. You said that we have provided baby boxes for 145,000 babies. Births of multiples cannot be targeted because you target the people who are most disadvantaged. There is an argument about the balance between the two sides. I do not understand on what basis, or based on what research, you have decided that families who are not classed as having low incomes, but who have births of multiples, might not have needs that should be met.

You have already accepted that you provide both universal and targeted benefits. You cannot use “We only target” as an argument against supporting families with multiples. Why is the birth of multiples not viewed as a specific category? Would it be worth your while to do some research into that? You have said that the petitioner says a lot about UK benefits, but she also makes a lot of other points about what everyday life is like. The least we can ask is that the Scottish Government do some research on whether you are excluding a group of families that would benefit from a wee bit of extra support, rather than—as you have done—dismissing them by saying that there is another group that must be targeted.

Maree Todd SNP Highlands and Islands
link

One of the challenges for any Government is to decide where to use its finite resources. In Scotland, we aim to have strong universal systems that support every family.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

How much does the baby box cost per person? That is a universal provision.

Maree Todd SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Universal provision cost £8 million.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

So, £80 million is spent on baby boxes, which is universal provision. Okay.

Maree Todd SNP Highlands and Islands
link

We aim to provide strong universal services and, given our finite resources, to target specifically families who experience poverty. I take you back to that question of research; one of the challenges of doing such research is the very small number of parents who are involved.

With regard to developing policy for parents of twins and multiples, at the moment, in early learning and childcare, we are focused on delivering 1,140 hours. We have already begun to consider a childcare system and framework for school-age children. I am very happy to commit to considering the needs of families with twins and multiples in development of that policy. We are commissioning work to develop it; given that the petitioner has highlighted those concerns, it would be very sensible to commit to giving specific consideration to families with multiple births in developing that policy framework.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

So, we can spend £80 million on universal provision of baby boxes, without much analysis of the impact, but we cannot look at that small number. I would have thought that, with a small number of parents, it is easier to do qualitative research on the support that they require.

I ask David Torrance to come in at this point.

Maree Todd SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I will intervene; I think that you said “£80 million”.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Okay. That is still a lot of money, without any targeting. However, there is, as you have identified, a very small number of people who cannot be seen on the margins but who might need a bit of extra support. I will ask David Torrance to come in now. Minister—do not worry; I will let you come back in.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

Good morning. In her most recent submission, the petitioner acknowledges

“all the good work that is being done by the Government to support parents and guardians as a whole, but multiples births are still at a disadvantage as they are not accounted for in many of the initiatives on their own merits.”

Does the Scottish Government have plans to provide support to families with multiples to address that disadvantage, in addition to the support that the minister has already highlighted?

Maree Todd SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Inaudible.—at the moment, we are developing a policy for school-age child care. Given the issues that the petitioner highlights, I am keen to look at the particular needs of families of multiples, for that policy. One of the challenges is in doing quantitative rather than qualitative research, as the convener mentioned. With quantitative research, when data numbers are low it is difficult to draw conclusions. Different families face different challenges; there is no universal experience of a family with twins or triplets, so it is difficult to draw conclusions about what is required to support them. While we are developing the policy, I am keen to consider what might need to be taken into account. As I said, we are demonstrating that we are listening and that we are keen to ensure that our policy meets the needs of families with multiples. I cite our development of the school-age childcare framework as an example of precisely that.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The minister talks about there being small numbers. Do you have any idea what the numbers are?

Maree Todd SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Multiples are about 1.5 per cent of births in a year.

Maree Todd SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I am sorry; I do not have that number at my fingertips. I can find it out.

10:00

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Why, if the numbers are small, can you not assess the specific impact on families of multiple births? It would not be a massive research programme. You cite the small number as an explanation for why it is difficult, but I would have thought that that would make the research pretty straightforward.

Maree Todd SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Perhaps it is just an issue with research: in quantitative research, small numbers give poor answers.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We are not asking for quantitative research. We want to understand the experience of families with multiple births. Why not talk to them?

Maree Todd SNP Highlands and Islands
link

We certainly do talk to them and we give a grant—

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Do you talk to them as a group, for analysis to gain understanding of the impact? It must be straightforward to have the conversation and assessment, and to do proper research into their experience. Are we seriously saying that because there are only small numbers we cannot do that research? That does not bode well for other minority groups.

Maree Todd SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I am not saying that; I am saying simply that it would be qualitative research and that families with twins and multiples are not a homogeneous group. We work closely with the Twins Trust and we fund it to provide antenatal teaching and a number of other supports. We could work with it to develop research to understand the impact of policy choices and what policy choices are available to us in Scotland in order to see whether we can better meet the needs of multiple-birth families.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Nobody is suggesting that they are a homogeneous group, but there is a specific experience of multiples and twins that would be worth capturing, which is what the petitioner is highlighting.

I have a couple of other points to make, then I will see whether any other members want to come in.

First, you have flagged up your support for the Twins Trust. The petitioner said that a commitment was made in February 2019 to provide funding to support and educate families in preparation for multiple births. Has that funding been released?

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is excellent—that is good progress.

Have you looked at the issue of pre-nursery care to meet the specific needs of this small group of people who do not fall into any identified categories? There is a category of vulnerable children, who can access childcare from the age of two. Would you consider that for families with twins and multiple births?

Maree Todd SNP Highlands and Islands
link

A system of universal provision is available for all three and four-year-olds, and various qualifications entitle two-year-old children who are in the category of vulnerable children to that same provision. That applies to about a quarter of the children in Scotland and, at the moment, we are facing an economic crisis, so the proportion of children who are eligible may increase. I am not considering targeting twins for that particular support. During this period of expansion, in which our focus is on delivering 1,140 hours, it is not possible to add to that category.

However, I am confident that there are already flexibilities in law to enable local authorities to meet the needs of children and families in their communities. The committee heard from a lady from the Twins Trust in the first evidence session about how Clackmannanshire Council had supported a mum with twins and ensured that she was able to access early learning and childcare. That flexibility is available to all local authorities and I would expect them to use it.

As well as the provision of funded early learning and childcare, local authorities have duties under section 27 of the Children (Scotland) Act 1995 to provide day care for children in need in their area, which may have been what happened for that mum in Clackmannanshire. In addition to the duties that they have to children in their area who are in need, they have discretionary powers to provide day care to children who might not be assessed as having need. Local authorities can fulfil their duties under the 1995 act with any type of care that they deem appropriate.

Again, I was interested that the committee has considered writing to the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities on that point; it would be very interesting to hear its view. I could not see a response from COSLA among the online written submissions to the committee on this petition, but almost daily people petition me to dictate from the centre what local authorities should do with those discretions. Usually my response is to leave the discretion up to local authorities, which I genuinely believe are best placed to recognise and respond to the needs in their communities. If COSLA would like to enter that discussion, I would be more than happy about it.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

It seems very odd to me that you think that some things are entirely a matter of discretion for local authorities when there are impositions on local government in other areas and, to use your own term, you are completely “focused” on childcare hours.

I am still not clear why you have set your face against the specific needs that have been identified by this group. You have already said that it is a small group of people, you have accepted that there are issues here and you praise a local authority that is providing extra support, but you still do not think that there is a job for you as a Government minister to identify those families as needing particular support.

Maree Todd SNP Highlands and Islands
link

It is because I am confident that our universal services will support them sufficiently, and where—

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

They are telling you that those services will not do that. With respect, minister, the whole point of the petition is to say that they do not.

Maree Todd SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Where that support is not sufficient, flexibilities are available locally, as the evidence that the committee has taken demonstrates. Flexibilities will be available locally to support—

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

You are saying that families such as the petitioner’s should just hope that they have a local authority that is supportive, because it is not for you to identify this group as having particular need. You think that, if a local authority provides support, that is good, but you do not think that it is a matter for policy or direction at a Scottish level.

Maree Todd SNP Highlands and Islands
link

As I have said, we are working very hard to deliver 1,140 hours with the eligibilities that are already set.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

It is possible to do more than one thing at a time, is it not? You would not say to families with a child with additional support needs, “We are focusing on the 1,140 hours, so we cannot meet your needs currently,” even when there might not be an economic challenge for those families. However, for this group of people, you have decided that you are not going to even research what their needs are or see whether there is a bit of flexibility in the system to support them so that they do not have to rely entirely on local government and being in the right place at the right time.

Maree Todd SNP Highlands and Islands
link

My highest priority at the moment is to deliver 1,140 hours. Our judgments about who should be targeted are always based on need. Our priority as a Government, as long stated, is to target and support low-income families, and we leave in flexibilities to target support for other issues that do not have that identified need.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

But you are not identifying the needs. You are not even prepared to do the research to see whether there are needs among people who are on the margins. Your basic position seems to be that there is not need here and that you will not do the research to ask whether there is need.

Maree Todd SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I have stated on the record that we are more than comfortable to discuss with the Twins Trust whether it is possible to do research that will demonstrate needs. I am more than happy to consider that in future, and I have stated that already.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

I have a question on the back of the convener’s question. Minister, you place a lot of emphasis on local authorities. As a councillor in Argyle and Bute, I did a lot of work with families and the families board. What is the Government’s guidance to local authorities on this subject and what funding will you make available? You must put your money where your mouth is.

Maree Todd SNP Highlands and Islands
link

We came to an agreement a number of years ago on multiyear funding for 1,140 hours of early learning and childcare. That agreement contained an estimate of the number of eligible two-year-olds, which is where the flexibility lies. That was sufficient to cover both those who have a statutory eligibility and those for whom it was discretionary—those for whom it was desirable that local authorities would provide support. I am confident that there is sufficient money in the system to cover that. There is guidance. The duty on local authorities to support children who are in need is defined in law, and I am confident that there is sufficient funding to support discretionary payments on top of that.

My sense is that we have developed strong, universal services that will support all parents in Scotland. Those who are in poverty will be able to receive targeted support. There is a space in the middle for discretionary support, which I am confident will pick up any needs. If I am wrong on that, we will work closely with the Twins Trust to identify that need in the middle and to see what we can do in Scotland to support that.

The petitioner has repeatedly raised concerns about the UK welfare system, which you know taxes me as the person who has responsibility for child poverty, as changes in the welfare system have increased the level of child poverty in Scotland. Where there are concerns about child benefit, I plead with the committee to consider contacting the UK Government to see whether we can fix that at source, rather than pressuring the Scottish Government to mitigate something that the committee appears, in agreement with the petitioner, to believe is profoundly unfair.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Nobody is suggesting that it is one or the other. We are supporting the petitioner. With respect, your “sense” of something is not enough.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

It is heartening to hear you say that there will be support, if needed, for those with multiple births and that that will come through local authorities. For the benefit of those who are watching and who may wish to access that support, who should they go to if they are struggling with childcare?

Maree Todd SNP Highlands and Islands
link

They would usually go to their health visitor. We have strengthened universal services: the health visitor pathway has been strengthened and health visitors will see new parents regularly in the first couple of years of a child’s life. They will carry out formal assessments and will also make informal judgments about who requires support. Health visitors are usually the first point of contact in helping mums who require support to access it from the local authority.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We have reached the end of our questions. Do committee members have a view on how we should take this forward? We may want to reflect on what we have heard before we make any further decisions. Members should indicate if they are not content with that, or if they think that there is something else that we should also do.

That seems to be agreed. We will reflect on the evidence at a future meeting. That will afford an opportunity for interested parties to respond to what they have heard from the minister. We would be keen, as she has suggested, to have a conversation with COSLA about its view of the issue.

I thank the minister for her time, which has been productive. There was a sense in the earlier exchange of correspondence that we were not getting to the root of the issue. I thank the minister and her officials for their attendance today.

10:15 Meeting suspended.

10:21 On resuming—

  1. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 63
  2. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  3. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 16
  4. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 8
  5. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  6. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  7. 11:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
  8. 11:00 New Petitions Petitions · 10
  9. 11:00 New Petitions Petitions · 6
  10. 11:00 New Petitions Petitions · 10

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.