PE1604 calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to expand the remit of the review of the arrangements for investigating the deaths of patients under section 37 of the Mental Health (Scotland) Act 2015 to include an inquest-type system for all deaths by suicide in Scotland and to include patients who were released from hospital or receiving care in the community under compulsory treatment orders.
Members will recall that, at our previous consideration of the petition, we agreed to write to the Minister for Mental Health asking the Scottish Government to consult the petitioner as part of its work to extend the terms of the review and for further information about the percentage of suicide reviews that are carried out within three months. The Scottish Government’s submission commits to consulting the petitioner as part of the review process. It also explains that, given the complex nature of suicide, there is no target for the commencement and completion of suicide reviews.
Have members suggestions as to how we might deal with the petition?
The petition asks us to urge the Scottish Government to look at what it says. The committee has done that and it seems that the Government has taken that on board. When I read the papers, I thought, “Well, it seems that we have done what we were asked and have had the appropriate response.” I am not sure whether there is a remit to go any further at this point.
Such reviews are complex and complicated, but that does not necessarily mean that there could not be a target. We could accept that some reviews might be more complex and would go beyond that. The worry about not having any target for reviews was the sense that, I think, we got in the evidence that they go on on as long as the process goes on. I think that that is a frustration.
Michelle, you were not on the committee at the time, but the petitioner’s evidence was powerful. Given that it was such a personal thing to her, she gave very courageous evidence, and part of it was the sense that there was—I might be misrepresenting her—no rigour around the process. First, if the person had not been in hospital, the case was not treated the same way—I think there has been progress in that regard—and also there was no timescale.
I was trying to look at what the petitioner was asking for. It threw up other issues for me, but I am sure that we should consider whether we have adhered to what the petitioner was asking for. In my view, that seems to have been delivered.
Can I suggest, whether it is right or wrong, that the earlier petition we looked at on the Mental Health (Scotland) Act 2015 and the independent reviews would, in a way, pick up some of the wider issues here? If we progress looking at how care and treatment are looked at under the act, some of the wider issues in this petition, which are not directly the ask of the petitioner, could be addressed. People could appeal to an independent review body, if there was one. In effect, through the other petition, we would address some of the fall-out issues in this one.
I sense from the committee that we feel that the petition has succeeded in that the issues have been highlighted and the Government has confirmed that it will extend the terms of the review to cover the issue raised by the petition and has committed to consult the petitioner, I think. Those are all very positive things for the petitioner. On that basis, would it be reasonable to close the petition in that it has achieved the intentions of the petitioner? Of course, it would be open to the petitioner if, at some point in the future, she wanted to come back and raise with the committee her sense of how effective that was.
I agree. The only other thing that we could do would be to establish a timescale for the review and when it could come to some sort of a decision. I do not know whether we would be able to get that.
Would it be reasonable to write to the Scottish Government to confirm that we are closing the petition and to recognise the progress that has been made but to highlight the issue about it being open ended? In that way, we would not be continuing the petition unnecessarily.
Do we agree to close the petition under rule 15.7 of standing orders on the basis that the Government has confirmed that it will extend the terms of the review to cover the issues raised by the petition and is committed to consulting the petitioner as part of that process.
We thank Catherine Matheson and her family for bringing the petition forward, recognising that there has been an outcome from it that, I hope, she will find of some comfort.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.