The next new petition is PE1663, by Leslie Wallace, which calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to sponsor a comprehensive and independent study of the full economic impacts of driven grouse shooting. Members have a copy of the petition and a SPICe briefing.
The petition background information explains that there is a need for a study of the true economic value of grouse shooting that
“takes into account the latest research regarding grouse moor management and new factors, such as the role of potential natural flood alleviation work in the uplands and fully developed eco tourism initiatives.”
Do members have any comments or suggestions for action?
I declare that Les Wallace is a constituent of mine, and I have had brief discussions with him about the petition and the overall issue.
The petition raises valid environmental concerns. The petitioner has clearly done extensive research and rightly highlights that there is no impartial study of the true economic value of grouse shooting. However, we know that the Scottish Government has announced that it is commissioning research into the costs and benefits of large shooting estates to Scotland’s economy and biodiversity. That work may address the petitioner’s concerns but, in the meantime, we should write to the Scottish Government asking for an update on where it is with its research and then look at the response.
As part of that, we need to ask the Government for the timescale for the research. We have established that the Government is doing it, but we have not got start and finish dates.
Have we established that the Government is doing the research? According to the briefing, it was called for, but there is no evidence that it is being done.
There seem to be a few petitions colliding on the management of grouse shooting estates. We have had one on mountain hares and one on raptors. There are quite a few flying through, and they all seem to be around the idea that the process is self-managed at the moment.
They are also on the tension between large estates and concerns about the environment and the protection of wildlife. It was interesting to hear last week that the mountain hare is thriving because of grouse.
Also, having subsequently had a wee look at it, I have found that other environmental issues are driving down the mountain hare population. The planting of spruce and conifers is driving the ferret, weasel and fox populations, which is decimating the hares. There is quite a tension.
It might be useful to bring together all the petitions and have a look at them. There is something about the unintended consequences and the impact of each issue on the other, which is what I think Brian Whittle is referring to. It would be useful to look at them together rather than at each one in isolation.
We will also write to Scottish Natural Heritage to ask for its view. The raptors petition has gone to what I call the rural affairs committee, although it is called something much grander these days. It might be interesting to ask the clerks to pull together the petitions that have tried to address the tension between the management of the land and the protection of the environment.
Do we want to do anything else on the petition in the meantime?
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.