The next petition is PE1668, by Anne Glennie, on improving literacy standards in schools through research-informed reading instruction.
The clerk’s note summarises the submissions that have been received from Dr Sarah McGeown, the Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills, and the petitioner.
The petitioner and Dr McGeown maintain their position that the training of teachers in reading instruction is not to the required level, and the petitioner argues that there needs to be
“an urgent and specific review of”
initial teacher education
“provision with regards to literacy and beginning reading instruction.”
The Deputy First Minister maintains the position that the Government has been consistent on that issue in acknowledging that there is a role for systematic synthetic phonics in reading instruction, but as part of a wider literacy strategy. There is no indication in the Deputy First Minister’s submission that the Government is considering changing its position on the matter.
Do members have any comments or suggestions for action?
We do not have the capacity to know whether the balance is right, but there is a question about the extent to which initial teacher education provides training on how to teach reading. We might want to flag up to the Education and Skills Committee that it might want to look at that as part of its broader work on initial teacher education. We do not have the capacity to make a decision on the professional or educational arguments, but whether we are getting the balance right in giving teachers the confidence to teach reading with phonics may be an issue. I am interested in members’ views on referring the petition to the Education and Skills Committee, which could at least have it sitting there. Education Scotland, colleges and universities are in front of that committee at various times of the year, so the issue could be flagged up then.
