Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Accessible Rail Travel (PE1575)

Tuesday 24 November 2015 Public Petitions Committee About 10:30–10:45 Petitions 19 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

19 contributions
Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

Our next petition is PE1575, by Alex Scott MBE, on accessible rail travel. Members have a note by the clerk, the petition and a Scottish Parliament information centre briefing, and will wish to note that, sadly, after lodging the petition Mr Scott passed away. In the circumstances, the petition is being taken forward by the Community trade union, which worked with Mr Scott on the petition. I welcome to the meeting Beverley Bambrough and Robert Mooney from Community, and I invite Ms Bambrough to speak to the petition, after which we will move to questions.

Beverley Bambrough Community
link

All aboard is the campaign for accessible rail travel in Scotland. I will introduce myself and my colleague. I am responsible for education and equality in the Community trade union. My colleague Robert Mooney is a key activist in Scotland in the National League of the Blind and Disabled. He works in Royal Strathclyde Blindcraft Industries at City Building, and he is the chair of the NLBD committee for Community and a member of our national executive.

We thank you for scheduling consideration of our petition and ensuring that the wish of a lifelong friend and campaigner—to ensure that safer transport remains high on the agenda of the Scottish Government—is fulfilled.

Why have we come? It would be remiss of us not to mention Alex Scott MBE, a very special man to us. Alex Scott was a lifelong trade unionist and campaigner for the rights of disabled people, particularly in Scotland. Alex, who was blind, was an activist, a campaigner and a much respected member of the National League for the Blind and Disabled, which became part of Community in 2000. He campaigned tirelessly to make sure that we never lost the ability to look at not just the large, high-level things that affect our everyday lives but the small matters that are sometimes seen as trivial to those who might not contemplate the impact of decisions that are made at a high level. Those decisions can make small but meaningful changes. Above all, Alex wanted to make meaningful differences to the lives of Scotland's blind community.

The all aboard campaign is a perfect example of Alex’s practical approach to campaigning. Tragically, it was to be Alex’s last campaign, as he passed away earlier this year. However, we are proud to present the petition on his behalf. I am sure that Alex will be looking down on Robert and me and will be willing us onwards, to ensure that we as a union continue to make a difference in people’s lives.

I turn to the campaign. Rail travel in Scotland is not always accessible in the way that we would want it to be for all disabled people. Why is that? Multiple factors make navigating different train lines and routes difficult for people with physical disabilities, particularly partially sighted people. Take the different train manufacturers that design trains. Each manufacturer will have buttons and handles in different positions, both on train main doors and in facilities such as toilets. Imagine, for a moment, not having your sight and being unable to find that button.

Alex once told me a tale of a man who wanted to be independent, working and travelling regularly on public transport. He was a proud man, who one day was travelling on the train alone. He needed to use the on-board facilities and entered the toilet after searching for the button, albeit with a little help from a fellow traveller. All did not go well. The man felt humiliated at the end of the journey. He could not find the button to exit the toilet and was stuck in it for a considerable amount of time.

Alex always said that it was about us enabling people—about the small and meaningful things. Here is a thought: if we could get manufacturers to agree to put buttons in the same place on trains, that would be small but meaningful.

Despite some improvements to disabled access at train stations, the fact that ScotRail staff no longer wear high-visibility jackets on platforms can make it difficult for a partially sighted person to see them when they need them most. A simple change can make all the difference to a partially sighted person—that is about being small but meaningful.

Community’s campaign is Alex’s campaign, above all. What are we seeking? Community believes that the Scottish Government must take responsibility for ensuring that Scotland’s rail network is accessible to all. Community has been working with colleagues in the Scottish Trades Union Congress disabled workers committee to promote the campaign. Recently we passed a motion at the STUC disabled workers conference calling on the committee to lend its support to Community—and to Alex—in lobbying the Scottish Government.

Specifically, the all aboard campaign has three key wishes to ask of the Scottish Government: for the Scottish Government to work with ScotRail and Community to standardise all buttons and signs across the rail network on both existing and future stock; for the Government to work with ScotRail to ensure that high-vis jackets are worn by all station staff—a simple thing that could be addressed more or less immediately; and for the Government to work with Community and other disabled groups in Scotland to promote that work and campaign for better disabled access to Scotland’s whole public transport network. Overall, we believe that undertaking that work in partnership with Community and other disabled groups will provide a safer, more equal and more accessible transport system for disabled travellers in Scotland.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

Thank you very much. I am not so much declaring an interest as informing people that I have had a discussion on the issue previously as the convener of the cross-party group on disability. The Scottish Accessible Transport Alliance had already raised the issue and we have invited the Minister for Transport and Islands to come to the next meeting of the CPG to discuss it.

Some of the issues that you raised came up as part of that discussion, which is why we wanted to invite the minister. Something that you did not mention is an apparent conflict due to the drive to have people using bicycles as much as possible. People are getting on to trains with their bikes to go to other destinations and the bikes are then taking up space that disabled people would otherwise have had access to.

Are you aware of that conflict between the Government’s desire to get people using bikes more, which means more bikes being taken on to public transport, and the need to make trains more accessible to people who have mobility problems and other issues?

Robert Mooney Community
link

I have never really thought about that before. I have a visual impairment and there are designated places on trains for bikes and there are designated places on trains for people with disabilities. I must admit that I, my wife, my son and my daughter-in-law all have quite severe visual impairments and I have never seen bikes as a major problem, to be honest. If there are going to be more bikes on the train as more people travel by bike and take their bikes on the train, that could probably cause a problem in the future.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

Do any committee members want to ask questions?

Hanzala Malik Lab Glasgow
link

I have no questions, just a comment. I think that it is a wonderful petition and it merits a lot of serious consideration. We should be writing to the Scottish Government to find out exactly what it is prepared to do to deal with the issues. It is an excellent petition.

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh Eastern
link

Do you have any international comparators? In a lot of the countries that I travel in, certainly in western Europe, the facilities that are provided for everybody on train services seem quite a bit better. I wonder whether that is down to procurement. Certainly the rail services in Germany and Spain that I have experienced in recent years seem to be much more regular, if I can put it that way. I do not know whether you have any information on that or know why that is.

Beverley Bambrough Community
link

I do not have any information or know why that is. I have a personal observation—I think that it is probably linked to how we procure things. We probably do not have joined-up partnership thinking when we are procuring things. If there is a multitude of different manufacturers, in order to bring some standardisation for the people who need to use the transport system, it would make logical sense to embed standardisation in every procurement process that goes through. When manufacturers were designing their trains, they would then have that one standard to work to. That would mean that everybody, no matter where they were in the UK, would be able to access the transport system.

10:45

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

We are talking about people who have visual impairments, but disability comes in a range of shapes and sizes. The convener has referred to issues for people who use wheelchairs or who have mobility problems. Have you had any discussions with other disability groups, apart from the STUC disabled workers committee, to look at what would be best for the wider community? We could propose changes for visually impaired individuals only to find out that people with mobility problems or wheelchair users have an issue because the buttons are out of reach or are in the wrong place to enable access for them. Have there been any discussions in the wider disability movement about the best placing of buttons and other fixtures in trains so that everybody can get the benefit of travelling on trains?

Robert Mooney Community
link

I think that the convener has already said that the matter has been raised at the cross-party group in the Scottish Parliament on disability. I am sure that it will have been raised there. As a frequent rail traveller who has a visual impairment, I think that part of the problem is that there are so many franchises in Great Britain and so many different companies, and they all use different types of trains. The issue is not just the toilets; it is the main doors and the doors going from one carriage to another. If you imagine for a minute having a visual impairment, you will realise that, when someone who is blind or partially blind goes towards a door, they have to feel for where the buttons are. For people in a wheelchair, the buttons are at a height where they can be reached and, if they can see them, that is fine. The buttons are not uniform. They are in completely different parts of the toilet cubicle and on completely different parts of the door, so people with visual impairment have to physically feel round the door until they come across the button.

I have heard more than once about a blind person getting hold of the emergency button in the toilet and stopping the train. It can be embarrassing. Blind people quite often get locked in the toilet and cannot find their way back out, as Beverley Bambrough said. Not that long ago, I was with six or seven blind people travelling to London, and one of our colleagues went to the toilet. The train stopped, and our colleague then came back. A wee while after that, the ticket inspector came up and said, “Did your wee pal tell you that he’s just stopped the train?”, although he had not. It happens frequently. All we are looking for is a bit of dignity. It is very undignified.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

It is not only blind people who stop trains because they do not know what button to press—Westminster ministers have been known to do that as well. There is clearly an issue, but I would like to work in conjunction with other disability groups to ensure that we get the right fit.

One difficulty is that some of the rolling stock in Scotland is more than 30 years old. The issue is how we retrofit that to make a standardised button system in trains, whether that is for getting access to the train or using the toilet facilities. With future rolling stock, we could certainly ensure that a standardised model is put in place, but retrofitting the rolling stock that is 30 years old would be difficult.

Beverley Bambrough Community
link

To go back to the question about whether there have been any overall discussions, it is worth noting that, in England, there are similar issues with accessibility to train stations and so on. There has been extensive discussion about staffing levels at train and bus stations to enable partially sighted and blind people as well as people with physical or mental health issues to access the transport system. The issue does not just stop with where the buttons on the trains are. We need a complete look at how we staff train stations to make things accessible to everybody.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

I have a question about high-visibility vests not being worn. It did not occur to me that that was the case. I travelled by train last week and I recall seeing staff in some English stations wearing high-vis vests, but you are right that, in Scotland, they do not. Have you been given an explanation for that, Mr Mooney?

Robert Mooney Community
link

I raised that issue initially because I had a problem with it. I have a pass that gets me free transport on trains but, when I go towards the barrier, I need to wait for somebody to let me through. Previously, I could see the person because they would have a high-vis vest on and I would head for them. Just recently, things changed and the vests became dark blue. I could not see anybody to go towards and so I had to stand there for quite a while waiting for somebody to let me through. However, last week, they changed back to the high-vis vests.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

Right—somebody has obviously been listening.

Robert Mooney Community
link

That is in the two main stations in Glasgow—Glasgow Central and Glasgow Queen Street. I do not know about stations in Edinburgh or elsewhere. It has changed back in Glasgow.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

Members have no more questions.

There is a genuine interest in the issue. It is an on-going discussion, but there is no reason why the committee should not get involved and try to find out where we can take it. We certainly need to speak to Transport Scotland to find out its views. The companies that run the trains will also have a view, which means Abellio in Scotland. We also need to identify a couple of the manufacturers and write to them for their views. There are also the bodies that have an interest from the disability angle. It would certainly be useful to get SATA’s take on the issue.

Do colleagues have any other suggestions?

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

It strikes me that, given that very little product is manufactured exclusively for the United Kingdom market, the manufacturers of buses or trains will produce units for the whole European Union and possibly more internationally than that. It would be interesting to find out whether our colleagues in the European Parliament have explored the issue. On the face of it, if we are looking for standardisation in the manufacturing process to facilitate access for those who are partially sighted, that commonality would have to happen at source and across the whole market for the product, not just here in Scotland. Frankly, it might be impractical to try to achieve that in isolation.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

Thanks for raising that point, Mr Carlaw. The deputy convener mentioned that when we were listening to the petitioners earlier. We certainly need to contact the European authorities to find out about the standardisation requirements in relation to the issue.

We will write to those organisations and collect that information. Obviously, we will keep the petitioners advised of the responses that we receive. We will take the petition forward as best we can to pursue the interests of the groups that you represent. Thanks very much for bringing the petition to us.

I suspend the meeting for a minute or two so that we can change witnesses.

10:53 Meeting suspended.

10:57 On resuming—

  1. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 48
  3. 10:30 New Petitions Petitions · 19
  4. 10:45 New Petitions Petitions · 40
  5. 11:30 New Petitions Petitions · 28

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.