Members will recall that, at a previous consideration of the petition in May, we agreed to seek clarification of why progress on this issue appeared to be slow. The Scottish Government’s submission indicates that consideration of whether speed awareness courses should be rolled out is
“solely a matter for the Lord Advocate”.
The Scottish Government previously advised that the strategic partnership board had invited Police Scotland to provide detailed information on suggested models for the pilot and wider roll-out, supported by comprehensive descriptions of its intended monitoring and evaluation, for consideration at the next strategic partnership board meeting, which is scheduled for this month.
I was a little confused. One of my clients, with whom I worked before coming to Parliament, was sent on a course. When I read this, I thought, “What course was he sent on?” Are there courses running?
I think that the committee got the sense that there was an awful lot of dragging of heels and a lot of stuff getting referred here, there and everywhere in terms of what could be done. I am not sure whether someone can access a speed awareness course, but it may be a different matter if it is as an alternative to a conviction for speeding, like a form of pre-court diversion.
That is what I had understood my client had gone on, so I do not know. The idea appears to be sensible, but we would have to look at the evidence base and the outcomes and at whether it reduces subsequent offending.
We should contact Police Scotland, because the Government makes it clear in its submission that it is a matter for the Lord Advocate, but he said that he would be happy to consider a detailed proposal from Police Scotland if that was put forward to him. We do not know at this stage whether Police Scotland has done that, so we need to find out whether it has done it or intends to do it before we can take anything forward.
The question that I would ask is in what circumstances the Lord Advocate would simply look at the evidence himself and say, “This might work.” A massive delay is getting built into this proposal, even though it seems to be quite straightforward. It would improve outcomes and road safety. I cannot see the downside of it, but there is reluctance somewhere in the process. It may be that the system is overwhelmed with other things. I do not know.
Rona Mackay’s suggestion that we write to Police Scotland is worth while, but I also suggest that we write to the Lord Advocate and ask whether he has had the opportunity to consider a more detailed proposal, because he referred to that in his submission in October 2016.
We should also check what, if anything, is already being done anywhere in Scotland. I know that, in the Borders, we have the young drivers courses as well, so it may be that there are localised things going on.
I think that we said this the last time, but it feels as if this is a pretty straightforward thing to do but, for some reason, it is getting terribly complicated. It would be worth knowing why that is.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.