Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

School Libraries (PE1581)

Thursday 20 April 2017 Public Petitions Committee About 09:30–10:00 Petitions 26 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

26 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The next petition is PE1581, which was lodged by Duncan Wright on behalf of Save Scotland’s School Libraries. Copies of the most recent correspondence from COSLA, the petitioner and the Deputy First Minister have been circulated with the clerk’s note on the petition. The Scottish Government officials accompanying the Deputy First Minister for this evidence session are Craig Flunkert, team leader for skills, literacy, numeracy and parents, and Catriona Mackenzie, policy manager. To make the most of our time, we will move straight to questions from the committee.

Deputy First Minister, your submission notes that libraries—both school and public—

“have a key role in supporting Scottish Government initiatives”.

The initiatives that are referenced have a particular focus on the early years. In an earlier Scottish Government submission, reference was made to the national strategy for public libraries that was developed by the Scottish Library and Information Council. That submission stated:

“it is important that school libraries continue to adapt to meet the needs of their users and the wider attainment aims of their schools.”

Given the recognition of the importance of school libraries, why should a specific national strategy for school libraries not be developed?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

I acknowledge and strongly support the provision of school libraries, which are an important part of the work that we undertake in encouraging an appreciation of literacy and literature among young people. I do not think that there is unanimity on the need to have a national strategy, but the petitioner makes a fair point about the importance of having such an approach and it is my intention to formulate such a strategy.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

In your submission of 13 April, you refer to the fourth edition of “How good is our school?” and say:

“I can now confirm that Education Scotland will be integrating the new librarian-focused guidance into the main ... framework. This will give it greater prominence and help demonstrate the fundamental and wide-ranging links between the school library and the school’s broader aims on Curriculum for Excellence.”

When is that likely to be published and can you give us an indication of its content?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

I want to have it in place for the start of the 2017-18 school year—that is, by August this year. It will reflect the key elements that we need to encourage in school libraries, which are a combination of the use of school libraries to encourage literacy within learning and a general appreciation of the social value and personal pleasure of literature. That fits in very comfortably with some of the wider policy objectives and approaches that the Government has taken, principally through the recently launched First Minister’s reading challenge, which is attracting significant participation around the country. The approach will also ensure that, through the wider work of curriculum for excellence, we equip young people to be conversant with information literacy, which we see as an important function and responsibility of school libraries within the wider school system.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

What was the “information” phrase that you used?

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Information literacy. I am old enough to remember when you learned all about the system—I cannot remember what it is called—that is used to organise information so that you can get it from encyclopedias rather than just googling it or having your daughter contradict you in front of the television because she can google something on her phone.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Should libraries be teaching the skills to assess information and where it comes from? Those skills are being lost.

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

We had a very interesting conversation at the International Council of Education Advisers with Pasi Sahlberg from Finland, who is looking very carefully at the impact of googling everything in the learning process. It is a fascinating area of inquiry.

I am old enough to remember preparing university work by standing at long index-card drawers and working my way through them. If I was to explain that to my children in comparison to what they have access to, they would look at me as if I was from the stone age. However, those are really important skills, as they allow you to assess the value that you should apply to what you find out from particular sources, which is a challenge that is not immediately obvious to individuals when they just google something and get whatever the search throws up. Libraries provide an opportunity for an appreciation of those important skills.

As you will be familiar with, convener, there are wider areas of our education system in which young people are enabled to develop research techniques and acquire those skills and knowledge that are an important part of our education process.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Do you accept that part of the concern that underpins the petition is the lack of appreciation of the role of libraries? They are not just about accessing books and an understanding of the joy of reading. The petitioner is particularly fearful that we are losing the teaching of skills.

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

I used the term “information literacy” to cover exactly that point. I totally accept the point.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Another issue that has been mentioned in consideration of the petition is the role that is played not only by libraries but by professionally qualified staff in libraries in enabling the achievement of educational outcomes. Concern has been expressed that local authorities do not fully recognise that. What is your view?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

It is difficult for me to generalise in that respect, but I will cite one anecdotal piece of evidence. I visited Elgin academy in February and, when I went into the school, the headteacher said, “The first place we are going to go is the library.” That was the first time that I have been on a school visit and been taken to the library first. It was quite a different experience, which was precisely designed by the headteacher to make the point to me that the school had a professionally trained librarian who was a very motivated and driven individual and who had transformed the library into the epicentre of many other aspects of the school. It took into account some of the issues that I raised earlier about an appreciation of literature, an understanding of information literacy and a place of contact, friendship, dialogue and reassurance.

We need to get into some of the thinking about how our schools provide a safe and welcoming environment. If any child at Elgin academy was feeling a wee bit lost, the library, which could be a hub of activity—whether it was paired reading between older and younger pupils, various escapades of acting out of literary works, or various projects and challenges—could provide isolated young people with a place to have a good experience. The professional strength of what librarians can offer is important, but it is difficult for me to give a general response to the question of appreciation of libraries. I have just given a good example for the role of school libraries and that practice will exist in a range of other examples around the country.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Your most recent submission states that you would

“expect all local authorities to give careful and positive consideration of the future role of libraries given their statutory responsibilities for the delivery of education and ensuring that there is an adequate provision of library services for their residents.”

Is there a mechanism for determining what amounts to “adequate provision” and, if not, what is the Scottish Government’s view on the minimum service that could be considered as an adequate provision?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

Mr Whittle and I talk constantly about the interrelationship between Government and local authorities. I do not say that to diminish the point, because it is an important one. Ultimately, there is a tension between local decision making and the Government’s requirements, and it is a tension that we continue to wrestle with. We discussed it as being material to the previous petition and we are discussing it again here as being material to this petition on school libraries.

The Government sometimes has to choose the ground on which we make something into a requirement, if I can put it as bluntly as that. If we make everything a requirement, there is no room for local discretion and decision making. I do not want anyone to misconstrue what I am saying. School libraries should have a prominent role in the life of the school. I cannot conceive of how teachers will be able to adequately convey the importance of an appreciation of literature and information literacy without being able to exemplify that in a school library. However, I have to be careful that I do not overprescribe to local authorities what I require them to do. I certainly believe that this is a significant aspect of what needs to be applied.

As we formulate a national strategy for school libraries, we can perhaps wrestle with the issue that Mr Whittle has put in front of me and decide how firm we should be in making some of the aspects of this debate a requirement.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

If I may, I will use the word “persuade” rather than “require”. Is there a policy to do that?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

That is the territory that we are in with a national strategy and guidance. We are trying to exhort and persuade local authorities to follow good practice, to use Mr Whittle’s word. Obviously, as with other issues, if we do not achieve satisfaction, we can consider making it a requirement. What I try to do in my work with local government—perhaps it is not always perceived in this way—is to encourage joint good practice between Government and local government. I would be very surprised to hear local authorities marshall an argument saying that they do not think that school libraries are a good thing. Whether due prominence is given to school libraries is perhaps a different matter.

10:00

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I suppose that that is the question. COSLA has set out its view that the creation of a national school library strategy

“would also further undermine the role of locally elected Councillors in making budget decisions and would be a further erosion of local democracy.”

The petitioner expressed disappointment at that comment. Do you think that having a national strategy has that impact, and what are the mitigations? I agree that nobody is against libraries, and I know that the pressure on you as a Government minister to develop a national library strategy will be the same as the pressure at local authority level, where campaigners are saying that there should be libraries. If we assume that nobody is malevolent or hostile to libraries in this situation, what is the balance to be struck in understanding why local authorities have not given the prominence to libraries that a national strategy might develop?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

As with all such questions, a range of different approaches will be taken around the country. I gave the committee the example of Elgin academy, where the library is the epicentre of the school. It is viewed as such and could not be made more central to the life of the school. There are other examples, for example in Argyll and Bute, of proposals to significantly reduce school library provision in the local authority area.

A national strategy may be helpful. If I am asked whether I think that it is a good thing that school libraries will start to get eroded, my answer is that I do not think that it is a good thing. I actually think that it is a really bad thing. I have looked at the material from the petitioner and I have looked at the evidence, and that is why I gave the answer that I gave to your first question, convener. In weighing it all up, we have to give clearer signals about what we expect.

As I told Mr Whittle a moment ago, it is a fine balance between my saying, “You must have a school library in every school,” and my recognising that there may be practical challenges and issues that go with that, particularly given our country’s diverse geography, but there will be ways in which we can provide school library services in a sustainable way if we attach due priority to them. What persuaded me of the need to have a national strategy is that we need to give a stronger signal than has been given, and the petitioner has prompted me to come to that conclusion.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

In achieving a balance between local authorities and Government, there is also balance to be found between priorities that can be made within budget constraints and the extent to which you can have an impact on the budget constraints that have perhaps been created for local authorities.

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

We were having a fairly harmonious morning until 3 minutes past 10. I am surprised that it has taken us this long. You will appreciate that I think that local authorities have been fairly supported in the Government settlement, not least by the additional resources that were provided to local authorities by the budget agreement that was arrived at for 2017-18.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

You would also expect me to say that it would require some library skills to interrogate the extent to which that budget process is one that everybody is happy with.

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

I would be quite happy to put my research-gathering skills to the test with the index cards of the old University of Edinburgh library at my disposal.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I will not say, “What a good education wasted.”

Thank you very much for that. There has been a lot of useful dialogue on the issue. The petitioner is concerned that the role of libraries is being reduced, so he will probably take some comfort from that understanding of the broader role of a school library and the professionals who operate in it.

It would be useful for us to reflect on the evidence from the Deputy First Minister with a note for a future meeting of the committee. We can consider what further action to take at that stage. That will afford the petitioner the opportunity to respond to what has been said on the establishment of a national strategy. Is that agreed?

Members indicated agreement.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I suspend the meeting until the Scottish Government officials have changed.

10:05 Meeting suspended.

10:06 On resuming—

  1. 09:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 39
  2. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 26
  3. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 38
  4. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 17
  5. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  6. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.