Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

In Care Survivors Service (PE1596)

Thursday 27 June 2019 Public Petitions Committee About 09:00–09:45 Petitions 95 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

95 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The first continued petition is PE1596, by Paul Anderson, on the In Care Survivors Service Scotland. The note by the clerk summarises our previous consideration of the petition, which was in May 2018, and refers to a recent submission from Wellbeing Scotland. Members have a copy of a submission from the petitioner that was received earlier this week.

This morning, we will take evidence from representatives of Future Pathways. I welcome Flora Henderson and Shona MacGregor—thank you for attending. You have an opportunity to provide a brief opening statement of no more than five minutes, after which we will move to questions from the committee.

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

Thank you for the invitation to offer evidence with respect to the petition. It has been a privilege to be involved in this piece of work and I am pleased to be here today.

In 2016, an alliance of four organisations was established to deliver a five-year £13.5 million support fund for people who were abused or neglected as children in care in Scotland. When Future Pathways was set up three years ago, no one knew how many in-care abuse survivors there were in Scotland. Survivor groups initially suggested that the fact that it was a Government initiative might dissuade people from registering. As of June 2019, almost 1,100 people have registered. Most live in Scotland, but others live in the rest of the United Kingdom and the wider world.

The impact of in-care abuse is wide ranging and the needs are diverse. We are learning that no assumptions should be made about who survivors are or what their needs are. The alliance partnership and our wider network of partners recognise that. Future Pathways works with each person to identify what will make a difference to them and to agree a plan after exploring a range of options. That co-produced support reflects the best of self-directed approaches and offers choice, control and independence. The 70-plus professionals and services that we have contracted with over the three years reflect the range of needs of the individuals who have registered with Future Pathways.

09:30

As a result of the success of Future Pathways in engaging with survivors, demand has outweighed capacity. A waiting list review was carried out in October 2018, which identified and triaged immediate support needs and ensured that support co-ordinators were available and assigned to everyone over 70 years old or with a terminal illness. We have worked hard to ensure that everyone who has registered with Future Pathways has received a service—832 people have accessed support in various forms and 706 people have had individual support from a support co-ordinator.

A proposal was made to scale up the service in line with demand and to implement improvements, which was considered and approved by the Scottish ministers in December 2018. That allowed us to reconfigure our model of support co-ordination into teams, with increased numbers of front-line staff and increased direct support to survivors. We made a concerted effort to contact more than 200 people, which enabled the immediate identification of needs and everyone to be allocated to a support co-ordination team. Those efforts have driven down the waiting list for a named support co-ordinator to 44 people. That is in the context of continued registrations of approximately 40 new people each month.

Now, when someone contacts Future Pathways to register, they speak to a support co-ordinator. That usually happens within a week and often immediately, which enables identification of needs and risk and prioritisation. Going forward, we expect that no one will wait for more than one month for a service. Work is under way to implement further improvements around the framework for discretionary fund purchases, engagement activity and other processes.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you.

You talked about waiting lists. Wellbeing Scotland’s recent submission of 21 June refers to the current Future Pathways waiting list as being “dangerously long”. How do you respond to that comment? I hear the figures that you have mentioned but, once somebody has made the first contact, how long is it before they have a meaningful contact that identifies need?

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

If we are able to contact someone immediately, that conversation will begin immediately. We have sometimes struggled to contact people and, if we cannot get in touch with someone, it is difficult to assess their needs and respond.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Do you accept that the waiting list is “dangerously long”?

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

That does not match the experience of Future Pathways or the improvements that we have made in the past six months.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Why did Wellbeing Scotland say that that was its view on 21 June? What was that informed by?

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

It is a subjective view based on the experience of people who Wellbeing Scotland may be talking to, but it is not borne out by our evidence or our experience of offering the service.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The first contact is simply to identify the person. How long might someone have to wait until there is a meaningful outcome? You could make initial contact with the people on a waiting list and then nothing happens for months. Have you looked at that?

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

The first contact is when the detailed structured conversation is offered. The only reason why it would not happen would be if the person chose not to have that conversation at that time or wished to reschedule for a different time.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Are the support co-ordinators trauma informed? Is that part of their training?

Shona MacGregor Future Pathways
link

I highlight that the members of our team are recruited from a wide range of backgrounds, including social work, health and counselling. We have a robust introduction period, which includes training on trauma-informed practices. Our team is very experienced in dealing with people who have such experiences.

On the point about what happens when people first make contact with us, as Flora Henderson said, we have changed our process so that people have those meaningful conversations right from the beginning. That helps us to identify needs and quickly provide support when it is required. In fact, it can be on the same day if referrals are made or support is put in place from other providers.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Wellbeing Scotland claims that it has

“offered to support clients on the waiting list”

but that that has not happened. What is your response to that?

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

The needs of survivors are diverse and cannot be assumed. Implicit in that statement is the assumption that we are offering something similar. Future Pathways looks into what someone needs and responds to those needs. Specialist support or, indeed, support to do with psychological problems and service does not apply to everyone who chooses to register with Future Pathways.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

There may be people that Wellbeing Scotland could help, in order to address the waiting list, but that support is not offered—you do not direct people towards Wellbeing Scotland.

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

We have worked very hard with Wellbeing Scotland to make sure that support to survivors is not disrupted. Our relationship with Wellbeing Scotland began on the basis of ensuring that the support to 134 people was maintained. I want the committee to know that Future Pathways has funded Wellbeing Scotland a total of £819,000 to ensure that that continued support is available. Under the arrangement, support has been made available to at least 326 people, which is over and above the original number identified to us.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

You have just answered my question in part. How many referrals for counselling, advocacy, informal support, groups and access to records—excluding the redress scheme—have been made to Wellbeing Scotland since Future Pathways was created in 2016?

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

Future Pathways is making referrals to Wellbeing Scotland, but the referrals may or may not be in line with expectations. A total of 28 referrals have been made for record searches. As the committee will know from its previous submission, Wellbeing Scotland has not felt able to sign up to our current contractual arrangements with providers.

We are anticipating that we will have an opportunity to meet the board of Wellbeing Scotland, to work through the difficulties, and we are keen to ensure that a way opens up for us to have a more normalised working arrangement that is good for both of us.

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

Yes.

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

August.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

How many referrals have been made to other service providers since 2016?

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

We have worked with more than 70 professionals and organisations, and 326 people were supported in total.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

Good morning. How many Future Pathways clients are or have been clients of Wellbeing Scotland and have been referred to Future Pathways by Wellbeing Scotland?

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

Ninety-five. We ask the committee to bear in mind that not everyone chooses to disclose where they found out about Future Pathways.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Good morning. Wellbeing Scotland suggests that Future Pathways is excluding it

“when recommending counselling service to clients”.

It suggests that that exclusion is in order to

“promote a private counselling ... service without an evidence base.”

I thought that I would give you an opportunity to respond to that.

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

Thank you. We do not recognise that description. Any referral to counselling is based on the preferences of the individual, who may already be in a therapeutic relationship. It is also based on geography—that is, what services are available locally—and, critically, evidence of appropriate quality standards, such as accreditation with or membership of the appropriate governing body.

We have had difficulties agreeing a contract basis for referrals. We would like to resolve those, so that referrals can be smoother in future

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

You will recognise that Wellbeing Scotland’s assertion leads us to believe that—you have confirmed this yourself—the relationship between Future Pathways and Wellbeing Scotland is not all that it could be. In its submission of April 2018, Wellbeing Scotland described the funding arrangements as

“an ongoing unstable situation and we feel that we are in a subservient power dynamic with Future Pathways.”

There is obviously an issue between the two bodies at the moment. How will that be resolved? At the end of the day, that would benefit the patient.

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

I think that that needs to be resolved through collaboration and dialogue, and Future Pathways is committed to that. I suggest that the special arrangements that we have made to ensure that funding is not disrupted indicate good will on our part and a wish to do our very best to resolve the issue. I am hopeful that continued conversation between the board of Wellbeing Scotland and our alliance leadership team will provide a way of unlocking the issue.

Wellbeing Scotland has referenced a bureaucratic approach and excessive reporting. Work is under way to find an alternative way forward that is in line with good practice and meets our need to evidence the use of public funds and the purchase of services.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Obviously, two parties are involved. What is Wellbeing Scotland’s involvement in the process that is now in train?

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

It would be as equal partners. Our board and its board are meeting together with the intention of resolving the issues.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

I am sure that we all hope that a way forward can be found. However, Wellbeing Scotland has raised a number of serious concerns with the Government about Future Pathways and the risk to survivors. The response of Future Pathways was to say that the block on referrals was

“due to practice issues with Wellbeing Scotland.”

What is meant by “practice issues”? Will you provide more detail?

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

The impediment to making referrals has to do with information sharing and making sure that we can effectively co-ordinate a range of resources around individual need. As I have mentioned, we are committed to working through those issues in detail, so that a good way forward can be found. There has certainly been a level of discomfort about how information is shared individually and publicly that has made the special arrangements about agreeing funding quite uncomfortable at times. We are just dead keen to get a contract in place, so that our relationship can be put on a more stable contractual footing. Future Pathways is not comfortable with the situation either.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We have been told that there have been fewer than 10 referrals to Wellbeing Scotland since the establishment of Future Pathways in 2016. Is that right?

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

We have made 36 referrals to Wellbeing Scotland for record searches, and we have—

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

We have funded the support of 192 people in addition to the 134 people who were originally identified by Wellbeing Scotland.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Why is it saying that there have been fewer than 10 referrals since September 2016?

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

Again, I think that the way forward in relation to the mismatch in numbers is a better relationship that enables us to share information more freely.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

This feels a bit bureaucratic to me. Wellbeing Scotland has a proven record of working with survivors in a trauma-informed and holistic way. I have been privileged to meet some of those survivors. Do you think that there is an issue to do with the broker model that is in place? It feels as though it is too bureaucratic and that it perhaps does not recognise the things that can be got through that service. The petitioner has highlighted to us the importance of long-term and on-going support, counselling and group work, which your model does not allow.

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

Our model does permit on-going support.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

How many people are with you for more than 12 weeks?

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

Quite a few, I would think.

Shona MacGregor Future Pathways
link

Out of the 1,100 people who are registered with us, many have been registered since the start of the project.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

It has been suggested to us that people can get a variety of services, such as a block of cognitive behavioural therapy counselling, but that those services have an end point.

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

I think that that is a misperception. We agree support and review it periodically. That is not intended to limit or stop the provision of support; it is intended to check in with people, to make sure that whatever is being provided still works for them, and if it is not working for them, changes can be made, or, if more of that support is needed, that can be arranged. It is not intended to reduce or get in the way of people having extended support.

09:45

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

So it is possible to be supported over a long period with individual and group counselling.

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

Yes.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

How many folk are in that position at the moment?

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

Most of them are. There are 91 people receiving counselling support. Most people require much more than 12 weeks of support—it is more usual for the support to be for one or two years or even longer.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

It would be very useful to have that information in writing, if that is possible.

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

Yes.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I have a supplementary following on from Angus MacDonald’s line of questioning. Is there an issue to do with the difference between the two organisations on data sharing and data ownership?

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

Our board and Wellbeing Scotland’s board need to work through that issue in detail.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I am asking whether the nub of the issue is to do with the sharing of data or the ownership of data.

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

It is to do with sharing not ownership of data.

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

That is one of the issues. As I said, our plan is to meet the board of Wellbeing Scotland, so that any concerns that it has can be worked through in detail.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

According to the petitioner, there seems to be an inconsistent approach with personal outcomes conversations and the in-care survivor support fund. Will you explain what a personal outcomes conversation involves and give us a bit more background on what the survivor support fund does and how it is allocated?

Shona MacGregor Future Pathways
link

Personal outcomes conversations are a widely recognised evidence-based support for people. They are about having meaningful conversations about what matters to the individual, what differences they want to see in their lives and what would help make those differences.

Our support co-ordinators speak to and get to know people and find out what they would like to change and what they would like to be different. Those conversations can go down a number of different avenues. Some people take a long time to recognise what is important to them and the differences and changes that they would like to see in the lives; other people are very clear about that.

I suppose the concern might be that everybody’s personal outcomes should be unique to them. No one person will have the same outcomes and goals in life, which means that no one solution is necessarily available for individuals. Perhaps that is why it is difficult for some people to recognise that they are not seeing inconsistency in provision, but they are seeing support that is based on the person and what works for them. What works for one person might not work for another.

On the survivor support fund, we have the opportunity to access the discretionary fund in a flexible way. When people identify a support or resource that might make a significant difference in their lives, we have facilitated that support in a number of cases. We have had people who wanted to reconnect with education—their experiences had impacted on their opportunity to complete it—and we have offered resource to get people back into education and see them through university.

Another example is somebody recognising their need to increase their health and wellbeing, including through physical exercise. We have supported people to purchase items that would help make a difference.

The support is unique to the person, so this is about sitting down and talking through what would be important to them. It is also a matter of looking at all the available resources that we can draw on—that may be the person’s own assets or those of the community and not just those provided by Future Pathways.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

You are saying that you are giving not only monetary support but other bespoke resources that would be beneficial to that individual. However, the petitioner has been looking at how the need for support has been evaluated. Is there a process other than what you have just described, which is listening and evaluating personal outcomes? Is your process fair? Some people are allocated a lot of resource and financial help; other people are not. Do you support people who are not successful in getting that resource and help so that they understand why that might be the case?

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

Understanding the experience of people who are registered with us is vital, and we are working to understand that through dedicated research and evaluation resource. In order to give confidence about how the decisions are made, a quality framework has been prepared to ensure that there are standards for how our work is approached and that regular monitoring and evaluation data is provided to the alliance leadership team, so that that can be considered and scrutinised. That has enabled the maintenance of quality and governance, as well as meeting the increased needs that I have given evidence on previously.

The work is fundamentally bespoke, which means that determining equivalence is difficult, as what is needed by one person will be very different from what is needed by someone else. However, using a quality framework that looks at how we deliver support allows us to be assured that the process is applied consistently across the service.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Am I right in thinking that you have been operational for seven years?

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

No.

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

Two and a half years.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Okay. When was the framework implemented? How can you look retrospectively at what the outcomes were for survivors before that was in place?

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

We can provide a more detailed response to that question after the meeting, if you would like.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

To go back to the data sharing issue, do you accept that people who are being supported by organisations such as Wellbeing Scotland are, because of their experience, reluctant and lack the trust to provide the level of information that you require? However, if they do not provide that information, they cannot access the services that they had access to before. In effect, you are operating as a gatekeeper on the basis of not getting information that clients do not want to provide to you.

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

Future Pathways has sustained a funding relationship and ensured that support is available through Wellbeing Scotland as requested by people, so I do not understand why that is being presented as a gateway issue.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Do people have to register with Future Pathways to access counselling services?

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

People need to be registered with Future Pathways for us to deliver support.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

In the past, what happened? Was there a fund that supported people to access services and they accessed them? Is the situation now that they must go through Future Pathways to access services and, if they do not register with Future Pathways, they cannot access the funding? Is that right? The petitioner says that, as a consequence of a decision to establish Future Pathways, he cannot get the support that he got before in the form that he wants, which happened to be provided by Wellbeing Scotland. Is that right?

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

Funding to Wellbeing Scotland has been consistently sustained throughout the period, despite some of the difficulties.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

With respect, that is not the question that I asked. The petitioner contends that Future Pathways would not allow the support that he had before. Is that right?

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

I would not have thought so, because support to Wellbeing Scotland has been maintained and its service is available. The financial support is at a level to ensure that support to survivors is not disrupted.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

It seems very odd that we have a petitioner at all then, or that Wellbeing Scotland is expressing concerns if nothing has changed.

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

I think that this piece of work has been complex from the start and there are different perspectives about what should be offered and how it should be offered.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The test is whether, if a process is changed and a service is reduced, that process change was correct. That is what we are trying to establish. Of course you will defend your organisation, but I am asking whether you recognise that the change to the broker model, with you acting as the brokers, has created disruption in the services that were offered previously to survivors.

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

Our evidence suggests that there is a need to help people to get the support that they need from a variety of resources, and our experience is that, when people contact Future Pathways, they can be worried about what to expect.

I want to share a case study involving Maria—that is not her real name. Maria is retired and has been registered with Future Pathways for around 18 months. Initially, she was very worried about being told what to do. Meeting her in her own home—Future Pathways can facilitate that—put her at ease, and she was able to have a unique partnership with her support co-ordinator, which she thought was fundamental in introducing a trauma support worker. She felt scared about sharing elements of her life, because she did not know what the reaction to that would be. Feeling that she was in a safe space and that she had choice helped her to feel that it was possible to make a difference in her life.

Maria’s experience of always being told rather than being asked meant that the support co-ordinator’s personalised approach was a surprise. Another implication of respecting and understanding her past experience and the effects on her life was that she sometimes felt undeserving of the help of Future Pathways.

The theme of collaboration comes through Maria’s experiences. She references her trauma support worker and her support co-ordinator as two very distinct avenues of support who work in tandem with each other. Additional support has provided a new skill—pottery and creative approaches. That was made possible through support from a befriender. Maria now confidently plans her trips to and from classes on her own and is attending a new class. The impact of the holistic approach is that she now feels more enthusiastic about the direction in which her life is going.

I share that as an example that is more indicative of our experience of working with people. We always try to maximise what is available to an individual according to their own circumstances, and we help to navigate that.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you. I have had direct experience of people who have had a good service from Future Pathways, so I recognise that.

I am conscious of the time. Does Angus MacDonald have a final question?

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Yes. I have a small point about finances and costs. Previous statistics from Future Pathways indicate a unit cost of £292 per hour, whereas the In Care Survivors Service Scotland unit cost is £43 per hour. Can you explain that massive difference? Is that discrepancy in the figures sustainable?

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

I do not recognise that analysis and would be happy to respond to the committee in writing on that.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

We have received that information. It would be good to get a detailed response to it.

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

Certainly.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

You have already indicated that you will provide information on the details of other stuff. Will you also give us a sense of how you evaluate your outcomes? You have said that there are outcomes. It would be useful to see that process, as well.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

Correct me if I am wrong, but I think that you said earlier that 91 individuals are receiving counselling services. How many of them are at Health in Mind?

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

At the present time?

Flora Henderson Future Pathways
link

Since the start of the project, 268 people have received counselling. Not all of them will still be in receipt of services. Referrals to Health in Mind have been in the order of fewer than 100 people. Again, I would be happy to provide written evidence on that to the committee.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

It would be very useful if you were able to provide written evidence on that and on the other issues, including the question of funding. There is concern that a new organisation has been established that needs money simply to run, and there is a question whether, on the basis of the figures that we have, it is good value for money compared with previous processes.

We recognise that there are a lot of issues and that a lot of important work is being done with survivors, which we appreciate. We have to think about what to do next. We will hear from Wellbeing Scotland after the parliamentary recess. Do members have any other suggestions?

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Two organisations whose remit is to help some of the most vulnerable people in society are involved. It is obvious that there is conflict between them and that, as it has ended up in a petition being lodged, it is serious. That can only impact on the survivors.

It has been indicated that there is on-going dialogue. I hope that, by the time we hear evidence from Wellbeing Scotland after the recess, that dialogue will have started to bear fruit.

We could also invite the petitioner to respond to the evidence that we have heard today.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Yes. The issue seems to be between two organisations, which are not equal, of course, as one funds and one does not. The petitioner has highlighted his concern that, as a consequence, people will not get the services that they could have got before. That is what we want to focus on.

I thank the witnesses for their attendance. If you want further information, you will be very welcome to it. You will also have the opportunity to respond to the evidence that Wellbeing Scotland gives when it comes before us, which will probably be in September.

I suspend the meeting briefly to allow the witnesses to leave.

10:01 Meeting suspended.

10:03 On resuming—

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
  2. 09:00 New Petition Petitions · 14
  3. 09:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 1
  4. 09:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 95
  5. 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  6. 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  7. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  8. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  9. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 12
  10. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  11. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 14
  12. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 10
  13. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 9
  14. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  15. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 50

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.