Our next new petition is PE1581, by Duncan Wright, on behalf of Save Scotland’s School Libraries, which is on school libraries—believe it or not. I welcome Duncan Wright to the meeting. He is accompanied by Yvonne Manning, from the Chartered Institute of Library and Information Professionals in Scotland. I invite Mr Wright to introduce the subject to us, after which we will ask questions.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
School Libraries (PE1581)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael McMahon Lab 9
- Duncan Wright 6
- Yvonne Manning Chartered Institute of Library and Information Professionals in Scotland 4
- Jackson Carlaw Con 4
- Hanzala Malik Lab 3
- Kenny MacAskill SNP 1
- John Wilson Ind 1
The record
28 contributionsGood morning, everybody. I will make three main points, as a lot of what we will discuss is covered in the petition. I will first give a bit of background on why we are calling for a national strategy for school libraries in Scotland.
We firmly believe that school libraries are unique in their ability to support teaching and learning and that they should be the central resource of every school, open every day and staffed by a professionally trained librarian. We believe that all learners should have equal access to a qualified school librarian.
Currently, there is no national strategy and, unfortunately, young people in Scotland are subject to a postcode lottery with regard to the level of school library service that they receive. That is resulting in educational inequality. I will highlight the situation regarding school libraries in some areas of Scotland.
Schools in Glasgow share one librarian between every two schools; Renfrewshire has only seven librarians across 11 schools; in South Ayrshire, library assistants have replaced professionally qualified librarians; and in Fife, school librarians who have retired have been replaced with library assistants, which I think is a hidden cut. As for Dumfries and Galloway, the librarian at Dumfries academy retired and was not replaced, and responsibility for the library was given to the head of English instead; moreover, I believe that Lockerbie academy currently has no librarian.
Within the past financial year, East Renfrewshire Council has proposed moving to a model of sharing one librarian between two schools, and Falkirk Council has proposed a 50 per cent reduction in the number of school librarians and closure of the centralised school library service. Most recently of all, Argyll and Bute Council has proposed the deletion of all 10 school librarian posts.
The Scottish Parliament information centre briefing comments that the number of school library staff fell in 2012 but that since then the number has remained relatively stable. However, the data neither tells us how many of those staff are professionally qualified librarians nor shows how many of them are shared between schools.
I hope that our initial petition has already highlighted the positive impact that a school library can have. The report “Impact of School Libraries on Learning: Critical review of published evidence to inform the Scottish education community” sets out a considerable body of international evidence showing the impact of school libraries including—and maybe most important—positive attitudes towards learning and higher examination scores. However, I must point out that the report made it clear that, in order to have that impact, schools need a qualified, full-time librarian who is proactive and has managerial status.
In addition to the research that I have already submitted, I draw the committee’s attention to the junior certificate school programme support service demonstration library project, which was set up in Ireland. In 2001, the Irish Minister for Education and Science provided funding for that project as part of the early literacy initiative, and 11 schools that were identified as serving socioeconomically disadvantaged communities were given funding for a fully resourced school library, managed by a professionally qualified full-time librarian. Over a three-year period, the project underwent a major evaluation, the main findings of which included: significantly improved reading scores among the students at the schools in question; continually increased book borrowing by students; evidence of better attendance; improved levels of concentration; and increased interest and motivation among students. The official report on the project, “Room for Reading”, which was published in 2005, said:
“the findings demonstrate over and over again, that well stocked, well managed school libraries, with access to books through structured library programmes that are directed towards the learning needs and interests of even the most reluctant and hesitant readers, can have impacts that are very significant.”
Perhaps I can finish by giving the committee an idea of our vision of a national strategy or at least where we think such a strategy should begin. We welcome the recent publication of the national strategy for public libraries in Scotland. As school librarians, we work closely with our colleagues in the public library sector, and this would be an ideal time to launch a framework for a national strategy for school libraries in Scotland.
In that respect, we think that four initial steps could be taken. First of all, there are no definitive figures on the number or proportion of schools that have a school library and a professionally qualified full-time school librarian, and we recommend that the education department ensures that such information becomes part of the annual data submission from schools.
Secondly, we recommend that the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning considers examining in greater depth the role that school librarians and school libraries play in supporting pupils’ literacy levels, enjoyment of reading, information literacy skills and access to knowledge, as well as their self-esteem, confidence, and sense of safety and wellbeing in the school community.
Thirdly, we ask that the cabinet secretary publicly welcomes school libraries’ demonstrable contribution to educational attainment and discusses with Education Scotland the prospect of embedding school libraries into its inspection framework.
Finally, we recommend that the cabinet secretary has a member of staff acting as lead for libraries to support the work of headteachers and school librarians in delivering positive outcomes for pupils.
School libraries are not just about shelves of books, computers and the issuing and the returning of books. A good school library with a full-time professionally qualified librarian is all about a relationship and a culture. A good school librarian can put the right book into the right child’s hand at the right time.
Thank you very much, Mr Wright. I open up the discussion to committee members. I think that you have made a very powerful and persuasive argument, but there are some issues that still have to be examined.
I am persuaded of the merits of school libraries. Given that we are facing financial pressures, would there be any merit in dovetailing the national strategy with the schools strategy, certainly in respect of new-build schools? I once visited a new school that was being built in the north-east of Scotland where the library was going to be available to the public and not simply the school. It is a bit like the situation with school sports facilities—why should facilities not remain open out of school hours if they are built in a manner that allows that? Could or should libraries, certainly in smaller communities, be not simply for the school but for the community?
There are many examples of school and public libraries being shared in community schools. That approach makes sense and it can be successful, although it depends on the staff. That takes me to the argument that we are making about professionalism and having professional librarians in facilities. Such a library will have the same children and young people but just in a different context. School librarians and public librarians sometimes work in profoundly different ways in delivering the best service for our children and young people. However, especially in Aberdeenshire, there are examples of community library facilities within schools. Obviously, they are different uses and such facilities are open to the public of all ages as well as for young people in the education service.
Where that approach is well planned and is not just something stuck on the edge of an existing facility—new-builds can be a good example of that—and where consideration is given to the professionalism of the staff, it really works and it makes sense.
As this is book week, the petitioners are here at the right time, because people are in the right frame of mind. You have made some very good suggestions. As an ex-councillor in Glasgow City Council, I know that some libraries there are in the wrong locations because people have moved on and housing schemes have developed elsewhere, so access to a lot of libraries is not as good as it ought to be. I feel that our schools could play an important role in providing library facilities to local residents and, more important, to the students. Kenny MacAskill is absolutely right that we need to look at that more closely, because it helps to deal with financial issues around buildings and, more important, it helps with the location of buildings. Kenny MacAskill used the word “dovetail”. If we can dovetail services, that is ideal.
I totally agree that libraries play an immense role in educational attainment for youngsters. I have been to many countries overseas and I have found the lack of libraries and the impact that that has on citizens to be quite marked. You are absolutely right that we need to look at the issue. I know that libraries are primarily the responsibility and jurisdiction of local authorities, but they need help with that. They do not have all the resource to be able to deliver what we are asking them to. It is a very tall order. The Scottish Government needs to intervene to support local authorities in that and we need to look at the issue more strategically. I totally agree with the petition and I think that we should take it forward to try to achieve that goal.
11:45
I welcome those comments. A strategic overview is exactly what is required. I do not think that local authorities understand the issues.
On the issue of dovetailing, I agree with Yvonne Manning that that works, but it is important to remember that it is not a one-size-fits-all solution. It must be done individually for each school. Public libraries offer a wonderful service to a completely different set of people from those who are served by school libraries. You might have a bookbug session with some 18-month-old babies, but it would be difficult to have a class of teenagers in at the same time. However, there is scope for dovetailing. I know that the system works well in Aberdeenshire, which Kenny MacAskill visited.
I do not want to suggest for a moment that local authorities do not understand and appreciate the challenge that is faced—as an ex-councillor, I can assure you that they do; it is just that that they cannot face that challenge by themselves.
On the issue of managing a school library, as you say, the school library is not just another classroom. I am talking about having a proper library facility in an area that everyone can access.
On the issue of dovetailing services, as Duncan Wright said, we work closely in partnership with our public library colleagues. Public libraries face a challenge with regard to engaging teenagers. School librarians know those young people; that is their community. A national strategy for school libraries would help to increase the dovetailing of services and would enable us to see where the strengths are in each sector, so that greater partnership working can take place for the benefit of young people.
I note from the information that we have before us that you have received quite a lot of high-profile support for your petition from people such as Christopher Brookmyre, Val McDermid and Ian Rankin. However, I was particularly struck by this comment:
“As Head of English in a school which closed down its library, I know what a devastating impact this had. I also know what a difference the restoration of our library has made.”
Can you give us an idea of the impact of a school library being closed down? You talked about the benefits of having a library, and I think that there is an assumption that there are benefits. However, can you quantify those benefits? Can you show statistically the difference in the attainment levels and so on between schools that have libraries and librarians and those that do not?
I do not think that any statistical research has been done. The Dorothy Williams report, “Impact of School Libraries on Learning”, has been quoted numerous times. It took various pieces of information that are available and made a case for school libraries, but I am not sure whether any statistics are available.
I am a school librarian and I know what would happen if I was not in the school. I know how classes would suffer. There would be no author events, no one would be teaching information literacy and there would be less emphasis on the teaching of reading for pleasure. Further, there would be no safe haven for pupils who feel that the school playground is a scary place. The value of having somewhere that pupils can go that is safe and is a place where they can get away from what happens in the playground is almost unquantifiable.
School librarians have a huge knowledge of the curriculum, and are able to offer additional support to our teaching colleagues, who have been quite open about how much pressure they are under at the moment. As soon as a member of the support staff is taken away—particularly the school librarian—another issue is created.
I take that point. The provision of school libraries and librarians concerns quality as much as quantity.
A thought has occurred to me as I have listened to you speak. Is the reduction in service in relation to librarians a consequence simply of cost reduction as a result of the council tax freeze or whatever else is causing straitened circumstances in local authorities, or are you articulating a concern that there is a broader growth of a lack of understanding of the value that librarians bring to the educational service? Where does the balance of the issue rest?
It is an interesting thing that, if people are getting a service, they do not really need to know in detail what I do as a librarian. However, local authorities’ backs are against the wall, especially in relation to education services, and they have a much smaller percentage of people that they can target to save money because of the protection of teachers, so it is really important that people understand what we do. At present, people are just thinking about the pounds that they need to save.
The situation in which our school librarians and our school library services are being removed, or certainly degraded, is a result of the budget savings that local authorities need to make. However, because there is no national strategy, the local authorities do not fully understand the implications of the decisions that they are making, and they will not know what they will miss until we are not there. That is frustrating for us, and that is why we lodged the petition.
We want the decision makers in local authorities, who have to make these decisions because of the budget savings that are required, to really understand the implications of what they are doing. They should not see us as easy targets, or as discretionary services.
So the answer to my question is both. The lack of understanding and the absence of a national strategy, which has accelerated that lack of understanding, are, in the face of pressures, making the librarian service too easy an option within the difficult decisions that have to be made. That is where you are coming from.
Yes.
Thank you.
A well-argued case has been put to us this morning. How do colleagues suggest we take the petition forward? Who should we speak to in order to progress it?
It is clear that a national strategy is needed. That has been missing for a long time. As I said, as a councillor in a local authority, I felt that libraries were vulnerable. I remember that there was a strike once and somebody said, “Well, we won’t need to worry about that strike.” That was a negative attitude. It is important to have a national strategy.
We should write to the Scottish Government to ask it how it feels about the issue and whether it believes there would be merit in putting together a national strategy. COSLA is another organisation that we should consult, because it represents a lot of the local authorities and it might have an opinion to share. We should ask COSLA whether it believes that there would be merit in having a joint strategy and whether the Scottish Government should engage with the local authorities to put together something that would be effective.
We must have a national minimum standard of libraries in our cities and villages, but that can happen only if the Scottish Government gets involved.
What Hanzala Malik says about the absence of a national strategy is valid. It occurs to me that we might also draw the petition to the attention of the Scottish Youth Parliament because it seems to me that, given the direct relationship that it has with young people, it would be a positive thing for it to become involved in providing support for the campaign and lobbying councillors and politicians more generally on it. The issue is important and, notwithstanding the work that we will do, it would be good to communicate its merits to the Scottish Youth Parliament as well.
I absolutely agree with that.
His name escapes me, but we had a brief conversation with one of the MSYPs. I can pass his name to you later, if you like.
I think that Jackson Carlaw’s point is that the committee should bring the matter to the Scottish Youth Parliament’s attention and get it involved.
Absolutely. Super.
I suggest that we write to the Educational Institute of Scotland to get its views on the petition. We heard today that reductions in school library services have an impact on educational attainment and on teaching staff.
We should also write to Unison Scotland, because I believe that it represents a number of school librarians. It might be able to give us up-to-date information on the impact of potential cuts to the library service and on how many school libraries are being staffed by unqualified librarians. Their role is still valuable, but it might not be as valuable as that of a qualified professional librarian. If we write to Unison, it might be able to give us some of those details.
There is a School Library Association. Is it already supporting the petition?
Yes. It is fully behind the petition.
We will take the petition forward. As I said, you made a strong and persuasive argument and we will pursue the matter as strenuously as we can. We will keep you updated on the responses that we get and have dialogue with you about taking the petition forward. Thank you for coming along this morning and for bringing the petition to the committee.
As we decided earlier that we would go into private session to discuss agenda items 3 and 4, I close the meeting to the public.
11:55 Meeting continued in private until 12:19.
In this meeting
Everything on 24 Nov 2015 →- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 48
- 10:30 New Petitions Petitions · 19
- 10:45 New Petitions Petitions · 40
- 11:30 New Petitions Petitions · 28
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.