Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Tick-borne Diseases (Treatment) (PE1662)

Thursday 14 September 2017 Public Petitions Committee About 10:15–11:00 Petitions 84 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

84 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The next petition for consideration is PE1662, on improving treatment for patients with Lyme disease and associated tick-borne diseases. The petition was lodged jointly by Janey Cringean and Lorraine Murray.

I welcome to the meeting Alexander Burnett MSP, who led a members’ business debate on the issue earlier this year, and both Janey and Lorraine. Thank you for attending. You have the opportunity to provide a brief opening statement of up to five minutes, after which we will move to questions from the committee.

Janey Cringean
link

Thank you for inviting us to the committee to discuss improvements to treatment for patients with Lyme disease and associated tick-borne diseases. Lyme disease is an infection that is passed to humans by the bite of a tick. It is caused by bacteria known as Borrelia. The best known species is Borrelia burgdorferi, but multiple species exist, of which at least five are prevalent in Scotland.

Typical initial symptoms of Lyme disease are a bull’s-eye rash and flu-like illness. More serious symptoms may develop weeks, months or even years later if the disease is left untreated. Later symptoms include joint pain and swelling, headaches, extreme fatigue and problems affecting the nervous system, heart and membranes surrounding the brain and spinal cord. If infection is caught early, most patients recover with standard treatment. However, 10 to 20 per cent of patients go on to develop a debilitating chronic illness.

On average, 5 per cent of ticks in Scotland are infected with Borrelia. In 1996 there were fewer than 30 laboratory-confirmed cases of tick-borne disease in Scottish patients, but by 2014 there were around 230 cases. However, the true number is likely to be much higher, because general practitioners estimate that only 20 to 40 per cent of cases are referred. Lyme disease is not notifiable, so nobody really knows. Tests on donated blood have concluded that 4.2 per cent of Scottish blood donors have positive Borrelia serology. That equates to 225,000 people having been infected, although not everyone who is infected has current symptoms. The prevalence of positive serology was even higher in the Highlands, with 8.6 per cent infection in the Inverness area.

Earlier this year, Alexander Burnett MSP—who is here today—lodged a Scottish Parliament motion on “Lyme disease: the need to do more”. In June, in the debate on the motion, Liam Kerr MSP stated that Lyme disease is expected to

“reach epidemic levels by 2028.”—Official Report, 14 June 2017; c 116.

There are numerous issues with testing and diagnosis. A patient may not remember a tick bite. Nymph ticks are the size of a poppy seed and are easily missed. There may not be a bull’s-eye rash—in the recent Scottish study, only 48 per cent of patients had such a rash. Testing is unreliable; in a recent analysis of test kits, it was found that Lyme disease generated more than 500 times more false negative results than HIV testing. In addition, immune response has been found to be undulatory, which means that test results can be negative during infection. There are no tests for two of the five species of infection that are found in Scotland, and ticks can transmit multiple infections from a single bite. Co-infections have been found to increase the length and severity of illness and there are no tests that cover all species of such co-infections. Given the unreliability of testing, it is very easy for Lyme disease and its related co-infections to be misdiagnosed.

10:30

There are also issues with treatment. There are a huge number of uncertainties in the treatment of Lyme disease. However, there have now been more than 700 peer-reviewed papers demonstrating the persistence of Borrelia after antibiotic treatment. Dr Berkowitz, a Lyme disease consultant who spoke at Holyrood in June, stated:

“there is now a mountain of good and indisputable scientific evidence that Lyme disease and its co-infections can become persistent and that various organisms have survival techniques to survive and even to thrive through courses of antibiotics.”

In fact, Borrelia has been found to be one of the most complex bacteria known to man.

The treatment of Lyme disease in Scotland has followed guidelines that were developed by the Infectious Diseases Society of America—IDSA—in 2006, before the recent medical understanding of the complexities and persistence of Borrelia. They have been removed from the US national guideline clearinghouse because they are now considered to be too out of date, and IDSA has not produced more recent guidelines.

In 2011, the British Infection Association issued a position paper that supported the IDSA point of view, stating that a diagnosis of chronic Lyme disease should not be made without “clinical or laboratory evidence.” Without reliable tests for Lyme disease and co-infections, there is no evidence to allow patients to get treated appropriately. Abandoned by the national health service in Scotland, many patients, including us, seek private treatment abroad.

What needs to be done? First, there should be improved testing. A test should be provided that does not rely on antibodies. A commercial Lyme antigen test that does not depend on the presence of antibodies and is described as

“a game changing tool for Lyme disease diagnosis”

is now available in Europe, but it is not yet available to Scottish patients. Also, more testing should be provided for all Borrelia species and co-infections.

Secondly, there should be improved treatment through the provision of better guidelines. Guidelines are needed that acknowledge the recent research showing that Lyme bacteria can persist through courses of antibiotics. The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence has been asked by NHS England to develop guidance on the diagnosis and management of Lyme disease, which is expected to be published next year. If the guidelines do not acknowledge persistence, we in Scotland should develop our own.

We should also establish a specialist treatment centre. We want a Scottish vector-borne illness treatment centre to be established to deal with complex cases that has a multidisciplinary team of specialists in infectious diseases, immunology, functional medicine and nutrition. In addition, the resources should be provided for research into and development of treatment of chronic tick-borne infections in Scotland.

Thirdly, education should be improved. Consultants, general practitioners and medical students should be taught to ensure that they are fully up to date on the persistence of Borrelia and co-infections and the complexity of treatment. The public must be taught to ensure that they understand the dangers and how to protect themselves. We want landowners to be required to display suitable warning notices at, for example, visitor centres and car parks.

We call on the medical and political leaders in Scotland to follow France’s example in ensuring that the recent acknowledgement of the complexities of Lyme disease is followed by a change of policy regarding treatment and that more resources are put into tackling the condition, which is increasing in prevalence and poses a great danger of negatively affecting the tourist industry and placing a burden on Scotland’s wider economy. If Lyme disease is going to reach epidemic levels by 2028, now is the time to act.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you very much. I appreciate that the issue is personal to you, and your evidence is more powerful because of that.

In your petition, you state that you have written a report for discussion with the chief medical officer and that you met Healthcare Improvement Scotland. What outcomes or feedback have you received from those discussions?

Janey Cringean
link

I got a letter back from the chief medical officer, who agreed with many of the points that I made but did not commit to any change. I also had a meeting with Dame Denise Coia, who was supportive of what I told her and has kept in touch.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

But no specific commitments have been made as a consequence.

Janey Cringean
link

There has been no action at the moment. Well, that is not the case: Dame Denise Coia has met lots of people and has been involved in discussions, I believe.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Good morning and thank you for your evidence. I feel a bit of a personal interest in this. One of the athletes down at the track contracted Lyme disease—apparently, it was down to the grass not being cut often enough at the stadium—so I have a little bit of understanding of the issue.

You said that there are numerous issues with testing. I would like to explore those with you. You have quoted Lyme Disease Action as saying:

“There are no conclusive tests ... currently in ... use in the UK that will accurately diagnose Lyme disease or distinguish active from past infection.”

Are you aware of other countries that use such tests? I know that you alluded to that.

Janey Cringean
link

A lot of the tests just do not detect Lyme disease. There are no markers of active infection for Borrelia—that is part of the problem. The new Lyme antigen test might prove to change that, but it is too early to know.

Lorraine Murray
link

There is another test out there—the lymphocyte transformation test, LTT-MELISA—which they are using on people who are not being picked up through the blood test. It works as follows.

“Conventional laboratory diagnosis involves demonstration of Borrelia antibodies in ELISA followed by confirmation of positive ... results in Western Blot. However, due to cross-reactivity with antigenically-related microorganisms”

such as the Epstein-Barr virus,

“delayed or failed antibody production, or ... IgM persistence, serological diagnosis alone is often ambiguous.”

That is where LTT-MELISA comes into play. MELISA stands for memory lymphocyte immunostimulation assay. It differs from an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay—ELISA—and Western blot in that the foreign antigen part of the Lyme bacterium is added to the patient’s blood and the degree of lymphocytic reaction is measured from that. The bacteria is added, and if there is a response with the memory cells, that is how Lyme disease is detected.

Janey Cringean
link

That test is used in Germany.

Lorraine Murray
link

It is used in Germany and in some places in the United States.

Lorraine Murray
link

I am not aware of the statistics, but I am sure that they will be out there. Certainly all the people who are coming back negative in relation to expecting an immune response are being picked up with that other test because it is more focused on their memory cells rather than relying on the antibodies. You have to realise that Lyme disease and all the different co-infections that people get suppress the immune system. That is what the test is based on.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

You have identified some other issues including cost, the lack of sensitivity of tests and the difficulties that that creates in terms of being used in the market for treatment response. The committee’s briefing refers to the online guidance, which identifies the possibility of false positive results. However, a number of comments that we have received on the petition mention false negatives. Will you comment on that?

Janey Cringean
link

There is a lot of controversy in the area of Lyme disease, so you will read different things in different places. There are different definitions of Lyme disease. It can be thought of as being caused by Borrelia burgdorferi, but there are multiple species, so we need tests that cover the whole range of infections. When people talk about Lyme disease, they may be thinking specifically about Borrelia burgdorferi. There is more information on that, there are more tests and more research has been done. However, patients need more than that, because there are at least five species in Scotland, for two of which there are no tests at all.

It is so easy for people to get a false negative because the tests do not test for the species that they happen to be infected by. That is what happened to me. When I was first tested in 2007, I was told that I had a high level of antibodies but they did not know what it was. I was given a clinical diagnosis of Lyme disease at the Western general hospital here in Edinburgh. I had three years of treatment, at the end of which they said, “You have had the treatment. You have no doubt had Lyme disease, but there’s nothing more that we can do for you, so you are discharged.”

At that point, I was still seriously ill and I went for private treatment. Four years later, I had a positive test for Borrelia garinii. I found out later that, when I was originally tested in hospital in Edinburgh, I was never tested for Borrelia garinii. It was not part of the test that I was given at that time, so it was 10 years from the point at which I was bitten until I got a test result that came up with anything. In that time, I had become too ill to recover.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

To clarify, are you saying that, on a retest of the false negatives, the LTT test will pick up all the elements of Borrelia, including the two that we cannot test for currently?

Janey Cringean
link

We are not experts on the medical side of things, but many patients are being diagnosed using the LTT-MELISA test. When they are tested in the UK, they are not being given a diagnosis, so they do not get treatment. They then go abroad to try to get an answer to what is wrong. In using that test, they get an answer, although it might not be the full answer.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

I presume that the increased activity in memory recognition will tell them that something is going on but not necessarily the form of Borrelia that is present.

Lorraine Murray
link

It depends upon the Borrelia that has been added to the test. They have about 20 different strains and they use the most common European strains. They also test for co-infections such as Babesia, which is a parasite. I got that from a tick and the NHS in this country could not test for it.

Janey Cringean
link

Many tests are not available. I believe that I might also have been infected with Bartonella through the tick bite. I have asked for Bartonella testing to be done and been told that no Bartonella tests are being done in Scotland now. There are also multiple species of Babesia and I have been tested for only one of them.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Do you have an understanding of whether there is consistency of testing across Scotland? You are clearly saying that some tests are not available in Scotland, but is the position different within Scotland?

Janey Cringean
link

I believe that that is consistent throughout Scotland.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Your petition says that the guidelines that are used in Scotland were developed in America in 2006 and that they are now considered to be out of date in America. Please expand on your concerns about the guidelines and why you are concerned that they might also be out of date here.

Janey Cringean
link

The guidelines that are used in the UK recommend two to four weeks of antibiotic treatment. In some cases, they recommend intravenous antibiotic treatment, but it is mostly oral.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

How does that compare with the guidelines that are published in America? Are they the same?

Janey Cringean
link

The guidelines that are being used here are based on out-of-date guidelines from the States. Many doctors, particularly in the US, believe that long-term treatment is necessary for Lyme disease and that it must be treated much more aggressively because of its persistence.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

The tendency here is to stick to the 2006 guidelines.

Janey Cringean
link

Very much so, yes.

Lorraine Murray
link

The research has discovered that the Borrelia bacterium is very clever. It can go into biofilm or into cyst form. It has been discovered that a multi-antibiotic approach to cover all the co-infections that have been found is getting people well, but that is not a quick treatment; it is done over years.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

What would your preferred treatment options be? If you could change things, what would you prefer to be done?

Lorraine Murray
link

I would go with the research that is already out there. Dr Horowitz, who comes from New York, has gone as far as writing and designing symptom checklists for patients and doctors. Purely by looking at those, he can narrow down the chances of someone having, for example, a co-infection of Babesia along with the Borrelia bacteria that cause Lyme disease. That determines what medication each person has—that is how the checklists work.

10:45

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

The process is individualised.

Lorraine Murray
link

In America, they do not focus on tests because they are so up to date with the symptoms and the progression of the different bacterial infections or parasites.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Are there any specialists in Scotland that you know of?

Lorraine Murray
link

No—I am not aware of any.

Janey Cringean
link

Roger Evans at Raigmore hospital has been involved a lot on the testing side.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

However, when it comes to treatment, there are not six top people or even one person who might be called in.

Janey Cringean
link

As patients, we do not know of anyone who has been helped significantly by care in Scotland.

Lorraine Murray
link

Can I make you aware of what happens to patients? Those who have not noticed the tick or the bull’s-eye rash—they might not have even developed the rash, which could have alerted them to the fact that they have been passed the bacteria—will go to their local doctor and it will be missed, because the doctor is not aware of the symptoms or is not familiar with the progression of Lyme disease and might never have seen a case before. I was diagnosed with chronic fatigue syndrome. Every symptom that I had was brushed off. Patients sometimes never mount an antibody response with the current test, especially if the disease has been left for years, as their bodies are overwhelmed by all the infections. Ironically, Lyme disease causes immune system suppression, so it is no surprise that there is no response.

Those people, without positive tests or adequate treatment, are left seriously ill and are often moved about the NHS system without an accurate diagnosis. They might be passed to an infectious disease specialist, but they will be denied treatment because they have not tested positive. What is more alarming is the fact that the patients have all the classic symptoms of the progression of Lyme disease. Unfortunately, they are denied treatment because the NHS relies on outdated guidelines and limited tests, and the symptoms are completely ignored.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

I am sorry to interrupt, but if someone goes to the doctor and says that they feel dreadful and were bitten by a tick, would that result in their being sent for immediate treatment? Is it up to the person to say that they have been bitten? If someone goes to the doctor with the symptoms, might the doctor not necessarily suspect that it is Lyme disease?

Janey Cringean
link

I do not know whether things might be slightly different now from when I was first bitten. I was bitten in 2004—I know the exact date when it happened—and I went to the doctor with a rash and an initial flu-like illness. The first thing that he said was, “Have you been anywhere in America where you could have got Lyme disease?” However, he did not believe that you could get it in Britain.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Were you aware that you had been bitten at that point?

Janey Cringean
link

Yes. That opportunity for treatment was completely missed. When people do not know that they have been bitten and have not had a bull’s-eye rash, there is even less chance of it being picked up.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

On the issue of treatment, you have indicated that you would like the establishment of a Scottish vector-borne illness treatment centre with a multidisciplinary team in place. Will you expand on that suggestion and tell us what you would like? You have said that there is a lack of specialists in Lyme disease, so I suppose that we would be starting from quite a low point.

Janey Cringean
link

The trouble with Lyme disease is that, because it is a multisystemic illness, it has all sorts of implications. Although there are specialists in infectious diseases, that specialty is not sufficient to cover the range of things that happen. The infections can modulate the biochemical mechanisms that occur in the body; therefore, functional medicine specialists are needed to understand that. For instance, someone might need supplementation with vitamins or other supplements to compensate for the things that happen. There are also nutritional aspects. For me, Lyme disease caused a complete intolerance to gluten and I have had to modify my diet significantly to stay stable. It would be really helpful to have specialists who could cover that side of things.

We do not believe that any one specialty has enough knowledge. If you focus on a specialty, you are not focusing on the whole person, and, because Lyme disease is multisystemic and has so many consequences, it would be much better treated by multiple specialties. When patients go abroad for treatment, they get organisations that are geared up for having multiple specialties looking after their patients.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

Have you had much support throughout your journey? You have obviously seen a lot of people over a long period of time. Have you had much support for these suggestions from the medical profession at an operational level, or have they all come from you?

Lorraine Murray
link

There is no support for people like us who have been affected by Lyme disease. If someone does not get better as a result of the couple of weeks’ antibiotics that they are offered, they are just left on the shelf, seriously ill.

Janey Cringean
link

I was discharged from the Western general hospital in Edinburgh in 2010 and told that no more could be done for me. I asked for a second opinion from Glasgow, but the consultant refused to see me because I had never had a positive test. My GP decided that, because two consultants had said that they would not help, he would not help either. Between 2010 and about two years ago, I had no help at all from the NHS.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

You were discharged from the infectious diseases department at the Western general.

Janey Cringean
link

I was discharged by the infectious diseases department and my GP. I felt completely abandoned, with no help at all. I have gone for private help and have survived with that.

Janey Cringean
link

Yes. It exists in America privately and France has a national plan for Lyme disease. Specialist treatment centres are being set up throughout France. It has that model in mind although it is not fully implemented.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

I thank Janey Cringean and Lorraine Murray for bringing the petition to us. Until now, I thought that a Lyme disease test was fairly straightforward. Having had a number of tick bites myself over the years, I have had it on my to-do list to have the test. I did not realise that it was far from straightforward.

The final aspect of your petition relates to education and public awareness. What roles within the medical profession do you feel would benefit from education? Do you have any thoughts on who might deliver the relevant education and on how it would be delivered?

Janey Cringean
link

There is a need for education at every level. A lot of the barriers that patients encounter relate to the fact that, when they reach the consultant, the consultant follows the guidelines. We are abandoned because the guidelines are being followed and we just drop off the end of the treatment.

We would like a specialist treatment centre to be set up that would involve consultants working with doctors who believe in the persistence of chronic Lyme disease. The consultants would learn from them, and other consultants in Scotland could then learn from the specialist treatment centre.

There is also a need for GPs to be brought up to date with the treatment. The issue also needs to be considered as medical students come through.

Lorraine Murray
link

Can I add to the list for GPs? A good idea that could be rolled out immediately would be for GPs to have the symptom list and multisystemic infection table on the progression of Lyme disease that is already out there. From that, they could immediately see whether a patient who had been sick for a few years but had not been picked up was likely to be suffering from Lyme disease regardless of the fact that their tests came back negative. Something like that could be rolled out to all doctors in the NHS.

Janey Cringean
link

There is already some training out there. Lyme Disease Action has produced some training in conjunction with the Royal College of General Practitioners. An online training course is available and is part of the continuous professional development element of general practitioners’ training. However, the last that I heard was that only 3 per cent of GPs had actually done that training.

Lorraine Murray
link

It does not really alert them to all the symptoms of Lyme disease, either.

Janey Cringean
link

Also, it is now somewhat out of date.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Another issue is that urban GPs may not be as aware of Lyme disease as GPs in rural areas.

Janey Cringean
link

Yes. I understand that a lot of GPs in the Highlands are much better educated about it than GPs elsewhere.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

You will be aware that there has recently been some media interest in and coverage of Lyme disease, and there is support for your petition from gamekeepers and moorland managers. Are you encouraged by that?

Janey Cringean
link

Yes. We have had a lot of mentions of support—if not publicly, at least privately. A number of bodies have been in touch to say that they are prepared to provide support.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

What other initiatives or stakeholder involvement would raise awareness out there?

Lorraine Murray
link

We would like to go as far as raising awareness through the National Trust, as it owns monuments and things out in the countryside. We would like awareness to be rolled out everywhere, if possible. I believe that there are now leaflets in the Lake District because someone who suffers from Lyme disease is distributing them there, but there is not much information out there for the public.

Lorraine Murray
link

Yes. We ring up the charity Lyme Disease Action and ask, “Can we have some leaflets?” I then go down and put them in my GP surgery. That is basically all the awareness raising that is done.

Janey Cringean
link

There are a lot of stakeholders that could have input. I have a list of doctors and organisations that might be of interest.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

If you can share that with us, that will be useful.

I will bring in Alexander Burnett. We will then need to wind up, given the time.

Alexander Burnett Con Aberdeenshire West
link

I thank the convener for allowing me to attend the meeting and speak to the petition, and I thank Janey Cringean and Lorraine Murray for informing the committee about what is a truly terrible and debilitating disease.

As the convener mentioned, I led a members’ business debate on the subject earlier in the year. I am grateful for the cross-party support that it received not only from members with rural constituencies but from others. There might have been a misconception that cases of Lyme disease occur only in rural areas, but, as Angus MacDonald alluded, we have been very successful in getting more people from urban areas out into the countryside and that has brought its own challenges. When those people return to their homes, their local GPs are often not aware of the problems. That goes to the heart of the point about awareness and education.

After the members’ business debate, we held an event that was extremely well attended. There had been some IT problems with members signing the petition, and the number of people who attended the event was greater than the number who were able to sign the petition—that should be noted for the record. The event was attended not only by people from across Scotland who have suffered from the disease but by people from across the United Kingdom and abroad who are working to eradicate it by removing vectors for ticks.

Lyme disease should be recognised as a truly global issue, and it is one that we have an opportunity to address today. It is terrible that this Parliament has now looked at Lyme disease for over 10 years. I believe that it has a responsibility both to sufferers and to countryside users. We are encouraging schools, people on Duke of Edinburgh schemes, scouts, guides and people of all ages, including groups, to go out into the countryside, yet we are failing them and, I think, being negligent in not informing them of the grave dangers that exist if they catch Lyme disease.

It is clear that the disease is not getting the attention that it needs. I hope that the Public Petitions Committee will take the opportunity today to address the situation and that, in turn, the Scottish Parliament will take the opportunity to catch up with the many other countries that are dealing with it. Thank you.

11:00

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

In your opening statement you mentioned the development of NICE guidelines and the feedback that you have received from the chief medical officer and Healthcare Improvement Scotland. Has any reference been made to the development of guidelines by the Scottish intercollegiate guidelines network?

Janey Cringean
link

No.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We can pursue that. Thank you for your attendance.

We now need to think about how we want to take forward the petition. I sense that we want to take it forward. There is an issue of responsibility, and the work in this whole area needs to be developed—we have heard powerful arguments for that today. Can I have suggestions from the committee about what we should do?

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

We should write to the Scottish Government, the UK Government and the various interested stakeholders, such as Lyme Disease UK, Lyme Disease Action, SNH and NICE. I was quite shocked to hear that only 3 per cent of GPs have undertaken the training. Maybe we could write to the GP body—I do not know what you call it—asking for a response on that.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Okay. The witnesses said that they can suggest stakeholders that it would be worth contacting. It would be excellent if they gave that list to the clerks at the end of the meeting.

We are keen to progress the petition. Rona Mackay has suggested writing to a range of organisations. Perhaps we can also write to NHS boards, which have to give advice within their own systems.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

I suggest that we also write to NFU Scotland and Scottish Land & Estates to get their views on the issue.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

I do not know whether we want to write to the British Veterinary Association, but awareness of Lyme disease is being promoted in the equine world at the moment. There is a growing awareness of it and people seem to be doing quite a good job. It might be worth linking up with some organisations on the animal welfare side as well.

Janey Cringean
link

The chairman of the Scottish health protection network Lyme disease sub-group is Professor Dominic Mellor, who is a vet. He would be well worth contacting.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

As I said, if you have a list, please ensure that the clerks get access to it so that we can get as much information back as possible.

Lorraine Murray
link

Is there some way in which we could get information from the doctors who have all the research and are curing people at the moment, such as Dr Horowitz? I think that he would be quite happy to work with the Government.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

My sense is that, in the first instance, we should write to stakeholders. You clearly have in mind somebody who is regarded as an expert elsewhere, and we can reflect on their involvement once we know what the medical profession and related organisations in Scotland and the United Kingdom are doing. We would not close our door to that.

I thank the petitioners for their evidence. We will get back to you about the responses that we receive. We will tell you when we will next consider the petition and you will have an opportunity to respond further.

I suspend the meeting to allow for a change of witnesses.

11:03 Meeting suspended.

11:04 On resuming—

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I want to say something before we move to the next item of business.

Our discussions this morning have, to say the least, run over a little longer than we expected, which is understandable, given the evidence that has been given to us. It is really important that witnesses feel that their case has been properly heard, but that has meant that we have less time to discuss other new petitions on the agenda. We are keen to give proper time to considering them as well. In order to ensure that they are given full consideration, I suggest that we reschedule to consider them at our meeting next week. That would mean that we could afford a proper opportunity to discuss the next petition. We have to be finished by 20 minutes to 12 today. Rather than putting ourselves under pressure in considering that petition and not giving proper time and respect to the other new petitions, do members agree that we should deal with the other new petitions next week?

Members indicated agreement.

  1. 09:00 Interests Procedure · 2
  2. 09:00 New Petitions Petitions · 60
  3. 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 36
  4. 10:15 New Petitions Petitions · 84
  5. 11:00 New Petitions Petitions · 35
  6. 11:15 Continued Petition Petitions · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.