Item 2 is consideration of new petitions. The first new petition is PE1582, by Karen Harvey, on compulsory pet insurance. I welcome Karen to the meeting and I invite her to speak to the petition. She has no more than five minutes, after which we will ask questions.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Compulsory Pet Insurance (PE1582)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Karen Harvey 21
- Michael McMahon Lab 8
- John Wilson Ind 5
- Hanzala Malik Lab 4
- Kenny MacAskill SNP 3
- Jackson Carlaw Con 3
- David Torrance SNP 2
- Angus MacDonald SNP 2
The record
48 contributionsThank you, convener and members of the committee, for the opportunity to speak to you about my petition, which is on health insurance for pets becoming a legal requirement.
A requirement for third-party liability insurance for dogs was suggested a few years ago but was dismissed as it was felt that it would be an unfair tax on responsible dog owners. Pet health insurance is usually combined with coverage for third-party liability, so it therefore ensures that both we and our pets are protected.
Every year the Pet Food Manufacturers Association commissions a pet population report. In 2014, it was estimated that 46 per cent of households have pets—the totals include 9 million dogs and about 7 million cats—yet only 15 per cent of those households actually have pet insurance. According to Allianz Insurance, more people claim on their pet insurance than on their household or car insurance.
As with human medicine, veterinary medicine has advanced hugely. According to Sainsbury’s Bank, which provides pet cover, vet fees are escalating at a rate of 12 per cent per year—more than six times the rate of inflation. Vets say that that is the result of the development of new drugs and medical technologies.
I have some rough figures, which I obtained from an independent online survey in October this year, of some ailments and the cost of treating them. A dog with cataracts costs £1,700 to treat; a cat with a broken leg costs £2,000 to treat; and arthritis treatment for older dogs costs around £6,500 over five years. In addition, the cost of treating cancer could be around £8,000.
The most up-to-date figures that I could find of animals being put to sleep due to their owners’ inability to afford veterinary treatment were from a United Kingdom survey in 2012. The survey revealed that, in that year alone, 320,000 cats and dogs nationwide that could have been nursed back to health were victims of premature euthanasia. One vet has said that vets are in business to treat and save the lives of animals, not put them to sleep because of cost. Eight out of 10 vets surveyed by Sainsbury’s Bank said that they had seen pets endure pain because treatments were too expensive. In total, 2.5 million owners have turned down medical help for pets based on cost alone.
If the owner has insurance, that gives veterinary staff more treatment options when a pet is sick or injured and allows the owner to make an informed decision about the best course of action to take, always bearing in mind the animal’s welfare.
When someone is choosing pet insurance, it is important that they consider whether the policy is right for their circumstances. Cheapest is not always best, but with careful research there are still ways of making savings. More practical help can be obtained from veterinary professionals, who are all used to dealing with insurance companies and will be able to advise on suitable policies and help with filling in the forms. I was also able to find unbiased help via the internet to find the best deals, so information and help are already out there.
During my research on the subject, it became clear that most people I spoke to were in favour of compulsory pet insurance but were concerned that insurance companies would take advantage of that and significantly raise the cost of their premiums. Insurance companies are regulated by two bodies—the Financial Conduct Authority and the Prudential Regulation Authority. Insurance companies have a legal obligation to do things properly and, after speaking to the FCA, I know that the authorities have a duty to investigate any claim of unfair behaviour.
I spoke to various organisations, including the Scottish Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, the Dogs Trust, the British Veterinary Association and an independent vet. Although the SSPCA was unsure how making insurance compulsory would work, it encourages new owners to insure their pets and gives 40 days’ free insurance with new adoptions. It has apparently already had discussions with the BVA regarding some sort of affordable insurance scheme for pets.
The BVA produces a leaflet that advises of the benefits of pet insurance. The independent vet suggested that, if potential problems with monitoring and policing were addressed, compulsory health insurance would solve many welfare problems. The Dogs Trust always recommends that owners take out pet insurance, as it considers insurance to be an important part of responsible pet ownership.
I am aware that it would not be sensible to impose an immediate start to the requirement that all animals be insured. It would need to be a gradual process, so it would probably work better to bring it in for pets that are born after a certain date, thus limiting the need for exemptions due to previous conditions.
There is no national health service for pets and our pets are often life-savers. They are certainly the best companions in the world, giving us unconditional love and loyalty. In return, do we not owe it to them to give them the same when they need it?
Thank you, Karen. I find the petition particularly interesting. I had not given much thought to the matter previously. I am not a pet owner and am not up on such ideas, so I was not aware of any discussions that had taken place on the issue. However, I know that the UK Government consulted on potential insurance for third-party injuries caused by dogs—predominantly dangerous dogs. Have you investigated that? Why did the Government not introduce that measure? What reasons did it give for not pursuing it?
The Labour Government wanted to introduce such insurance, but it was quickly dismissed because it was felt that the only people who would take it out would be responsible pet owners, who were not the target that the proposal was meant to hit. The Government felt that it was unfair to responsible owners, so that is why it was dismissed.
Who would we get to ensure that pets were insured? Who would do the monitoring?
The Scottish Government is introducing microchipping for dogs next year, so the monitoring and policing of insurance could run along the same lines. I have found out that the police and local authorities will have scanners for microchips. Perhaps the insurance details could be on the same databases as the microchip details.
So you do not believe that there would be any additional bureaucracy or cost involved for public authorities. I can see why insurance companies may be interested in introducing compulsory insurance, because they would get payments that they would not otherwise get, but the cost to the public purse might be prohibitive, especially at a time when budgets are tight. Do you consider that to be the case?
No. If it ran along the same lines as the microchipping, that would not be the case.
Good morning. It is an interesting concept. However, you have alluded to the fact that the type of people who need the cover are those who can least afford the treatment; they are also the group of people who will be least able to afford the insurance.
There is also an element of individual human rights here, in that we would almost be forcing another tax on people. I am opposed to forcing additional burdens on people. Policing the approach would not be easy either.
Finally, if somebody did not buy the insurance because they simply could not afford it, that would mean that we would deny them a pet. That would be unreasonable and unfair.
I find it difficult to support the petition on those grounds.
link
Good morning, Karen. How much does pet insurance cost on average? I have a pet cat and pay insurance for it.
There is no average cost. It all depends on the type of pet that somebody has and where they live. As with all insurance, the cost is based on risk, so there are many things to take into account.
I will give you an example. I have a golden retriever who is now 12 years old, and I have paid £42 a month for her insurance since the day I got her at six months old. That might sound like a lot but, as she is now 12 years old, she has quite a number of conditions, which we claim the insurance for. We claim around £200 a month for her medications and treatments. She is still a happy, springy dog who loves to go her walks and wags her tail. Had we not had that insurance, she would not be here today.
10:15
link
So you are paying roughly £500 a year. Families on low incomes who have pets would be forced to take out insurance. You said that there are something like 9 million dogs and 7 million cats in the UK. Would the proposal not force families to abandon pets? Would there not be a huge increase in that?
Not really. I am not suggesting that any existing pet owners would have to go out and take out insurance all of a sudden. It would be for new additions to the family, such as pups born after a certain date, for example. I know that microchipping is supposed to be done at eight weeks so perhaps it could run along those lines, with insurance being taken out when a pup is born.
It would not really be feasible to expect all existing dogs to be insured. There would be so many exemptions that that would not work. If the requirement came in for new dogs and cats or whatever, it would not mean an additional financial burden for families. It might make a family think twice about whether they could afford to have the pet in the first place. If the requirement is approached in that way, I do not see that it will mean an increase in the number of abandoned dogs.
Good morning, Mrs Harvey. The briefing that we have received on the petition advises that pet insurance is not compulsory in any other part of the UK. Have you made any attempts to look at the situation in any other jurisdictions or countries?
Yes, I have and I could not find any country that has compulsory pet insurance.
Is there any indication that it is being looked at anywhere else?
I did not find any in my research.
During your inquiries, have you looked into the inclusion of pet insurance in household insurance policies, rather than creating a whole new raft of insurance premiums for owners? Have you spoken to any of the major house insurers to see whether they might offer that as part of their wider package?
No. I did not think about it being included in house insurance. I spoke to pet insurance companies, which were not keen to give any opinion on the suggestion at all.
If someone has house insurance with a certain company, it was suggested that having pet insurance with the same company means that there are discounts to be had.
It is just that some household accidents are caused by pets—we see adverts showing cats running along the mantelpiece and that sort of thing. I just wondered whether anybody had done any work with the companies that provide household insurance.
You indicated that the legislation that was proposed at Westminster was dropped because it was thought that only responsible owners would take out insurance. Was that the only reason why it was dropped?
As far as I know, yes. That is what I discovered.
Only responsible owners will take out pet insurance—because they are responsible owners. The difficulty is with the figures that you gave of 9 million dogs and 7 million cats. We have the experience of dangerous dogs and the owners who are less than responsible and will not look after their pets or take them for treatment. We often hear the SSPCA talking about incidents at canal banks and railway sidings and so on, where dogs are abandoned or cats are put in sacks. Will having compulsory pet insurance resolve such situations?
I do not think that they will ever be resolved. Unfortunately, we will always find that people do such things. It is the same with any law—murder is against the law, but people still do it. My proposal would not take that away completely, but I like to think that it would help. If a family gets a pet from a breeder, and the breeder is registered, they usually hand out four weeks’ free insurance. It would be up to the breeder to inform whoever is monitoring the system about the new owner. The new owner’s details would be on the insurance, so there would always be a register of who owned the dog or cat.
Should it be the responsibility of the breeder or the seller of the pet—whether it was a pet store or whatever—to make the new owner aware of the potential liabilities that they were taking on?
Yes, I think that that is a good idea.
You mentioned your golden retriever, which has medical conditions. We know that certain breeds have genetic abnormalities that could lead to medical intervention having to take place. Surely we could ask the breeders and the pet stores or other sellers of animals to make new owners aware of the potential cost of having a pet. This is the time of year when the slogan “A dog is for life, not just for Christmas” usually comes out, but surely we should be doing more to get sellers and others to make people aware of the potential financial liability if something happens to their pet.
Yes, I think that that is definitely a good idea. There are certain conditions related to some breeds. When someone takes out pet insurance, they have to research whether the conditions that their pet is liable to get are covered in the policy. That is quite easily done.
I can see the logical argument for why everybody should have pet insurance. There is a good reason for having it. The issue is the bureaucracy and the difficulties. I assume that you are not suggesting making it a criminal offence not to have pet insurance and that it would be a civil matter.
Yes.
How, then, do you envisage enforcing the measure? We have difficulties enforcing the television licence, which is currently not paid by a lot of people even though that is a criminal offence. We had difficulties with the previous pet licence, at 10 shillings or whatever it was. How would the proposal be funded? How would it be enforced? We would be seeking to enforce a financial penalty against people who had not taken out insurance because they did not have the financial wherewithal to do so.
As I said, I believe that it might run along the lines of microchipping. I tried to do a bit of research into the microchipping law, but I could not find out a lot of information about it. The database that exists for microchipping could be used for the information on insurance. There would also be a responsibility on veterinary practices. If an animal came into a veterinary practice needing treatment and was not insured, there would be a responsibility on the veterinary staff to report that to the authority that is looking after the matter. The staff would at least need to make the owner aware that the animal needed insurance. I think that there is 21 days’ grace in relation to microchipping. We could do something like that and give people a grace period to allow them to acquire insurance. I believe that there is also a financial penalty in relation to microchipping. Perhaps that could work with the insurance as well, which might help with the funding.
The discussion seems to have been about cats and dogs. Does the petition aim only at cats and dogs or are we talking about some of the more exotic pets that people get now? We do not microchip some of the things that people get from pet stores now.
That is right. For my purpose, we would have to start with dogs and cats. Small furries and things like that are different. Obviously treatments are not so expensive, advanced or in depth for small furries. As I understand it, people tend not to take their small furries to the vet unless they are really ill and, at that stage, there is not a lot that the vet can do anyway. I do not think that insuring them would be workable or feasible. It is the same with exotics. At this stage, I would start with dogs and extend it to cats.
Actually, I was going to ask the petitioner to define “pet” for the purposes of the petition.
I understand the idea and have done some very quick calculations. If there are 16 million cats and dogs across the UK, and 10 per cent of those are in Scotland, if your dog was an example, that would mean an £800 million cost in Scotland and £8 billion over time in the UK. I accept that there would be reductions as a consequence of scale, but I only have to say those figures to myself to understand that it is politically unlikely that any Government would seek to impose such a huge financial cost on the public. I do not see it as likely, I am afraid.
I am, however, interested to know what efforts the pet insurance industry makes to promote pet insurance directly to pet owners. Where do you think that falls short if so few pets are being insured?
That is a good point. An advertising campaign might be beneficial and it would be a good idea to promote pet insurance. Pet insurance companies advertise through television commercials and so on, but perhaps more in-depth advertising to make pet owners aware of potential costs could be done. There are discounts to be had if people do their research. If people take out an all-of-life policy that covers their pet from the day they get it to the day it dies, I know from my experience with my own dogs and other people’s pets that they will generally get back what they have paid into the insurance, and sometimes more.
I have a couple of points to make about some of the evidence that you have given this morning. You suggested that veterinary clinics should report people who do not have insurance. The problem with that is that the very people who I fear will not take out insurance because they do not have money will not take their pets to the vet because they fear that they will be reported for not having insurance.
I also need to reinforce the point that we would deny a lot of people the pleasure of keeping pets and people simply would not take out the insurance, which would mean that they would put themselves in a position where they are breaking the law. That has all sorts of implications for where they could take their pets, such as whether they could go to the vet or take them to public places, and whether their movement with their pet would be constrained. All those things come to mind. There are far more negatives than positives in the idea, although the idea is an ideal one. Unfortunately, we are up against the people who generally cannot afford to pay and that is what suggests to me that we would be putting pets in harm’s way rather than giving them a better quality of life.
10:30
You are right that there is always that risk. However, is that risk any greater than people not taking their pets to the vet anyway because they cannot afford the treatment?
I think that it is, unfortunately.
You do.
Yes. Sorry.
We seem to have exhausted our questions. As I have said, your petition is quite thought provoking, but there are some practical considerations that have to be taken into account.
It is not really for the Public Petitions Committee to adjudicate on the petition’s merits at the moment. We have to investigate the practicalities further, so we need to ask the Government, which would be responsible, what its views would be. You also highlighted a few charities that are already involved in the discussion and it would be useful to contact such organisations as the British Veterinary Association, the People’s Dispensary for Sick Animals and some of the others that you named. We will collate the information that you have given and write to the SSPCA and the Dogs Trust.
I would also be interested in seeing whether any of the pet insurance providers would be interested in discussing with us how they go about promoting pet insurance and how much they feel that they spend on that. I would like to know about the relationship between that and the uptake.
We could either talk to an individual company or an association of insurance companies.
Yes, whoever would be willing to give us some evidence. I would have thought that one would be typical of another.
We might want to check with local government because things such as compliance with the dangerous dogs legislation are administered through local authority dog wardens. It is a local authority responsibility and there would be implications for resources and costs.
Perhaps the dog wardens could be brought into it.
I am sure that the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities would have a view, given the local authorities’ responsibilities.
We need to sound out a wide range of organisations about the petition and the points that you have made. We will do that, collect the responses that we get, and then get in touch with you and see what we will do with the petition when we have a fuller picture from the organisations out there. Thank you for bringing such a thought-provoking petition to us this morning.
Thank you.
10:32 Meeting suspended.
10:34 On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 24 Nov 2015 →- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 48
- 10:30 New Petitions Petitions · 19
- 10:45 New Petitions Petitions · 40
- 11:30 New Petitions Petitions · 28
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.