To ask the Deputy First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00236)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Iain Gray Lab 6
- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 5
- Tricia Marwick 1
The record
12 contributionsI begin by paying tribute to Campbell Christie, a true giant of Scottish public life. Campbell’s contribution to Scotland over many years speaks for itself. He was a key campaigner for this Parliament, leader of the Scottish Trades Union Congress, chairman of his beloved Falkirk Football Club, a valued member of Forth Valley NHS Board and latterly, of course, the chair of the Christie commission on public sector reform. His legacy is immense and it will undoubtedly stand the test of time. We will all miss him, and I am sure that the entire chamber will want to send its deepest condolences to his wife Betty and, indeed, to all his family at this very sad time. [Applause.]
Later today, I will have meetings to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
Those were welcome words. I look forward, with many others, to celebrating Campbell’s life at Falkirk football stadium tomorrow.
This week, analysts from Citigroup told global clients not to invest in Scotland because of the Government’s separatist agenda. Is it not now clear that the uncertainty created by a separation referendum will damage this country’s economy?
I looked very closely at Iain Gray as he asked that question, just to see whether he was at all shamefaced. On the very morning that we learn that there is £400 billion-worth of revenue still to be extracted from the North Sea, only Iain Gray could stand up and question Scotland’s ability to be independent.
We disagree with the Citigroup report and think that it is wrong. It is based on two fundamental flaws. First, it ignores the reality, which is that investment is happening now, in the context of a live independence debate: £750 million has been invested in the past 12 months, and Mitsubishi, Doosan and Gamesa have £46 billion-worth of projects in the pipeline. That is the reality.
Secondly, the report makes the erroneous assumption that somehow, post-independence, the rest of the United Kingdom will no longer buy Scottish energy. That is patent nonsense. I know that Iain Gray is not usually one to miss the opportunity to clutch at any passing straw, but today he has excelled himself.
I looked very closely at the news about the potential of Aberdeen. I believe that Aberdeen has that potential, but the report says that it will be realised only if we have a transparent and stable fiscal regime—the very thing that Citigroup says that the Scottish Government is jeopardising.
If the Deputy First Minister will not listen to investors on energy, what about the engineers? In 25 minutes, the Institution of Mechanical Engineers will brief its “Scottish Energy 2020” report in this very building. It will say that the Scottish National Party’s 100 per cent renewables plan
“cannot be justified from an engineering perspective”,
that
“there are currently no credible strategies from a technical point of view, published by Government”,
and that
“without ... far reaching changes in Government policy, the target will not be met.”
I think that Scottish engineers are the best in the world. Does the Deputy First Minister think that she knows better than they do?
To go back to the news from Aberdeen, Iain Gray talks about fiscal arrangements. Has it escaped his notice that the fiscal arrangements that have the capacity to damage our North Sea potential are those from the UK Government? He has ignored that point.
Iain Gray asks who knows best. Does he think that he knows better than Roy MacGregor, the chairman of the Global Energy Group? This is what Roy MacGregor has to say:
“the investment is happening—in full knowledge of the Scottish Government’s planned referendum—and the renewables are being deployed in part thanks to the First Minister who has clearly demonstrated the vision and ambition that investors want to see. Scotland’s ability to produce power is a massive asset and one that is prospering”.
Just for once, Iain Gray could give up the opportunity to come to the chamber and talk Scotland down.
I saw Roy MacGregor’s letter in The Press and Journal. I hope that Roy saw it before it got there. That is a welcome investment by a Scottish company. However, the Deputy First Minister is still answering question 1. Question 2 was about what Scottish engineers are saying about the SNP’s energy policy. They are saying that
“energy policy has to be based on an understanding of energy supply technologies, not political expediency.”
They are trying to be polite, but they are talking about Alex Salmond. Will the Deputy First Minister listen, or will she send poor old Kevin Pringle off to forge a new engineering report in the professors’ names?
Iain Gray is so predictable at First Minister’s question time that I answered question 2 in answer 1. I pointed to the massive renewables investment currently under way in Scotland—£750 million of new renewable electricity projects began generating in Scotland in the past 12 months. There is a pipeline of 17GW of renewable electricity projects—a total estimated capital investment of £46 billion ready to create thousands of new jobs for Scotland. That is the reality.
The stark contrast between Iain Gray and the First Minister will be lost on no one today: the First Minister overseas, fighting Scotland’s corner, winning investment for Scotland; Iain Gray, at home, talking Scotland down as usual.
There are none so deaf as those who will not hear. [Interruption.]
Order.
The report says that there is no credible plan, there is no credible pipeline and there is no route map to achieving the SNP’s renewable energy targets.
The SNP says that renewables is its key policy for Scotland’s future, but it has not got a clue about it. Investors say that the referendum makes the policy unsupportable and that separation makes it unaffordable, but the people who actually build the technology say that it is technically undeliverable. Last week, the First Minister had to apologise for misleading Parliament, but is he misleading Scotland on energy every day of every week?
There is a renewables route map, published by this Government. I suggest that Iain Gray reads it.
The companies are investing—Mitsubishi, Doosan and Gamesa. Iain Gray talks about people not wanting to hear. Let me draw to his attention something that was said at the weekend by Ian Smart, who tried to be a Labour candidate at the most recent election. He said that it is time for Labour to realise
“that it is not that people don’t hear the message. It is that they don’t like what they are hearing.”
It is time that Iain Gray paid attention to that message.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 3 Nov 2011 →- Veterans Debate · 43
- City of Edinburgh Council (Privatisation of Services) Questions · 6
- Orthodontic Dentistry (Access for Children) Questions · 6
- Flood Defences (Perth and Kinross Council) Questions · 6
- NHS Fife (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Scotland-Norway Ferry Service Questions · 6
- Farming Tenancies (Compensation for Investment) Questions · 6
- Fireworks (Safety) Questions · 4
- Housing Benefit Cap (Representations) Questions · 6
- Business Gateway Contracts Questions · 6
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Cabinet Meeting First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Charities and Voluntary Organisations (Financial Pressures) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Respite for Carers First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Knife Crime First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Further Education Colleges (Unemployed People) Questions · 9
- College Funding (Reduction) Questions · 10
- Human Rights Education Questions · 4
- Further Education (Regionalisation) Questions · 6
- Room 13 Questions · 6
- Educational Attainment (Rural Areas) Questions · 6
- Further and Higher Education (South of Scotland) Questions · 4
- After-school Clubs and Out-of-school Care Questions · 7
- Gaelic Questions · 6
- Further Education (Widening Access) Questions · 4
- College Principals and Chairs (Meetings) Questions · 5
- Community Colleges Questions · 4
- Colleges and College Campuses (Closures) Questions · 4
- Vocational Skills Training (Borders) Questions · 4
- Further Education (Student Support) Questions · 4
- English University Places (Scots Applicants) Questions · 4
- Activity Agreements Questions · 5
- Highers and Advanced Highers Questions · 6
- Glasgow City Council (Additional Support for Learning) Questions · 4
- Offensive Behaviour at Football and Threatening Communications (Scotland) Bill (Stage 2 Report) Bill debate · 166
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 7
- Rogue Traders Members’ business · 10
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.