Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Restraint and Seclusion in Schools (National Guidance) (PE1548)

Thursday 20 April 2017 Public Petitions Committee About 09:00–09:30 Petitions 39 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

39 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I welcome everyone to the Public Petitions Committee’s seventh meeting in 2017. I remind members and others in the room to switch phones and other devices to silent. We have received apologies from Maurice Corry. His substitute is Edward Mountain, whom I welcome to the meeting.

Agenda item 1 is consideration of three continued petitions. We will hear evidence on each petition from the Deputy First Minister, and we are grateful to him and his officials for attending the meeting.

The first petition is PE1548, on national guidance on restraint and seclusion in schools, lodged by Beth Morrison. Members have copies of correspondence from Dr Brodie Paterson and the Deputy First Minister and two submissions from the petitioner.

The Deputy First Minister is accompanied by Laura Meikle, team leader, and Melanie Lowe, relationships and behaviour in schools policy officer. As we have limited time this morning, we will move straight to questions.

Welcome, Mr Swinney. I will start with a question about the communication passport, which is covered in your correspondence with the committee. You say that the passport will be signposted in “Included, Engaged and Involved Part 2: A Positive Approach to Preventing and Managing School Exclusions”—IEI2—and will be part of a suite of documents to support schools and local authorities with IEI2’s implementation. The petitioner notes that you have indicated that that resource will be rolled out via the glow network. What is the timescale for the passport and other documents being published?

John Swinney SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills · Perthshire North
link

The communication passport material is readily available on the glow site. The passport, which the petitioner refers to, is an important development that has been progressed significantly by one of my constituents, Mrs Kate Sanger, on behalf of her daughter. I have had the pleasure of dealing with Mrs Sanger about the support for her daughter. I have a copy of her daughter’s communication passport with me. Mrs Sanger and her other daughter, Jennifer, have put together a fabulous piece of work on behalf of Laura Sanger.

The passport represents a powerful resource that can be used by anyone who is involved in supporting Laura. As a model, the passport offers a clear way of advising individuals about how they can best support Laura’s needs.

In addition to the communication passport tool being available on the glow website, I have asked Mrs Sanger and Mrs Morrison, the petitioner, to discuss the passport with a gathering of senior officials from the advisory group for additional support for learning, which is a Scottish Government group that is convened by Jan Savage from Enable Scotland. The group brings together representatives of the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities, the Association of Directors of Education in Scotland, Education Scotland and all the relevant bodies that are responsible for putting in place the guidance and enabling the use of tools such as the communication passport in our system.

I want Mrs Morrison and Mrs Sanger to have the opportunity to speak face to face with those bodies, which will be either the enablers or the inhibitors of the communication passport being widely understood and used in our education system, so that they can explain the rationale behind the passport and encourage participation in and use of such a tool. I expect that meeting to take place on 30 August.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Given that not only teaching staff but other support staff might support a young person, are measures being put in place to allow people the time to reflect on what a communication passport tells them about that person?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

It is not enough to put the tool on the glow website and tell people that that great resource is available to use. Doing that helps, because it means that there is widespread access to such material throughout not only our education system but the care and support system, but it is also important that we actively promote the attributes of the communication passport.

You raise the fair point that there is value in such a passport only if it influences the practice, behaviour and actions of members of staff and if they have enough time to consume the details and to understand its significance. The gathering that I mentioned is important in providing a platform for the petitioner and Mrs Sanger to explain the passport’s attributes and benefits. It is also important that the passport becomes part of the normal way of working, to make sure that we support young people who have additional support needs.

I mentioned the passport for Laura. Although there is a lot of detail in the passport, it is important for that detail to be understood and followed. Whatever discipline members of staff come from, they will be better equipped to support individuals in meeting those individuals’ needs if they have an opportunity to understand, to follow the material that is in the passport and to reflect it in their practices.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Good morning, Deputy First Minister. Your letter says that you will

“consider a refresh of the ... Child Protection guidance following the implementation of the recommendations of the Child Protection Improvement Programme”.

I am interested in the timescale to which that work will be completed. Will you outline the expected conclusion of that programme and when you expect the recommendations to be implemented?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

First, the guidance that is to be refreshed will be published in the context of the school exclusion guidance. The purpose of the guidance is to address the issues that the petition raises from the perspective of encouraging positive behaviour. Although the material will be under the umbrella of school exclusion guidance, the thinking and the rationale behind the guidance is all about encouraging positive relationships and behaviour.

It has taken quite a bit of time to get to this point. It is fair to say that there has not been unanimity about this being the right thing to do; indeed, we have had to work hard to persuade a variety of bodies of the advantage of the approach. However, I am satisfied that the guidance that we have developed has been considered by the Scottish advisory group on relationships and behaviour in schools, with which the committee will be familiar. I am confident that we will be in a position to publish the guidance by the end of May, but I want to hold off in order to hear whether the committee wishes to say anything else about the issues as a consequence of my attendance today.

On the wider issues that relate to the child protection improvement programme, as the committee will be aware, the Government is progressing a number of strands of work to ensure that we can be confident that our child protection programme is appropriate and effective in meeting the needs of children in Scotland in the current environment.

Before Christmas, we received from Catherine Dyer a report that looked at what I will describe as the structural and procedural design of the child protection improvement programme. That report essentially validated the procedures and processes of the child protection improvement programme but challenged us significantly on ensuring effective leadership in the delivery of the programme. When Mr McDonald made his statement on the issue to Parliament earlier this year, he made it clear that the early focus of our work will be on strengthening the child protection programme to honour and address the recommendations that Catherine Dyer put in front of the Government.

I expect that the updated guidance on the child protection programme will probably not be available until 2018, given the work that we have to do to strengthen the leadership elements. I will be happy to advise the committee on the progress that we make on that.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

On the drafting of the guidance on the use of restraint and physical intervention, the petitioner has concerns that that has been treated as an education issue rather than a learning disability issue in an education environment. She has also suggested that, although some experts offered assistance in drafting the guidance, those offers were declined. Will you respond to those comments and outline how you have ensured that the relevant expertise has been drawn on in the development of the guidance?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

We have extensively consulted a wide variety of stakeholders that are involved in this field of activity. That has principally been through the activities of SAGRABIS, which is chaired jointly by the Government and the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities.

As I said in my response to the convener a moment ago, there has not been unanimity on how to take forward the agenda. We have had to work carefully to create unanimity and to structure the guidance in the way that it is now structured. That has involved extensive stakeholder involvement to ensure that we have in place all the necessary attributes, and it has resulted in the development of a guidance document that takes a proactive and preventative approach to how one might address the issue of physical restraint.

The preventative and proactive approach is epitomised by the thinking that has gone into the communication passport, which I referred to. The guidance is predicated on trying to avoid such situations materialising. The emphasis in the procedure and the process is on the need to create avoidance approaches that are based on positive relationships and a positive understanding of individuals’ needs. The communication passport is an important tool in ensuring that that happens.

The advice is predicated on the importance of recognising the knowledge that staff have. The detail of the assessment that staff have made of the child or young person is vital to predicting and planning for the type of situation that might cause stress or frustration and lead to challenging or distressed behaviour. It is about acknowledging the importance of planning situations and approaches that try to ensure avoidance. The communication passport is helpful because it advertises the signals of distressed behaviour so that, when those early signals are identified, steps can be taken to try to reduce the stress and difficulty that are created.

The guidance is predicated on that preventative and proactive approach. It presents any question of physical restraint as an absolute last resort that should be considered only when there is a risk of physical harm. In the wording of the guidance, we have gone to great lengths to ensure that that character comes through.

09:15

That brings me to the other point that Rona Mackay raised, which is the petitioner’s expressed concern that the matter is being considered as an education issue. I assure the committee—and my explanation in getting to this part of my answer is designed to address the fact—that that has not been the way in which the Government has approached it.

I respect the fact that individuals will have to come to a judgment about that when they see the guidance. However, my thinking and the thinking that my officials have taken forward has been about taking a proactive and preventative approach to equip individuals with knowledge and understanding beforehand in order to avoid situations materialising. That cannot be just a narrow, educational view; a whole-person approach has to be taken. I hope that that will be clear to individuals when they look at the guidance that the Government will publish at the end of May.

Edward Mountain Con Highlands and Islands
link

Good morning, Mr Swinney. How do you see the guidance in the document that you are talking about being promulgated down to the people who will have to deal with such situations? I know that avoidance should always be the first call, but there are cases such as that of my wife, who was a classroom assistant and was assaulted. When the situation flared up, she was unclear how to respond. Although she had been given guidance, it is sometimes difficult to remember the guidance. Will training be undertaken to ensure that the guidance is promulgated down to all those who need to know it?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

Mr Mountain will be aware that a number of levels of communication will be required to make sure that the message can be received. Once the Government publishes the guidance, it will be there for local authorities to take forward. As the principal organisations that operate facilities in which those policies will need to be put into practice, it will be for local authorities to ensure that staff are adequately and appropriately trained.

Obviously, there are particular environments in our education system in which some of the issues that will be associated with the guidance will be much more prominent. There will be circumstances—perhaps such as the one that Mr Mountain’s wife faced—of a more isolated nature, in which knowing the guidance inside out is not going to be at the top of the training programme’s list of priorities. We have to make sure that staff who are put in that situation are aware of the guidance and have the necessary support available to them. Through leadership in the education system and through training, it has to be ensured that staff can be properly and effectively supported.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Good morning. The petitioner has highlighted the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child recommendation that a national recording system be developed and has observed that, in a response, you stated that

“Details on how this should be undertaken should be included in the local authority’s policy on de-escalation, physical intervention and restraint.”

I understand that the petitioner would welcome clarity on what that means and on how the inclusion of those details in a local authority policy would comply with the recommendation on the development of a national system. Would you care to respond to that point?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

That point concerns an important issue to do with how we respond to calls from the UNCRC about the type of system that we operate. As the committee and Mr Whittle will know, local authorities have the responsibility of delivering education services at a local level. I am regularly asked what degree of intervention by the Government there should be in that delivery. This is one of those situations in which the local authorities have a responsibility and then I come along and say that I want to monitor them to another extent in that respect. I understand why the UNCRC asks for that information to be compiled at a national level but, fundamentally, we have a decentralised education system in which our local authorities have the operational role.

As part of the guidance, I have asked our local authorities to undertake that recording of information. Obviously, we can gather that from local authorities, but I think that it makes the most practical sense to respond to that call from the UNCRC by asking local authorities to record the information, because that respects and reflects the character of our own system.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

On the issue of local authorities’ policies, will the guidance provide a clear framework or mechanism for how policies should be developed? Will it outline a role for the Scottish Government in ensuring that any framework is followed?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

My answer to that question will be similar to what I said previously. I think that the guidance is sufficiently clear to set out to local authorities what we expect to see. Some of the detail that I went through in my answer to Rona Mackay’s question was about that fundamental reliance on a proactive, preventative approach of understanding the young person to ensure that they can be properly supported, which will enable us to avoid the development of the kind of situation to which the petition refers. That approach is at the heart of the advice and guidance that we have set out, which we would obviously like local authorities to reflect.

Education Scotland has a responsibility to carry out the inspection of our education system, and one of the issues that it will look at is how the Government’s policy formulation has been applied at local level in order to ensure that the aspirations that are set out in the Government’s guidance are being reflected at local level. Clearly, if we come back in a couple of years and find that we have not made the progress that we would all like to be made on the matter and that the guidance has not been followed, the Government could take further action, if necessary. I would rather operate on the basis of the Government promulgating the guidance and the local authorities turning it into practical reality, but if we find that that is not the case, the Government will obviously have to take account of that in its future actions.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I want to highlight that the petitioner and Dr Paterson have provided strong evidence to underline their concerns about the issue of physical restraint and local authorities’ policies on it. Dr Paterson suggests that

“a significant number of authorities continue to have no such policies.”

Further, the petitioner has commented on a recent BBC Radio 5 Live investigation on the use of restraint and seclusion in special schools that found that in 37 of the UK’s 207 council areas, 13,000 restraints were used, with more than 700 injuries being caused to children as a result of restraint. The petitioner notes that that does not reflect the true figure across the UK, given the number of authorities that are not included and the small number of authorities that responded to freedom of information requests.

Again, we come back to the question of the balance between the role of Government and the responsibilities of local authorities. Would you consider imposing a requirement on local authorities to develop a policy on the issue of physical restraint? If so, would they be required to report annually to the Scottish Government?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

Some of my response to that will relate to what I have just said to Brian Whittle. We have embarked on an approach of setting out national guidance and requiring local authorities to take forward guidance and provision that reflects that. Our intention is to promote what I would characterise as a voluntary route, whereby we are not putting anything in statute but are seeking to encourage and motivate good practice. However, if we find after a period that that approach has not been successful, I would have to consider other options.

Therefore, my answer to your question is that I would have to be open to considering further requirements if I found that our approach was not resulting in the formulation of guidance at local level that reflected the guidance that has been agreed by the Scottish advisory group for relationships and behaviour in schools. SAGRABIS involves the Government, local authorities and ADES, so I am trying to take people with me as I embark on this agenda. However, if, in due course, we find that that has not been effective, I will consider whether a greater obligation—perhaps one with statutory force—is required in order to put that into practice.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Is the test of effectiveness whether guidance and policies are developed or whether there is transparency around reporting an incident?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

It is transparency in the reporting of incidents. We also want to receive feedback from members of the public as to whether parents and carers of young people feel that what I am saying here is reflected in what they experience in different settings around the country. If that is not what members of the public experience, I must accept that, come back here and do something different.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

How do you see that channel of communication from the public to you working? There are individual constituency cases and there is the petitioner. There is a concern that it is not just an education matter but one that concerns the expertise of people who deal with young people with learning disabilities. You have made an offer—which I am sure will be welcomed—to engage with and involve the petitioner and your own constituent. Is there something more formal that could be done on the issue with the organisations that properly understand learning disability? Earlier, you mentioned a group that has been brought together. Is that the vehicle to deal with the gap between what you hope is happening and what might actually be happening? Is that how that information loop can be closed?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

That would undoubtedly be within my view of how that needs to be taken forward. Earlier, I made reference to the event at which I intend to ensure that Mrs Morrison and Mrs Sanger are able to explain the communication passport. That is a meeting of the Scottish Government advisory group for additional support for learning, which is chaired by Jan Savage from Enable Scotland. It brings together a range of key stakeholders, including COSLA and ADES, as well as other organisations that can be a conduit for the information about established practice that the convener talked about. I will look to that group to give the Government advice on how the guidance is proceeding and how it is being experienced at local level.

As you will be aware from discussions that we have had separately at the Education and Skills Committee, which has taken a very strong interest in the arrangements for additional support for learning, I expect there to be considerably more dialogue with that committee on many of those issues. I am very keen to make sure that we respond positively to any flow of information that suggests that the guidance is not having the effect that I am suggesting to the committee that it might have or should be able to have.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

I want to ask about the issue of seclusion. The petitioner and Dr Paterson appear to be particularly concerned about the suggestion that the term “seclusion” might be replaced in the guidance by a term such as “supported separation”, which would have the effect of allowing seclusion rooms to remain. That is in the context of the UNCRC recommendation to abolish the use of isolation rooms. Will you respond to those concerns and explain whether supported separation would allow seclusion rooms to be used?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

There is the possibility that seclusion might have to be used as a very last resort in such circumstances. What the guidance will do is set out, first, that seclusion should be absolutely a last resort and, secondly, that it must be deployed with support and supervision as part of a plan that has been proactively considered on what is to be used in certain circumstances, should those circumstances prevail. It should not be used as a form of punishment—that would be utterly unacceptable—but there may be an argument for it to be used as part of a plan to provide proper safety and security for the individuals concerned. It should be used only on those terms as a last resort and as part of a plan. It should never be used as a punishment of any form.

09:30

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Do you accept that the UNCRC recommendation that isolation rooms should be abolished is pretty clear and that simply recasting them as seclusion rooms does not address the issue that it has asked us to address, which is that the rooms should not exist, even as a last resort? The petitioner and Dr Paterson were explicit on that, too.

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

I assure the committee that I am not playing with words on the matter or using terminology to perpetuate an existing practice. I am trying to explain that there might be circumstances in which a period of quiet time as defined within a plan can be used effectively as part of a considered approach to de-escalating a situation. However, I stress some of the fundamentals of my answer to Rona Mackay: that should never be viewed, presented or positioned as a punishment and it should be used only as part of a proactively considered plan for techniques that might be necessary to de-escalate a situation. It should never be used on the basis of personal isolation; it must be used on the basis of support to assist in de-escalating a situation.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Do you accept that there is a problem? How would it look different? Would it be a separate room? Is there an issue with the environment? Some of the evidence says that some of the physical characteristics of the room can cause greater distress to the young person. Would it be that they were not removed to a physical space but that they were with a member of staff?

I am not sure. I understand the cynicism of people who think that we can deal with the UNCRC by deleting the word “isolation” and inserting “seclusion”. However, the UNCRC is explicit about its desire for the rooms to be abolished.

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

As I said, I have met Mrs Sanger, who produced the communications passport, on numerous occasions as a constituent of mine but I have also met her with Mrs Morrison, the petitioner. Mrs Morrison has shown me pictures of what might be described as isolation rooms, which I judged to be totally unacceptable. When I talk about the need for seclusion as a last resort, I am talking about a separate room or a safe space that is deemed to be appropriate for helping to de-escalate the situation. Therefore, a young person could not be taken to any old room; they would have to be taken to a particular space where the situation could be de-escalated with support from a member of staff as part of a plan that recognised that to be a measure of last resort. That is simply to recognise that there might be issues of safety for the young person or other members of staff that have to be considered at the time.

I do not in any way want to convey the impression that the guidance encourages the use of seclusion. It recognises that, in certain circumstances, there might be a need to de-escalate a situation, but that must be done as part of a planned and supported approach in appropriate accommodation. I have seen images of accommodation that has been used in the past, and I judge some of that accommodation to be utterly inappropriate. The guidance would make that clear as part of the process.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Whose job is it to deem whether the accommodation is appropriate?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

That would have to be undertaken by those who assess the appropriate care needs of individuals. Such assessments will be undertaken at local level in the context of the judgments that have been made about what support it is appropriate to provide in meeting an individual’s needs. I come back to the wider assessment that must be made of the needs of individuals and the requirement to ensure that those needs are properly met within the system.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I apologise, Deputy First Minister, because you have alluded to aspects of my question already. You mentioned that the policy might require to be adapted in the future. Assessment of the policy’s effectiveness will come down to the measurement resource that is put in place. Does the Government have a specific requirement that will ensure that there is proper measurement of the policy’s effectiveness?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

That will rely on the quality of the information gathering and reporting that is undertaken at local level, which is where the data will be generated. It is important that, as a consequence of the application of the guidance, data is collected effectively at local level.

When it comes to what we do with that information, we get into a discussion about whether the guidance has been effective in meeting expectations with regard to the Government’s intentions in responding to the petition. Some of that will emerge from inspections that are undertaken by Education Scotland and by us determining whether the proactive approach has led to a lower incidence of reported events, which is what we would like to happen as a result of the application of the guidance.

Reporting needs to be undertaken to ensure that we have a picture of whether our policy approach is effective and is leading to good practice at local level. If we find that that is not the case, we will have to revisit some of the

issues.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Will you be looking for uniformity of data gathering across councils?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

Yes, we will certainly need to have consistency across local authorities.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I want to go back to the issue of who is responsible for deeming the use of seclusion or isolation rooms to be appropriate. Some of those spaces have been deemed to be appropriate by people who have been responsible for supporting a young person, but the parents have regarded them as inappropriate. In making progress on the issue, do you envisage there being parental involvement in defining what is acceptable when it comes to seclusion, as opposed to the abolition of isolation rooms?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

To go back to a point that I made, I have seen photographs of seclusion rooms that I judge not to be appropriate, so I have to accept that practice has not been appropriate so far. If I accept that, other people in the system have to accept it as well. One purpose of the guidance is to improve practice. We want to ensure that, as a consequence of our issuing the guidance, we actually improve practice at local level and that the guidance gives pause for thought to improve and strengthen the provision.

One of the fundamental points of my evidence to the committee today, which is central to the whole discussion, is that there must be considered and careful preparation of the support arrangements for any young person who has additional support needs. If that process is to be good practice in any shape or form, it must involve parents and carers. For example, what organisation would not take seriously the communication passport that my constituent Mrs Sanger has put in place for Laura, as it has been devotedly put together with quality and depth of information? Why would that not be embraced by an organisation as a fabulous resource to help it to understand how it can best support Laura and her needs?

As part of that, as a provider looks at the difficult territory that it might get into when situations escalate, having parental involvement in identifying how a situation might be de-escalated would provide crucial information to assist the provider to do that satisfactorily. Parental and carer involvement in that process is absolutely crucial.

The importance of the journey to improve practice cannot be overstated. The guidance is designed to help with that and to encourage more of the many examples around the country of thoughtful and careful preparation of plans to support young people and ensure that their needs are met. That is an essential part of the system that we have in place. Members of the committee will have heard me and other ministers talking about the importance that we attach to the policy principle of getting it right for every child or young person. We have to ensure that that is followed through in practice in the provision that is put in place and, if it is not, we have to be open to being challenged about exactly that.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you. We have no more questions. Do members have any comments on how the committee should take forward the petition? Alternatively, we might want an opportunity to reflect on the Deputy First Minister’s evidence. Perhaps the clerks could produce a note for us to consider at a future public meeting of the committee. There is lots of food for thought in the evidence that we have heard today and in the comments that the petitioner and others have made. Is that acceptable?

Members indicated agreement.

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

Can I just add one other point, convener? Obviously, I intend to publish the guidance at the end of May, but I want to have the opportunity to reflect on any thinking from the committee before I take that final decision. I am anxious to make progress and to publish the guidance so, if the committee could provide me with its thoughts reasonably soon, that would give me the opportunity to reflect on them and see whether the guidance needs to change any further to reflect the issues that committee wishes to raise.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I think that we would want to respond positively to that offer, which is helpful and important, not so much for the committee but for the petitioner, who has been persistent on the question for such a long time. She has commented that there has been progress and she has welcomed the engagement with the Scottish Government on the matter.

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

If it would help the committee to have sight of the draft guidance as it stands, I am happy to provide that to the clerks for the committee to reflect on.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

That would be useful. There are quite a number of things that we want to take forward on that. I thank the cabinet secretary for his response to the petition.

I suspend the meeting briefly to allow the Scottish Government officials to change.

09:44 Meeting suspended.

09:46 On resuming—

  1. 09:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 39
  2. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 26
  3. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 38
  4. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 17
  5. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  6. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.