Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Armed Forces (School Visits) (PE1603)

Thursday 20 April 2017 Public Petitions Committee About 10:00–10:30 Petitions 38 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

38 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The next petition is PE1603, on ensuring greater scrutiny, guidance and consultation on armed forces visits to schools in Scotland. The petition was lodged by Mairi Campbell-Jack and Douglas Beattie on behalf of Quakers in Scotland and ForcesWatch. Copies of the petitioners’ recent submission and correspondence from the Deputy First Minister have been circulated with the clerk’s note on the petition. Accompanying the Deputy First Minister for this evidence session are Marie Swinney, team leader, and Katherine McNab, policy adviser. As with the two previous petitions, we will move straight to questions from the committee.

Deputy First Minister, as you know, the committee has received a submission on the petition from Skills Development Scotland. In your submission, you note that Skills Development Scotland’s

“careers services … are shaped by the Scottish Government’s Career Information, Advice and Guidance Strategy and the recent refresh of the Youth Employment Strategy.”

You go on to say that they

“align with the recommendations of the Commission on Developing the Young Workforce … so there is a range of existing guidance to ensure that careers advice is impartial and focused upon the individual’s needs.”

As well as being impartial, do the various strategies support the provision of careers advice that presents a full and accurate picture of careers, such as outlining the possible risks as well as opportunities that particular career choices may represent?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

The central requirement of a careers service must be to provide a dispassionate assessment of any career opportunity and how it would relate to the skills, interests, attributes and outlook of any individual young person who interacts with the service, so my answer to that is yes.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

In some of the submissions that we have received, references have been made to studies carried out by organisations such as Medact and Combat Stress that consider the longer-term outcomes experienced by some people who have joined the armed forces. How does the Scottish Government take account of such reports when reflecting on armed forces visits to schools and ensuring that young people are supported to choose post-16 destinations that will enable them to fulfil their potential in the long run?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

The key point is the one that the convener raised with me, which lies at the heart of the petition: in any careers information, advice and guidance, it is a requirement that advice be presented about all attributes of a particular career choice—the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats—and that that be relevant to the perspectives, interests, attributes and experience of the individual young person who seeks the advice. A tailored approach must be taken to meet the needs of young people in relation to that advice. It must also be ensured that, when that assessment is made for young people, that is done in a truly dispassionate way.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

The nub of the matter for the petitioners is that, whenever anyone comes to demonstrate a career opportunity, they will always try to be as positive as they can be about that career and to make it look as good as possible. That is a given, but is that an inherent part of the armed forces’ approach?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

I am not sure that I agree with Mr Whittle’s presumption.

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

My apologies—I did not choose my words well. I am not sure that I agree with Mr Whittle’s proposition.

To return to my first answer to the convener, careers advice must be dispassionate; it must give the whole picture. It must cover not only what might be exciting about the career, but what might be risky about it. I would be interested to assess the careers advice that I might have been given about where I have ended up and the relationship between the excitement and the risk.

It is essential that careers advice is presented in that fashion. A core part of the curriculum for excellence’s purpose is to equip young people with the decision-making capability to be able to look at what is presented to them and to make a judgment—so that they can weigh up something and know that it is right for them and to weigh up something else and know that it is wrong for them.

There is an obligation—this is an implicit part of careers information, advice and guidance—that careers advice must be dispassionate and must present the whole picture. That enables young people to make their judgments about what is, and is not, appropriate for them.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

When someone gives dispassionate advice on a career in the armed forces, do you expect them to highlight the issues mentioned by Medact and Combat Stress on the long-term consequences of such a career?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

I would have thought that that is fair material to be part of that assessment.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Concerns have been expressed about the possibility of some schools being targeted, particularly in areas with higher rates of deprivation and that such schools have—allegedly—received a disproportionate number of visits. Would that concern you if that were the case?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

First, I have no information that supports that point and it would be wrong of me to suggest otherwise. I have seen the communication that the Ministry of Defence has shared with the committee, which makes it clear that that approach is not taken.

A career in the armed forces is one of the employment possibilities for young people in Scotland, so it must be presented as part of the range of available activities. We have in place a good framework through developing Scotland’s young workforce. Back in 2014, Sir Ian Wood produced that fantastic piece of work for the Government. The framework is being used widely across the school system, with a lot of employer engagement and participation at the local level. That is helping to structure many aspects of the interaction between schools and the world of work. Of course, the armed forces are part of that world of work, and information about them should be presented in the dispassionate way that I have talked about in that context.

10:15

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

You said that you were not aware of areas being targeted. Do you see a role for the Government in collecting data, which is what the petitioner calls for, to ensure that there is a system that would enable you to find out whether that is the case?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

Through the activity around developing Scotland’s young workforce, we are encouraging schools now to be much more engaged with the world of work. We have not collected data so far on the existence or the substance of that activity. Obviously, we can give consideration to whether that would be appropriate, but I am mindful of how much information we are trying to collect from our schools, given my general desire to reduce the volume of bureaucracy that we require on the part of schools. Ultimately, the school leadership will make judgments about the interaction that the school has with the world of work and will ensure that that is appropriate to the needs of very young people and is presented effectively in all circumstances.

Edward Mountain Con Highlands and Islands
link

I remind the committee that I was a soldier for 12 years, and that my son is a serving soldier. That might affect my questions.

Mr Swinney, do you accept that soldiers today are professionally trained, and that the cost of training them up to the standards that are required to deal with the equipment that they are issued with is considerably more than it was when I joined the Army, and that, therefore, the military makes a huge investment in ensuring that it gets the right people involved and that those people then complete the training? Do you accept that what is important to the military is that it gets the right people rather than that it gets a great quantity of people and that, therefore, the Army must ensure that the people who it gets are happy in their jobs? There is no point in the Army taking someone through basic and advanced training only for them to leave. Do you accept that the Army is looking for that person to have a long career of at least six years, and more likely 12 or 22 years, which is a good career? Do you accept that that is the premise from which the Army is starting this process?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

I think that that would be a pretty fair point.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

On the issue of the dispassionate approach to giving information about all the options around someone’s career, the petition flags up the fact that the Army comes into schools not only in relation to careers visits, but also in relation to things that are involved in the curriculum, and that, often, the connection between the armed forces and the school will be not be about careers but instead about affording people other opportunities. Would that dispassionate approach be reflected in those visits, too? What safeguards are there around that kind of softer contact with schools?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

Fundamentally, the judgment about that sort of contact—which is different from contact around recruitment—concerns the relevance to the curriculum. That connects to what Mr Mountain said. From the perspective of elements of the curriculum such as science, technology, engineering and mathematics—the STEM subjects—for example, it might be possible to make something more easily understood by using an example involving something to do with the military. However, that would ultimately be a professional judgment for people to make about what would be an appropriate exemplification for a particular topic in the curriculum. We rely on members of our teaching profession, particularly through curriculum for excellence, to make judgments about what is an appropriate exemplification in relation to aspects of the curriculum, and to deploy that judgment as they see fit.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

The petition addresses the issue of consent and the involvement of pupils and parents or guardians in decisions about education. We have received different views on that. The Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland, Tam Baillie, is of the view that it should be assumed that children and young people in secondary school are able to give informed consent. However, the Scottish Parent Teacher Council stated that

“any proposed armed forces recruitment activity must be subject to detailed consultation, and the view of parents listened to and respected.”

Do you support the call for consent to be given in advance of any armed forces visit and, if so, do you see a role for Scottish Government guidance in setting out rights and responsibilities in that regard?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

Fundamentally, the issues around where consent is secured must be carefully judged by individual schools. I make that comment in the context of my belief, with which Parliament will be familiar, that schools should be involved in a very active on-going process of parental dialogue on all issues. I would want to encourage in schools an extensive and deep process of dialogue with parents on a habitual basis. That is good for the school and good for the parental community, and it creates strong, well-founded and well-supported schools. Any issues of consent are most effectively resolved within the context of that dialogue.

Once young people are 16, they are free to offer their own consent on such issues, and that becomes a complicating factor in the consideration of all these questions.

The issue is best resolved locally, through the encouragement of active parental involvement in the school’s agenda and by ensuring that at all times the school leadership is operating in an environment where it is seeking consent in the parental community.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I hope that we would all agree that the armed forces should be seen as a very legitimate career and one that is as potentially fulfilling as any other. It seems that with the petition we need to square a circle. Together Scotland and the petitioners have suggested that the issue should be subject to a child rights and wellbeing impact assessment. Would you consider commissioning that?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

I am certainly happy to consider whether such an approach should be taken. Obviously, in such a circumstance we would have to weigh up a range of factors. I am happy to give consideration to that point.

Edward Mountain Con Highlands and Islands
link

A particular concern has been expressed in evidence about armed forces visits to special schools. The petitioners call for an inquiry into such visits, which should look at whether they should be prohibited. Are you are aware of that issue and do you have any views on such a prohibition?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

I am not aware of that at all, so if there was more detail that the committee could share with me on it, I would be happy to hear it.

Edward Mountain Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am not aware that such visits are undertaken, but the petitioners raised the issue, so I was asked to ask about it.

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

If you could help me with that, I would be happy to explore the issue.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

What is evident to the committee is the petitioners’ strength of feeling. They are seeking reassurance that vulnerable young people or young people who have fewer economic opportunities are not disproportionately being drawn into a life in the armed forces without a proper understanding of its consequences, simply because of their circumstances.

I return to the question that Rona Mackay asked about the idea that young people in poorer communities are targeted because they are vulnerable to the lure, if I can call it that, of a life in the armed forces. I am not suggesting that I agree with any of that; I am putting it like that simply to play devil’s advocate. In essence, those are the petitioners’ concerns.

I said at a previous meeting that poverty is the greatest recruiting sergeant for the Army. That is perhaps how the issue has been characterised in the past. How do you respond to that? We have had an interesting conversation about the measured way in which you would want to deal with the matter. The argument that underpins the petition, which has been expressed quite strongly by the petitioners, is that there is an injustice or potential exploitation here. I am not suggesting that the armed forces would want to be party to that, but the petitioners’ sense is that that is happening. As a Government, how do you respond to that? Do you have a role to play in addressing such concerns?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

I quite understand the concern that has been expressed by the petitioners. In general, one of the great strengths of the petitions process is that it provides an opportunity for members of the public who are concerned about certain issues to have them aired in an organised parliamentary fashion so that we can reflect on them. I have nothing but respect for the motivations of all the petitioners who come forward with a point of view. They are citizens of our country, and they are entitled to be heard properly and with respect.

In this case, I have tried to reassure the petitioners by considering the issue within the context of our general approach to careers guidance. Our general approach to careers guidance is to make sure that, when young people engage with careers advice, they get dispassionate advice and they hear about all the ups and the downs of a particular career so that they can make their own judgment about it. If I found that that was not the case, I would be deeply troubled. That is true in relation to any career, not just a career in the armed forces. Young people need to be properly advised about the ups and downs of every career that they might decide to pursue.

That is my first and main point of reassurance; I hope that it helps. In all circumstances, regardless of what career a young person is contemplating, they are entitled to a dispassionate assessment of its ups and downs.

My second point concerns work that is in progress. The thinking behind the Government’s agenda on education, which is widely supported in Parliament, in our local authorities and in the country, relates to the attainment challenge. At the heart of the attainment challenge lies making sure that every young person in our country can fulfil their potential regardless of their background—in other words, we must ensure that poverty is not an inhibitor to young people fulfilling their potential. I stress that I accept that that is work in progress, but we are striving to address the matter. I hope that that partly addresses the concern that, somehow, there is a predisposition for young people from deprived backgrounds to end up in the armed forces because it is the only option available to them, if I can put it as crudely as that.

I return to Mr Mountain’s point about what the Army and the military are looking for. Increasingly, the armed forces are recruiting on the basis of the skills that they require rather than on the basis of the volume of applicants. It is not just a case of being a numbers game; it is about having a range of people who can do certain things. That changes some of the dynamics of the discussion.

Out of all that, there is an obligation on us as ministers to make sure that we are presiding over an education system that is able to fulfil the potential of young people and to equip them with the educational capability and the skills that will enable them to fulfil their potential.

10:30

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

I asked earlier about data collection. The petitioners have had recurring problems trying to obtain information from the armed forces. Would you consider asking for a commitment from the armed forces to make accessible, good-quality data available to the public or to the Parliament?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

I am happy to do so and if the committee wants to specify what it thinks would help in the discussion I am happy to make a request to the United Kingdom Government in relation to those points.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

To reiterate a point that I made earlier, I hear what you say about careers and the needs of the modern armed forces as opposed to what happened in the past. However, there is a question about how the armed forces now come into schools in a way that is not directly related to careers in the armed forces. In some areas, it may be that the forces can offer fun things to do that other groups and organisations cannot offer and it is a kind of soft power, with young people getting to do interesting, team-building activities with the armed forces. There is perhaps a suspicion—that may be too strong a word—on the part of the petitioners around how that could become a gateway to recruitment.

I am not sure whether you have a view on the guidance that you would offer to schools on that. Perhaps we can find out more from the Ministry of Defence on how it views such activity by the armed forces in schools.

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

That is a slightly more difficult issue because, in our developing Scotland’s young workforce activity, we are generally encouraging schools to be much closer to the world of work, so we want businesses and economic organisations—including the armed forces—to be able to demonstrate what the world of work involves.

The overwhelming majority of school interaction with the world of work will not be with the armed forces; it will be with local companies and local organisations that are able to demonstrate what it is like to work in particular areas and to give work experience.

Schools are now involved in much more systemic work experience activity. For young people who are on a more vocational pathway through school, such work experience will increasingly dominate their journey through the education system and we judge that to be a good thing. However, a very small minority of that work experience will be in relation to the armed forces.

I accept the convener’s point that such work experience might be a softer introduction to the armed forces, but it might also be a softer introduction to a chemicals firm or to a social enterprise provider. It is about how we manage it so that people do not get the wrong impression. That is a slightly more difficult thing for us to police when we have generally agreed that exposing young people to the world of work and making that transition more seamless is a desirable policy objective.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Okay. The petitioners make the point that choosing a life in the armed forces could bring with it more risk than other careers but they are not suggesting in any way—and nor are we as a committee—that it is not a legitimate career choice for people.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I do not know whether this is a question or a comment and I do not know the answer—perhaps it is something that we can explore. It seems to me that the route to armed forces is through the cadets; the air training corps or the army cadets can be a gateway to a full career in the armed forces. The petitioner has an issue with direct recruitment from schools and perhaps that is a bit of a red herring, because the real recruitment process is through the cadets.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

It would be useful to have a conversation with the Ministry of Defence on the point that Rona Mackay makes around data collection, the sense of the environment in which everyone is operating during the visits and the extent to which it sees the cadets having such a role. The MOD may make the case for working with young people involved in the cadets, as it might be an opportunity to create a bit of space and energy in their lives and a structure that they would not have had otherwise. That contentious point is at the heart of the issue in the petition.

I thank the Deputy First Minister for coming to the committee. We have come to the end of our questions and comments. What suggestions do members have for dealing with the petition?

Edward Mountain Con Highlands and Islands
link

I apologise, convener, if I should have made this comment earlier. When I joined the army, I certainly knew the risks. Mr Swinney is right to say that we must take cognisance of the fact that the army has dropped from 200,000 people, as it was when I joined, to 82,000 people. It is looking for a particular set of skills. I repeat the point about the cost of training for each soldier. That cost means that it is vital to get the right people and saying that the armed forces are trying to recruit people who are just looking for a way forward is wrong.

It is good that Mr Swinney is going to write to the MOD. The last time that the committee considered the petition, I thought that you should ask the relevant people in Scotland to come and give evidence on what they do. I see no reason why they would not do that. That would help the committee understand what the Army is trying to achieve with the teams that it sends out. I do not think that there is anything sinister in it and I am sure that the Army would welcome the opportunity to come to the committee.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The committee is in the process of taking up the offer of a briefing from the Ministry of Defence on how it sees such matters. That is an important point and following that briefing we will be able to make decisions on how we report back to the committee.

I suggest that we reflect on the Deputy First Minister’s evidence and ask the clerks to produce a report so that we can consider at a later meeting what action to take. Is it agreed that that is how we will take the petition forward?

Members indicated agreement.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I thank the Deputy First Minister for his evidence on all three petitions. Given how busy you are, we appreciate your giving us three petitions-worth in one visit. I am sure that the rest of your day will be a doddle in comparison.

10:38 Meeting suspended.

10:41 On resuming—

  1. 09:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 39
  2. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 26
  3. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 38
  4. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 17
  5. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  6. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.