I open the debate as convener, and accordingly my contribution will be apolitical. I offer my gratitude to my deputy convener, who for perfectly valid reasons wishes to be freed from those apolitical shackles, thus consigning me to summing up. That is worse for members, as they will have to listen to me for a tight 14 minutes and possibly another 10. I got my revenge and my sympathies in first.
On behalf of the Justice Committee, I thank the Minister for Community Safety and Legal Affairs and the Lord Advocate for their responses to our report, and the Lord Advocate for providing the committee with his draft guidelines, which I think the committee and the wider public found—and will find—helpful.
It is unusual to find ourselves debating a committee report on a bill when stage 1 is long over. However, it is appropriate that we have been given chamber time, because the bill has aroused a lot of interest in the wider world, and the issues that the committee uncovered deserve a wider airing. Further to that, the debate underlines the significant role of committees in holding the Government to account.
The bill was introduced in June. It is a response to the events of the previous football season both on and off the pitch. There were a number of incidents, ranging from the small to the sinister. The latter included the sending of suspect packages to particular individuals, apparently for no reason other than their faith background or footballing allegiance. We might disagree on the best approach in legal and policy terms to deal with the problem, but we all agree that that type of behaviour is utterly unacceptable and needs to be tackled.
The events of the previous season have tended to be labelled as part of Scotland’s sectarian problem. It may be news to some, but the word “sectarian” is not to be found in the bill. Each of us probably thinks that we know what it means, but it emerged in the evidence that there is no one clear definition. As the evidence from Nil By Mouth put it, sectarian is a word that “transcends its dictionary meaning” in Scotland.
Nevertheless, it is clear that the bill’s intention is to tackle sectarianism along with other types of unacceptable behaviour. The committee unanimously accepts that there is a continuing sectarian problem in Scotland, and that it is not found only at football matches. We agree with the Scottish Government that no one piece of legislation will solve the problem.
I turn now to procedure and evidence. Members will recall that the Government’s original plan was to deal with the bill by the summer recess through the emergency procedure, to have it ready in time for the new football season. As members know, as convener I expressed my disagreement with that, as did others. However, in the very limited time that the Justice Committee had in June, we undertook to hear evidence from the police, legal experts, representatives from football and civic society, and the Government. There was a mixture of views about the merits of the bill and about the appropriateness of the use of the accelerated procedure.
Shortly afterwards, the First Minister announced that he was minded to propose a lengthier timetable for consideration if Parliament agreed to the bill’s general principles at stage 1, which duly came to pass. It may be that the committee’s evidence sessions contributed to that change of heart—I certainly hope so.
In any event, I think that of all the new committees, we hit the ground running—and we were the better committee for it. As convener, I am glad that the committee had the opportunity for more extended consideration of the bill. There can be circumstances in which it is necessary, on balance, to expedite procedures on grounds of urgency, but in general, legislation benefits from robust, measured and careful scrutiny.
It is no secret that there are differences of opinion—to put it mildly—between committee members on the bill. However, if Parliament agrees to it we will end up with a better and stronger act because of the longer time that we have taken over it. I thank committee members for dealing with one another in committee in a civilised and collective manner, despite their differences. I am sure that that will continue and will be reflected in the tenor of the debate.
The committee heard from 33 individuals or organisations that gave evidence in person. We also received 83 formal written submissions on the bill as well as letters and e-mails from the public. I thank all those who provided evidence, particularly those who gave evidence at extremely short notice in June. Four committee members—myself included—attended an old firm match at Ibrox in September. That was extremely instructive, especially for those of us—I am one—who had not hitherto rated ourselves as aficionados of the beautiful game. We did not simply attend the match, which we hardly watched; we spent time with the police, stewards and supporters before and after the game to get a rounded picture of the reality of an old firm encounter and the preparations involved in it. I express my thanks to all who facilitated our visit.
I turn to the content of the bill, which is a bill of two halves—there end the footballing allusions—that creates two new and distinct offences. That fact, too, is often overlooked. One offence relates to offensive behaviour at football; the other relates to threatening communications. The more complex aspects of the bill are found in some of the details of those two new offences.
The chamber is well aware that the committee divided on the key question whether the new offences were necessary. A majority of members accept that we need a new law to address offensive behaviour at football that is not based on the “fear and alarm” formulation found in the current law. The majority likewise accept that there may be shortcomings that prevent effective prosecutions for some threatening communications. The majority also note what the Lord Advocate referred to as the “transformative effect” that legislation can sometimes have in changing attitudes towards what is and is not socially acceptable—we have the example of the ban on smoking in public places. A minority in the committee disagree, doubtful that the case for new criminal laws has been made, and think instead that the existing laws should be more rigorously applied. We will hear both sides of the argument this afternoon.
As convener, I will focus on the many areas in which the committee speaks with one voice. Much of this relates to the detail of the two offences. Whatever committee members’ overall views, I hope that we can at least agree that there is continuing potential to test the robustness of the bill at the amending stages, which is a task for all of us, including the chamber at stage 3.
The first offence—I will call it the football offence for shorthand—requires three elements to be proven: first, that there is offensive behaviour; secondly, that that behaviour occurs
“in relation to a regulated football match”;
and, thirdly, that the behaviour is likely to provoke public disorder. I stress that all three elements must be present.