The next petition is PE1699, by Amanda Digby, on the release of murder victim bodies for funeral arrangements. When the committee considered the petition previously, in September 2018, we agreed to seek views on the action called for from a range of stakeholders, as outlined in our papers. The committee was particularly interested in gaining more information on the timeframe for the review of post-mortem examination protocols.
The Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service’s written submission confirms that, following consultation with the Law Society of Scotland, the Faculty of Advocates and forensic pathologists, it has reviewed the post-mortem examination protocols. The review concluded that a complementary consultation protocol that supports effective consultation between pathologists who are instructed by the Crown and the defence may deliver further improvements, and such a protocol was published in October last year.
The petitioner has indicated that she met the Lord Advocate and the Cabinet Secretary for Justice late last year—I was privileged to be at that meeting, too—and that she is “taking comfort” from the new protocol which, as she says, will lead to
“a more balanced protocol for Procurator Fiscal and forensic Pathologists to work from.”
However, she raises concerns that the protocol will result in more homicide victims becoming special cases and that bodies may not be released any sooner than they would have been before the protocol.
The suggestion that the protocol that is used in England and Wales could be adopted in Scotland received limited support from the Scottish Government, the COPFS and the Law Society of Scotland. They argue that there are fundamental differences between the two legal systems and that, in England and Wales, there is no equivalent to the procurator fiscal.
In the Law Society’s written submission, it suggested that there is scope for improvements to be made to the public information that is available in relation to post mortems and scope to explore the role of new technology in relation to the holding of post mortems in order to speed up the process.
When I met the petitioner and her family, I was struck by their courage in taking forward the matter and by the level of distress that they felt families have experienced because bodies are retained in a way that does not happen elsewhere. I think that there is an issue with the availability of people to do post mortems speedily. The new protocol should help, but we should ask the important question that the petitioner asks about how that will be monitored. Her concern is that we will simply shift the label so that there will be more special cases and then we will have the same problems, although we will do things in a slightly different way. I want us to press that issue a little further.
