Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

A77 Upgrade (PE1657)

Thursday 14 September 2017 Public Petitions Committee About 09:30–10:15 Petitions 36 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

36 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

PE1657, which was lodged by Donald McHarrie, is on a proposal to upgrade the A77. I welcome Finlay Carson MSP, who is here to support the petition.

The committee has received a written submission from P&O Ferries, which is included in our papers. Since the papers were published, the committee has received a further written submission from Dr Daniel Goodare, which is available on the petition web page.

Unfortunately, Donald McHarrie is unable to attend today’s meeting, but I welcome John Campbell and Willie Scobie, who are both members of the A77 action group, and invite them to make a brief opening statement of no more than five minutes, after which we will move to questions from committee members.

Willie Scobie A77 Action Group
link

Good morning. Thank you for accepting our petition and for agreeing to hear the evidence that we would like to lead. I am accompanied by John Campbell from Maybole, who is also a member of the action group. As you said, convener, we do not have the petitioner with us—Donald McHarrie had an accident with his knee, and he sends his apologies.

In the short period that we were allocated in which to receive signatures, the petition received 1,599 signatures online and a further 1,652 offline, which comes to a total of 3,251. That seems to be a reasonably good response to the petition and shows that people are concerned about the A77—not only its condition but the fact that it is an arterial route.

The petition calls for the A77 to be upgraded to a dual carriageway from Whitletts roundabout to the ferry ports of Cairnryan and Stranraer—there is an extension from Cairnryan towards Stranraer that connects with the A75 trunk road, which is a European route.

In June 2005, PE859 was submitted to the Public Petitions Committee by Sheena Borthwick of West Sound, who gave a presentation to the committee along with Alan Gordon, the route director of Stena Link. At that time, Stena was threatening to move away from Loch Ryan altogether but, fortunately, it remains there. That petition called for improvements to the A77 and A75. Subsequently, five passing places were installed on those routes. However, we do not feel that that went far enough towards the upgrading of the roads.

The two major international ferry companies that are involved in the issue have invested around £500 million, but that investment was not matched by investment in the A77 or the A75, as can be seen if we compare that with investment elsewhere. Some £0.5 billion was spent on the A55 in Wales to upgrade the dual carriageway, £125 million was spent on dual carriageway and motorway improvements for the link road to Heysham, and, in Northern Ireland, there is motorway the whole way from Larne to Belfast and then right down to Dublin. Compared with connections to other ferry ports, the A77 seems to be the one that has been neglected.

Following the closure of the Troon to Larne ferry—P&O has submitted evidence to the committee on this—there has been increased traffic from Troon. The A77 is a major link road to four major cities—Edinburgh, Glasgow, Belfast and Dublin—and it is essential that it serves the economic and social wellbeing of the area, including the needs of the agricultural sector. We have had the support of NFU Scotland for the upgrade.

In 2015, about £1 billion of exports to Northern Ireland and the European Union member state of the Republic of Ireland have been carried along the A77 and through the UK’s third busiest passenger ferry gateway and freight hub.

In the economy in the south-west of Scotland there are areas of deprivation and run-down areas, leading to increased unemployment and reliance on state benefits. Our young people are leaving the area. We have to try to boost the whole economy, both in Ayrshire and in Dumfries and Galloway.

We have noticed recently that there has been an improvement to the A737 Dalry bypass, which is not dissimilar to the A77. I will let John Campbell speak more on other areas. We have not seen the same improvement to the A77 as has happened at the A737 at Dalry, which is a lot less necessary to the ferry ports. We wonder why.

Other aspects include safety. The road has to be fit for purpose and the demands of modern traffic. The A77 poses a risk for people who live alongside it, with 44-tonne lorries constantly passing by 24 hours a day. The impact on the people of the area is not just physical but psychological.

We welcome the recent announcement from the transport minister, Humza Yousaf, on the Maybole bypass, which has been a long time coming. That does not go far enough, however, in that it is not going to be a dual carriageway or have cycleways or electric vehicle chargers and so forth—things in which, if the Government had delivered them, we could have taken pride.

Another major safety concern is the two landslip sites, at Lendalfoot and particularly at Marchburn, a kilometre north of Cairnryan. It was only last week that we saw the removal of the traffic lights at Lendalfoot, which have been there since January. People have had to suffer the traffic lights at Marchburn for four years, and we do not often see any work going on to sort the landslide there. We are seriously concerned about that.

Another safety issue is around sections that are closed due to road collisions. In 2016-17, there were 21 road closures. When there is a road closure, we have a diversion and, because there is no other route south of Ballantrae, the diversion is the A714 from Newton Stewart to Girvan, which is definitely not fit for purpose. At times, heavy goods vehicles have to take to the embankments because they cannot pass each other on the road. That is a serious concern, not only in terms of safety but in economic terms, as road hauliers have increased transport costs because of fuel and so forth.

We consider that the south-west of Scotland needs a fit-for-purpose road infrastructure. We feel that improvements would certainly help to bring regrowth to Ayrshire and the south-west of Scotland and would help to make better successes of the events that take place in the south-west of Scotland, such as the Scottish air show, golf tournaments and many other events. Also, we want the road to be seen as a tourist route, because we are remapping Stranraer as a destination spot, and the A77 and A75 are crucial to that.

I mentioned the 21 road closures. Of those, 11 were for planned roadworks, where it was not safe to convoy the traffic, so it had to be diverted. One closure was because of the weather and flooding and a further nine were due to road traffic accidents, involving, sadly, three fatalities. The convener referred to the submission by Dr Daniel Goodare, which is on access from the south-west to Glasgow and the medical centre of excellence there. The A77 is crucial in that regard. If someone has a heart attack, we need to get them to Glasgow within what is referred to as the golden hour, but there is a fear that, at times, the road will be closed.

I will finish with three points. We are looking for the Public Petitions Committee and the Scottish Government to immediately prioritise dealing with the landslide at Marchburn, which has been an issue for far too long. We ask that that be sorted as a matter of urgency. We ask that the road be improved by resurfacing to deal with the potholes, which are constantly mentioned on social media. In the long term, we look for the upgrading of the A77 to dual carriageway status.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you very much. We will now move to questions. I ask Finlay Carson to come in first, because I understand that he is unable to stay for the whole of this item.

Finlay Carson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Thanks, convener. I appreciate the opportunity to speak in support of the petition. I also put on record my thanks to the committee for coming down to Dumfries and Galloway last week to consider evidence on the A75. The A75 and A77 are very similar. Members will realise that Dumfries and Galloway is not particularly well connected when it comes to road infrastructure, and that the A77 and A75 are absolutely crucial to the on-going economic sustainability of the area.

Unfortunately, I can speak only very briefly, but I want to highlight Willie Scobie’s point about the traffic lights at Marchburn. Brian Whittle will remember that, last year, there was a transport summit in Dumfries at which we had a personal commitment from Humza Yousaf to look at why the traffic lights have been there for such an extended period. Unfortunately, as happens in so many cases, the request was passed on to Transport Scotland and we got the bog-standard response. As I think the committee has experienced in the past, the buck seems to have been shifted.

I emphasise the importance of the A77 to Stranraer. Stranraer should be seen as a gateway to Scotland, with its ferry port making it the shortest sea route to Northern Ireland. That sea link will become even more important when the United Kingdom leaves the European Union.

Stranraer is a town that has not had the investment that it should have had. The A75 and the A77 really need to be upgraded before we can expect anybody to invest in that corner of Scotland. What we really want is equity of spend. The A77 needs to be recognised as an important route. The evidence that the committee has received from P&O—and may receive from Stena—indicates just how important the A77 is, not only for freight transport but for the tourism industry.

10:00

There are complaints when the route is closed. As Mr Scobie said, the road has been closed 25 or 30 times recently and there is a huge outcry because people are expected to take an hour’s detour. There are no alternative routes—it is either the A75 or the A77; if it is not one of them, it is some B-class roads that are far from adequate to carry the sort of traffic that comes through Stranraer. I urge the committee to consider the petition very seriously, and not just in light of the road safety issues on the A77. It is unlike a lot of routes in Scotland—its whole length is designated as dangerous. We know that it is dangerous because of the average-speed cameras on some sections. That alone should indicate that work is needed to upgrade the route.

Equity of spend in the south-west of Scotland would be very much welcome—it is what we deserve.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I am not quite sure that that qualifies as a question but thank you for that.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Mr Scobie, in your submission and opening statement, you referred to investment in the A77 relating to safety improvements. One of the projects that you mentioned, which is soon to begin, is construction of the Maybole bypass. The local member, Kenny Gibson MSP, has campaigned for the bypass, among other projects, for some time. To what extent do you think that the bypass will address the concerns that you have raised in the petition?

Willie Scobie A77 Action Group
link

Maybole is in Ayrshire. I live in Stranraer, in Dumfries and Galloway, and we see the Maybole bypass as a crucial improvement. The town’s High Street is dangerous and very narrow. If there are any accidents, it is completely cut off. We welcome improvements in Maybole. However, we would have much preferred to see the road upgraded to dual carriageway standard.

John Campbell A77 Action Group
link

I was born and brought up in Maybole and spent 33 years as a part-time firefighter there. I went to hundreds of crashes and have seen dozens of fatalities up and down that road. Even though we were a part-time station, for many years we were one of the busiest stations of any kind anywhere in Scotland for crashes. We carried more equipment than the full-time appliances and were well experienced. We covered an area for crashes that was twice the size of the area for house fires. At one point, we went to five times more crashes than we did house fires or other serious fires.

The first time that the Maybole bypass was pegged out was in 1936 by a Mr Howie, an apprentice surveyor with Ayr County Council. The council went to the farmer and asked to buy the land. The landowners will tell you that the council has been four times since to buy the land—in the 1980s, the 1990s and the early 2000s. The money was given to us and then taken away again at the last minute.

Because the High Street is so dangerous, Maybole is, I believe, the first place in Britain where a section of a trunk road has been given a 20mph limit. In the past 100 years, there have been four fatalities that I know about—there may have been more—and lots of serious injuries.

We have also had a total building collapse. Some of the buildings are from the 1700s. With the bottom castle and the top castle, at one time it was the only high street in Scotland that had two castles. Parts of the oldest building date back to the 1400s. The castle at the bottom of the High Street—the Kennedy’s castle—dates back to the 1500s. That was when the High Street was built, and it was built for horse and cart. It was where Robert Burns’s mother and father met at the market. It is a very small, narrow street, and it is now being used for 44-tonners—brand-new 40-foot-long vehicles that are twice the size of the vehicles even 20 years ago. They are allowed to be there, but they are only inches away. Where the road is nearest to a building, the pavement is 36 inches wide. In two other places, the pavement is just over 36 inches wide.

As I said, we had a total building collapse. The engineers had been saying for many years that that would happen because of the vibration. At 4 o’clock one Sunday afternoon, the father was in the house with his family, his wife and two children. He heard a loud crack and shouted to everyone to get out of the house as quickly as possible. They got out, and the eye-witnesses whom we spoke to after everything was made safe said that the father was the last one out and that the cloud of dust was following him out. That was in the middle of the High Street. In addition, a lorry jack-knifed at the traffic lights and went right through a shop window.

Lots of things have happened, and we have heard promises from many transport ministers who have come down to Maybole over the past few decades. One of them actually said, “I won’t forget Maybole. It will definitely get a bypass.” That has happened time and time again.

The people of Maybole used to say, “We won’t believe it until we see the diggers in.” Now they are saying that they will not believe it until they are driving along the road. That is only one part of the A77 that has been ignored. The gentleman who pegged out the bypass in 1936 said in his retirement speech, as one of the top surveyors for Ayr County Council, “I pegged it out but it’s still not built.” There is story after story about the Maybole bypass, and nobody in Maybole believes that it is actually going to happen.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

It looks as if it is on the cards now but, as you say, we will have to wait and see.

You mentioned the proximity of heavy goods vehicles to housing. When the committee was looking at the A75 last week, we saw a couple of villages where that is certainly the case, so I can imagine how bad it is in Maybole.

Willie Scobie A77 Action Group
link

Can I maybe just add—

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I will allow you a few moments at the end to contribute, but I am keen to get through the questions.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I need to declare an interest, in that Maybole is part of the region that I represent. I have been working with the A77 upgrade committee and it is my fault that we are sitting here now, because I encouraged the group to submit the petition. As Finlay Carson said, transport minister Humza Yousaf and John Swinney attended a symposium in Dumfries. If I am brutally honest about it, the issue has been on the agenda since then and I have seen nothing happen. Over the years, the size of the ferries and lorries has increased, as has the amount of traffic on the road. I drive on that road often and it is without doubt one of the most dangerous roads in Scotland, notwithstanding the fact that it is a main arterial route down to Cairnryan.

We have talked about the temporary traffic lights that have been there for four years. Perhaps Mr Scobie could tell the committee how many times a ferry unloads a serious amount of traffic—I understand that it can be up to 100 lorries—and what impact that has at those temporary traffic lights.

Willie Scobie A77 Action Group
link

On any given day, 26 ferries come into Cairnryan, with P&O Ferries and Stena Line. As a ferry lands, it can unload 110 44-tonne heavy vehicles within a half-hour turnaround. That means 110 vehicles accessing the A77 or the A75, which has a major impact on the temporary lights, causing a tailback of maybe a mile. Thereafter, people will want to pass convoys of heavy vehicles, and there are very few passing places. I have referred to the improvements on the road, but there are still very few places to pass safely. With that mile-long tailback—that convoy of traffic, with all the heavy goods vehicles and cars trying to get by—people start to take risks and chances, which increases the safety issues on the road.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Your submission talks about the benefits of major events such as the golf open at Troon. Would the action that you are calling for make the area more attractive to such major events, and what impact would that have on the economy and communities?

Willie Scobie A77 Action Group
link

We are trying to promote the south-west of Scotland as a festival area and, in that respect, I highlight the Scottish air show as an example. As for golf, I point out that the American President Donald Trump now owns Turnberry, where the open has been held in the past.

There are attractions in the area, but the situation is putting people off. With the road closures, a number of people south of Ayr just decided, “I’m not going to go.” That sort of thing has a major impact not only in Dumfries and Galloway but on events in Ayrshire, because people who use the stretch of road from Stranraer to Newton Stewart find it a long trek, and indeed, it is not in good condition or fit for purpose.

The situation is having a major impact. As I have said, Stranraer is trying to re-map itself as a destination. For those who come on the ferry, it should be pointed out that Stena has now moved its operations 6 miles up the road. There has been a serious impact on Stranraer’s economy; to attract more tourists into the town, we need to rebrand it as a destination instead of its being synonymous with ferry ports. However, the A77 is a turn-off.

John Campbell A77 Action Group
link

We believe that Turnberry is now the number 1 golf course in the whole of Britain, and a lot of people want to play there. However, the Royal and Ancient Golf Club has indicated on a few occasions now that it is not happy with giving the open championship to it because of the roads. Indeed, one of the things that it has highlighted is the stretch from the Whitletts roundabout, where the A77 stops being a dual carriageway.

Last year, the open was at Royal Troon, and the independent report that came out in January reckoned that the area alone made about £110 million. After all, it is not just about people going to the area for the four days; there is a huge build-up to the event, and television companies, the media and so on are there for weeks, setting everything up and using the local facilities. Turnberry is a huge facility; it employs about 400 people part-time, full-time, directly and indirectly. At one stage, however, the main hotel came very close to closing down; many people do not know that, but for various reasons people just did not want to go there. In fact, golf agents stopped sending people down to the area because it was taking so long. Americans would be here for weeks, driving around Scotland and spending an absolute fortune on, for example, Scottish golf courses, clothes and so on, but they stopped getting sent down to that part of the country, because they were wasting part of their holiday just having to travel there. This is having a huge impact on that part of that economy.

I should also point out that, further south, you have the caravan sites. There are hundreds of jobs down there, because of the beautiful scenery. However, people come once, and they do not want to come back. It is quicker for a family in Glasgow to go to Berwick-upon-Tweed and the north-east of England than to go to Portpatrick, which is absolutely crazy.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

As you will be aware, the committee was down in Dumfries and Galloway last week to hear evidence on the petition regarding the A75, and there was mention of the summit that has been talked about this morning and which I think Brian Whittle has referred to. Was anything else discussed at the summit that you would like to highlight to the committee and which has not been mentioned so far?

10:15

Willie Scobie A77 Action Group
link

I think that there has been mention of it. I attended the summit that Humza Yousaf promised he would hold within 100 days. It has been mentioned that he gave a personal commitment to me that he would get something done about the landslide, which is just a catastrophe waiting to happen because the landslide is at the top and the bottom of the road and it is really only the road that is holding it all together. However, there has been no action since that time. I think that they are relying on the road to be sorted through revenue funding.

Four years ago, Scotland TranServ attended a council meeting in Stranraer and laid out that, given the maintenance budget, it would be 20 years before it would finish that particular road. There has been no capital investment to fix that road. In comparison, landslides on the A82 at the Rest and Be Thankful and on the A9 were fixed in a matter of days or weeks. We have had a landslide for more than four years, but the new Forth crossing was built in six years.

Humza Yousaf said that he would look at the economy and take on board the points that were well made at the summit, but there has been no improvement since.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you. Do you want to highlight any final points? I know that you wanted to make another point earlier.

Willie Scobie A77 Action Group
link

With regard to the question posed by Angus MacDonald on the Maybole bypass, we welcome the bypass, which is essential for Maybole. However, on the 47-mile stretch from Whitletts to Stranraer, eight towns and villages have to be passed through. I know that the committee was in Dumfries and Galloway recently and, when travelling on the A75, you would have passed through two villages. However, there are eight towns and villages on the A77—no doubt you travelled through them on the way home—and I do not know how many roundabouts and speed restrictions of 30mph and so forth. John Campbell has a map of Scotland that shows very few, if any, other major trunk roads pass through towns and villages, because they are all bypassed. The A77 has eight towns and villages on its route, which far exceeds what is the case on such routes in the rest of Scotland. The area of the A77 and A75 trunk roads is almost like the forgotten corner in terms of investment in the infrastructure of arterial routes.

John Campbell A77 Action Group
link

Convener, I have a map that I have taken to meetings in Newton Stewart, Stranraer and all the way up to Ayr. I have taken it to about a dozen meetings since February. The map shows the distances that can be travelled without going through a 30mph limit. If you would not mind, I could show you on a map of Scotland the different road systems going north and south.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I wonder whether it is possible to find a way of sharing that information with the committee afterwards.

John Campbell A77 Action Group
link

Yes.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I am conscious of the time and practicalities involved in our seeing that information. Perhaps you can speak to the clerks at the end of the evidence session and see whether a way can be found for us to see that information. However, I thank you for your evidence. You make a very interesting and substantial case around the economic, environmental and safety issues that you have highlighted. I think that the committee has found it very interesting and thought provoking. However, I do not know what action we will want to take on the petition.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

As has been said, the area that we are talking about has been called the forgotten part of Scotland. It is in danger of becoming the ignored part of Scotland because it is no longer a secret that there is an issue there.

I have struggled to get a coherent response from the Government about a longer-term strategy for the A77 and A75. Given the seriousness of the issue and the real possibility, according to the ferry port owners, of taking the route from Dublin to Holyhead—getting from Belfast to Birmingham through Holyhead rather than Stranraer has now only a 20-minute difference—if we do not do something, we are in danger of losing the port.

I ask that we bring Humza Yousaf, the Minister for Transport and the Islands, to the committee to allow us to tease out the Government’s plans for that part of the world. The matter is really serious.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

The arguments about the A77 and the A75 are pretty much the same, but with some differences. How should we link those together more tightly? They are two separate petitions, but the economic arguments and the issues about the ports and the movement of traffic are the same. I wonder if we should hear them both together. If there were to be an upgrade, a decision might be needed about prioritisation.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

If we were to hear evidence from the minister, it would make sense to put the two together. I do not think that anyone would have any objections to that. The issues are the environment, the economy and safety. My only question is whether those issues go beyond the transport minister’s remit because the economy goes beyond simply transport issues. We could ask the Scottish Government who would be the most appropriate person to come to the committee.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

As the petition is new—although the saga is long-running—we should write initially to ask the Government for its views. We could then link the two petitions for gathering evidence, as Michelle Ballantyne suggested.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

If we write to the Scottish Government, our expectation would be that, ideally, the minister would come to talk about both issues and how to address the area’s economy. The points made about threats to the port are significant, as are those about the other developments around it.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

Could we ask particularly about the Government’s engagement with the port? I spoke to the shipping lines last week about important economic discussions and their future impact.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We will write to the Scottish Government and raise the issues and the simple specific questions, which might include the timetable for the Maybole bypass and Humza Yousaf’s commitment that was mentioned earlier and now sits with Transport Scotland. The bigger picture questions that we can highlight for both petitions are about the impact on local communities, the long-term plan and recognition of the economic consequences of not doing anything.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

With regard to inviting the minister, we will write to the Government and get its reply, and then we will ask him to come in. Can we circumvent that?

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We will write to the Government about the petition, and ask for a written response with a view to the minister coming to the committee beyond that. That is not to cause delay; when we schedule a visit with whoever the Government minister is, they will already have provided written evidence, which affords the opportunity for the petitioners to respond ahead of our session with the minister.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

We would presumably need the minister’s support for any suggestions going forward, so he would have to be on board and briefed anyway.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I thank the witnesses for attending the meeting; we appreciate it. We will keep in touch about a Government response and the scheduling of any future consideration of the petition. I suspend the meeting briefly to allow for a change of witnesses.

10:24 Meeting suspended.

10:25 On resuming—

  1. 09:00 Interests Procedure · 2
  2. 09:00 New Petitions Petitions · 60
  3. 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 36
  4. 10:15 New Petitions Petitions · 84
  5. 11:00 New Petitions Petitions · 35
  6. 11:15 Continued Petition Petitions · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.