In that case, the final petition on which the committee will take evidence today is PE1664, on greater protection for mountain hares. The petition was lodged by Harry Huyton on behalf of the OneKind charity. I invite him to give a brief opening statement of no more than five minutes, after which we will move to questions from committee members.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Mountain Hares (Protection) (PE1664)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Harry Huyton OneKind 13
- Johann Lamont Lab 8
- Angus MacDonald SNP 5
- Michelle Ballantyne Con 4
- Brian Whittle Con 3
- Rona Mackay SNP 2
The record
35 contributionsOn behalf of our supporters and those who signed the petition, I thank the committee for taking the time to consider it.
Mountain hares are native to Scotland and are a conservation priority at the EU level—they are listed in annex V of the EU habitats directive. At the UK level, they are a priority species under the biodiversity action plan, and they are on the Scottish biodiversity list. However, very large numbers of mountain hares are culled and killed for recreation across the Highlands and the Borders—that is their range in Scotland.
The killing outside the close season, which is 1 March until 31 July, is unregulated and not monitored, and the mountain hare population is not systematically monitored. It is therefore impossible to say what impact the killing is having on the mountain hare population or, indeed, on the welfare of individual mountain hares, but we know that a large number of mountain hares are killed each year. The only study that SNH has commissioned found that approximately 25,000 mountain hares were killed in 2006-07. That is thought to be somewhere between 5 and 14 per cent of the mountain hare population.
It appears that, in recent years, large-scale culling has become a routine part of intensive grouse moor management in the belief that it will result in lower transmission of the louping ill virus to red grouse chicks and therefore higher red grouse populations. That is consistent with accounts and photos of large-scale culls, which we have summarised in a report that I have with me. That report, which was published on 1 August, is available on our website.
I draw the committee’s attention to the most recent example. A wildlife photographer who was just north of the Cairngorms national park was out taking photos of red grouse and a vehicle drove past him. He took the photo that I am showing to the committee, which shows the clean-up after a cull. There are a lot of mountain hare carcases there. The photo was taken at around 4 o’clock on 28 February, which was in the last few hours of the mountain hares open season.
In addition to those systematic culls, it is important to note that recreational killing raises serious conservation and welfare concerns. It involves a large number of animals. Our research found that around 25 companies offered recreational killing online. They usually offer eight to 10 animals per gun for walk-up hunts and up to 200 a day for a driven hunt.
The Scottish Government has made a number of significant interventions, three of which I will highlight. First, in 2014, the Scottish Government called for voluntary restraint on large-scale culls. Since then, it has made it clear that its policy is not to support large-scale culls. Secondly, earlier this year, SNH confirmed that it would no longer permit the snaring of mountain hares. We welcome that as significant progress because of the serious welfare concerns around that practice. Thirdly, on 31 May, the Cabinet Secretary for Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform announced that an independent group would be established to look at the environmental impact of grouse moor management, including mountain hare culls.
Our petition calls for greater protection of mountain hares, and in our submission to the committee we put forward a number of recommendations on how that could be achieved. I hope that they will be considered by the Scottish Government in the inquiry. I would also like to underline a simple and practical recommendation that we have made, which is that mountain hare culling could be licensed by extending the close season so that it continues all year round.
I want to stress the point that, although we have an inquiry, a number of issues are not being addressed, and I hope that the inquiry will consider mountain hare culls and their impact in full—that is, on welfare and conservation—and put forward a long-term solution. However, we all have to realise that it will take some time to go from the inquiry to the point of implementation—the group has not yet even been formed. I therefore want to emphasise the urgent need for some kind of interim protection for mountain hares that could take effect in time for this year’s culling season. The culling season is generally in the winter.
The Scottish Government has a long-held policy against large-scale culls. The calls for a voluntary approach to restraint appear not to have worked, which is leading to the continued unwarranted persecution and suffering of this species. It also undermines the authority of the Scottish Government, given that nothing is happening even though it has said for some time that it is against this. Further, it makes it impossible for Scotland to demonstrate that it is meeting its obligations in relation to this species under the habitats directive. Therefore, we ask the Scottish Parliament to call on the cabinet secretary to acknowledge that the voluntary approach is not working and to use the existing powers to introduce interim protections for the mountain hare while the inquiry considers the issue in full and develops a long-term solution to the problem.
In your submission, you refer to proposals that you have made to the Scottish Government to improve the protection of mountain hares. What has been the response to them?
About this time last year, we wrote to the cabinet secretary with those proposals. We have been told that they are under consideration and that the Scottish Government wants more evidence of culls taking place.
Does it want you to provide that evidence or is it seeking it?
I think that there was a general call for evidence, as it were. People were asked to make the Scottish Government aware of any culls that they knew were happening. That is partly why we produced the report that we published in August. It pulls together all the reports of culls that we are aware of.
Mountain hare culling is not a regulated activity in any way. Because it happens mostly in the middle of winter in quite remote locations, public encounters with culls are relatively rare. The wildlife photographer happened to get the photograph that I showed you earlier because he was leaning out of his car window looking at the red grouse through his long lens when the vehicle that I told you about happened to drive past. I would not say that he was lucky—that would be the wrong word—but it is a relatively rare occurrence for someone to encounter a cull and be able to report it.
The evidence that we have been given suggests that mountain hares are strongly associated with the heather moorland that is managed for red grouse and that they benefit from the habitat management and predator control that is aimed at improving grouse densities. Something seems a bit counterintuitive there. I probably have this completely wrong, but does that mean that there are more mountain hares precisely because of this human-made habitat that has been created for the benefit of grouse sport?
Part of the management regime for grouse moors creates a good environment for mountain hares. Predator control that is done for the benefit of grouse will create a good habitat for mountain hares, so you will find that mountain hares do well on grouse moors. However, it is difficult to talk precisely about the overall population trend, because there is no systematic monitoring—I think that that is covered in the committee’s briefing. The Scottish Government has commissioned research into developing better methodologies for counting mountain hares, and I hope that that will, at some point, lead us to an actual population estimate so that we can provide an authoritative overview of how the population is doing. However, until then we can only go on the bits of data that we have, which come from monitoring that is conducted by the British Trust for Ornithology. It monitors some mammals, including mountain hares, as part of its breeding bird survey, and its data from 1994 to 2014 suggested a significant decline in the population of mountain hares. In recent years, the population has gone up a little bit, so it might be a cycle of population—it is hard to tell. There are also reports of more localised extinctions or reductions in populations. For example, the Mammal Society has noted a number of moors on which mountain hares were once common but are no longer common. Adam Watson, who is a leading ecologist in this field, also notes areas, particularly in the west Highlands, where there are greatly reduced numbers of mountain hares.
11:15
You have referred to the Scottish Government’s response to the call for a package of measures to protect birds of prey. How do you think that those measures would address some of the problems that you are talking about?
You state that some actions need to be taken immediately and you refer to the fact that the group has not been set up yet and that it will take a while to implement any findings. However, I confess that I am slightly confused by the fact that you have said that the very habitats in which the culls are taking place are the ones in which there are increasing numbers. Would you expect there to be increasing numbers during your moratorium?
It would be interesting to monitor that. Your first question was about what we want to happen after the inquiry is set up—is that right?
How will the actions that have been taken in relation to birds of prey help mountain hares?
We have yet to see what the inquiry will recommend. However, one measure that it has been asked to look at is the licensing of grouse moors. How effective that is depends on how that licensing is constructed. It could, for example, require estates to report on the control of mountain hares and other species. Remember, we are operating in an environment in which we have very little data, so anything that we can do to increase transparency about what is happening will certainly help. However, I would hope that the inquiry will consider specific measures to protect mountain hares.
Your second question concerned the apparent paradox in relation to the fact that grouse moors are quite good habitats for mountain hares. Our point is that that fact does not justify culling them.
No, my question was to do with whether you would expect to see a large increase in mountain hare numbers if there was a three-year moratorium.
It would be quite hard to measure that, because we have no baseline data but, yes, we would expect to see them doing better if there was a moratorium on killing them.
Your petition mentions that you have liaised with the Cairngorms National Park Authority. What was the outcome of those discussions?
My understanding is that the Cairngorms National Park Authority has considered the issue at board level and that it is encouraging estates to increase transparency in relation to how their estates are managed, what culls are taking place and the numbers of animals that are involved in those culls.
You talked about licensing and registration. How straightforward would that be? Would there be a huge administrative burden? Would people be likely to take that up? Do you mean that that should be legislated for?
The licensing of grouse moors will hopefully be a bigger policy, in that it will consider a lot of issues and problems related to grouse moor management. A recent study that was published by SNH into how hunting is regulated in other EU countries showed that Scotland is one of the more loosely regulated countries, so I think that there is space to introduce new regulation—that is certainly what these problems suggest. I think that the inquiry will be able to answer your question in full, because it will be able to consider how a licensing scheme should be constructed, what it should include and how it could be delivered.
You have already referred to the research project that is being conducted by the Scottish Government, but can you tell us more about who is involved in it, what its scope is and when you understand its findings will be available?
An update would be useful, but I can certainly relay to the committee my understanding in that respect. I understand from Scottish Natural Heritage that the work, which has been commissioned through the James Hutton Institute, is on developing and trialling a methodology for a mountain hare population census. It has been trialled on a number of estates, and the work should be published towards the end of the year.
The challenge, though, is that that work will not immediately—or, indeed, for some time—answer a lot of the questions that we have. For example, it will not give us a national population estimate, nor will it tell us much about the impact that culling and recreational killing are having on the population. For that to happen—this, again, is my understanding—further research would need to be done to apply that methodology effectively.
The project is welcome, but these are baby steps. The fact that it will be some time before it begins to answer those questions again underlines the importance of having some interim measure to protect mountain hares.
Your preferred interim measure would, I presume, be a three-year moratorium.
A moratorium seems like the obvious approach. It is compatible with the Scottish Government’s position against large-scale culls, and it has support from conservation organisations.
We have tried to put forward a number of approaches. The other possibility would be a simple extension of the licensing regime. Given that the current regime applies five months of the year, why not just extend it to apply the whole year round? If we ran it for a few years, it would not only result in fewer mountain hares being killed but provide quite essential data on the level to which the species is being controlled.
I point the committee to a similar arrangement that was introduced five years ago for seal killing in Scotland. In that example, the move from unregulated to licensed activity not only resulted in a big reduction in the number of seals killed but brought transparency to the sector. Every three months, SNH publishes the latest data on the number of licences that have been issued and the number of seals that have been killed under licence, and that is essential from a conservation and, indeed, a welfare perspective.
Thank you. It is helpful to get that on record.
Your petition recognises that the culling of mountain hares is a way of controlling the tick-borne louping ill virus among grouse. We have had petitions raising the issue of ticks on one hand and highlighting the economic benefit of driven grouse shooting on the other. That shows that there is some conflict between the petitions that are coming before the committee, and I wonder whether you recognise the concerns about the impact of mountain hares on other activities that might bring economic benefit to Scotland.
Indeed, and I listened to the evidence on the previous petition with strong interest.
Let me start at the beginning. According to the SNH-commissioned study that I cited earlier, about 50 per cent of the hares killed in that year were killed as part of organised culls on grouse moors to control ticks, with the aim of reducing the prevalence of louping ill in red grouse chicks. In effect, the aim is to sustain a high population of red grouse for shooting by controlling the tick vector. The problem, though, is that there is no evidence that such an approach works. SNH scientific experts who looked at the scientific literature on the issue have concluded:
“there is no clear evidence that mountain hare culls serve to increase red grouse densities”.
I think, therefore, that the approach is based more on an assumption rather than on any actual evidence.
Obviously, louping ill is different from the virus that was highlighted in the previous petition that the committee considered. I have heard people claim that it might result in reduced prevalence of Lyme disease, too, but I have seen no evidence of that, either. Indeed, there is no evidence of any case of Lyme disease being transmitted by mountain hares or that control of mountain hares results in lower prevalence of Lyme disease among humans. Moreover, the health aspect is not part of the serious proposal that is being considered by the Scottish Government and such like. As far as I am aware, the two issues are not linked in that way.
Thank you.
I find it interesting that other petitions have reflected some of the challenges that we have heard about with regard to protecting the mountain hare and the fact that it is thriving in a managed environment that, in other cases, some environmental groups might be concerned about, and the implication with regard to a condition that clearly has been neither properly addressed nor understood by the medical profession. A number of interesting connections and questions have been highlighted, although dealing with them is perhaps above our pay scale.
Does the committee have any suggestions for taking the petition forward?
Given the Government’s previous interest in the issue, we should write to it to find out its current thoughts on the petition.
It is also worth seeking the views of stakeholders, including SNH, SLE, the Scottish Wildlife Trust, the James Hutton Institute and the Game and Wildlife Conservation Trust.
If members think of any other stakeholders that might have a view, they should feed them in to us, and we will address that.
Does the committee agree to the proposed approach?
Members indicated agreement.
I note the petition’s request that we clarify that the snaring of mountain hares is illegal. Presumably, doing so would be straightforward.
We can raise that with the Scottish Government, too.
The petition actually says that the issue
“has now been satisfactorily addressed in the recent SNH review of snaring.”
Since the petition was drafted, SNH has indeed clarified that it will no longer license the snaring of mountain hares, which we welcome. No action is required on that.
I think that we have agreed how we will take the petition forward. Again, Mr Huyton, you will have the opportunity to comment on any evidence or response from the Scottish Government and others. Thank you very much for your attendance.
I briefly suspend the meeting.
11:27 Meeting suspended.
11:28 On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 14 Sep 2017 →- 09:00 Interests Procedure · 2
- 09:00 New Petitions Petitions · 60
- 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 36
- 10:15 New Petitions Petitions · 84
- 11:00 New Petitions Petitions · 35
- 11:15 Continued Petition Petitions · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.