Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (Tax Rates and Tax Bands) (Scotland) Order 2015 [Draft]

Wednesday 25 February 2015 Finance Committee About 11:30–12:15 Subordinate legislation 60 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

60 contributions
Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

We agreed to start back at 11.45 so that is what we will do.

Our next item of business is evidence from the Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Constitution and Economy on two statutory instruments that relate to the land and buildings transaction tax. He is joined for this item by Neil Ferguson, Alison Cumming and John St Clair of the Scottish Government.

I welcome the cabinet secretary to the meeting, ask him to make an opening statement explaining the instruments and remind him not to move the motions at this point.

John Swinney SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Constitution and Economy · Perthshire North
link

Do you wish me to make an opening statement on both orders?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

The primary purpose of the Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (Sub-sale Development Relief and Multiple Dwellings Relief) (Scotland) Order 2015 is to provide for a relief from land and buildings transaction tax in relation to a land transaction involving sub-sale arrangements, but only where development of the land in question is in prospect.

The work to develop the provisions in the order followed a number of meetings of a working group that involved industry professionals and tax specialists, which was convened to explore the issues associated with a sub-sale development relief. I place on record my thanks to those who participated in the exercise.

Given the experiences of sub-sale rules applicable to stamp duty land tax, my core considerations in the design of the relief have been to ensure that it supports economic activity in the form of property development while not supporting land speculation and minimising any risk of tax avoidance. Members may recall that I made those points during passage of the Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (Scotland) Bill and placed my position on the subject on record during the stage 3 debate on 25 June 2013.

To achieve those aims, a consultation paper was published in June 2014 seeking views on draft regulations that would introduce a sub-sale development relief under which the first buyer in a sub-sale arrangement would pay the full tax due and then, provided significant development of the site had taken place within five years, the relief would be claimed and the tax returned by Revenue Scotland on receipt of a tax return.

However, the consensus of the responses to the consultation was that, to help with cash flow in development transactions, the relief should be available at the outset. If development was not completed within the five-year period, the relief could be clawed back. Otherwise, the industry argued, developers in Scotland would be placed at a disadvantage in terms of cash flow in comparison with their competitors in other parts of the United Kingdom.

That issue has been addressed in the revised regulations that are now before Parliament and are the subject of the committee’s discussions. The order provides for a relief which has a number of features.

First, the relief will be available only to the first buyer in a transaction that involves sub-sale arrangements where “significant development” is in prospect. The order defines “significant development”.

As has always been envisaged, the relief will be available to the first buyer when the whole site is sold to a second buyer. Partial relief is available if the first buyer retains part of the site and the remainder is sold to a second buyer or further partitioned to other buyers. To be clear, no relief is available for the proportion of the site that the first buyer retains.

The relief is restricted to the first buyer only; it is not available to a second or subsequent buyer where a series of sub-sale arrangements is in place. That reduces the risk of tax avoidance and is an improvement on the corresponding arrangements relating to stamp duty land tax.

In recognition of the development industry’s concerns, the relief is to be claimed and granted at the point when the first buyer submits the land transaction return. Revenue Scotland may request that the first buyer provide specific evidence that the claim is valid—for example, that there are firm plans to undertake significant development.

Lastly, if significant development does not take place within five years, the relief will be withdrawn or partially withdrawn. The tax that should have been paid will then become repayable.

I am confident that the relief will provide a robust mechanism that balances appropriate safeguards to the property development industry in Scotland with the need to protect revenue and maintain a firm position on tax avoidance.

In addition, the relief has been discussed in detail with Revenue Scotland. Administration of the relief will have implications in terms of checking that significant development has indeed taken place and recovering the relief where that is not the case, which will increase administrative costs for Revenue Scotland in due course. Taken in the round, though, my view is that the relief represents an appropriate balance between equity, collection of revenue and administrative effort.

Finally, the order also amends paragraphs 11 and 12 of schedule 5 to the Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (Scotland) Act 2013 for multiple developments relief, to ensure that the calculation using the minimum prescribed amount of 25 per cent applies only to the acquisition of multiple dwellings, not multiple dwellings and other property. Under the drafting as enacted, it was felt that there might be ambiguity on that important point, which was undesirable and which, subject to Parliament’s agreement, will now be clarified.

The order also makes a consequential change to provide that the minimum proportion prescribed in the Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (Prescribed Proportions) (Scotland) Order 2014, which has already been considered by committee, stays in force on the amended basis.

I move now to the Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (Tax Rates and Tax Bands) (Scotland) Order 2015. The primary purpose of the order is to set tax bands and percentage tax rates for land transactions that will be subject to land and buildings transaction tax. The instrument sets the rates and bands for residential property transactions and for non-residential property transactions and, with respect to leases, it sets the tax rates for each band applicable to chargeable consideration that consists of rent.

The Scottish Parliament legislated for a marginal progressive rate structure for LBTT back in 2013. That was intended to replace the much criticised slab structure of stamp duty land tax, which was shown to cause distortions in the housing market around the tax thresholds. The reform was recently replicated across the United Kingdom, although for residential transactions only, following the reforms to SDLT that the Chancellor of the Exchequer announced in the autumn statement.

I set out the Scottish Government’s proposed rates and bands for LBTT in the budget last October, and I updated Parliament on planned residential rates and bands during the stage 1 debate on the Budget (Scotland) (No 4) Bill in January.

I made it clear to Parliament last October that I intended the devolved taxes to be revenue neutral in their first year of operation. The Government did not want to raise any more or less from the two devolved taxes than would have been raised had the UK taxes remained in place, and we wished to maintain devolved spending at planned levels.

Of course, at the time of the draft budget, we had still to reach agreement with the UK Government on the block grant adjustment for the devolved taxes, despite two years of effort in that respect. The LBTT rates and bands presented in the order, taken with the proposed rates of Scottish landfill tax, are designed to be revenue neutral against the block grant adjustment in aggregate, as I set out to the committee in my letter of 22 January and in the chamber on 4 February.

The Scottish Government forecasts that we will generate revenue of £381 million from LBTT in 2015-16, of which £235 million will come from residential property transactions and £146 million from non-residential property transactions, including the taxation of leases. Those forecasts have been endorsed as reasonable by the Scottish Fiscal Commission. As the committee is aware, work is continuing on the estimation of the revenue losses arising from forestalling, and the Scottish Government’s estimates will be subject to review by the commission. The impact of forestalling on the block grant adjustment also remains to be agreed with the UK Government.

I will now turn to the policy objectives underlying the decisions that I have taken on the three sets of LBTT rates and bands presented in the order. In setting the rates and bands of tax payable on residential property transactions, I have sought to prioritise support for first-time buyers and those progressing through the housing market by redistributing the tax burden from lower to higher-value transactions. Those rates are consistent with the principle that taxes should be proportionate to the taxpayer’s ability to pay.

The nil rate threshold is set at £145,000, which will take around 50 per cent of house purchases out of tax altogether—10,000 more purchases than under the new rates of UK SDLT. The marginal rate of 5 per cent, which I announced in January and which is to apply to the value of a purchase between £250,000 and £325,000, also ensures that the tax due on more than 90 per cent of transactions will either be less than the UK charge or will be zero.

For non-residential property transactions, the rates and bands are designed to ensure that Scotland remains an attractive location for business investment. They will reduce the tax charge for the majority of transactions below £2 million, ensuring that the tax due on around 95 per cent of transactions will be the same or lower than the SDLT charge.

Finally, the rates and bands for non-residential leases are set to ensure parity with the UK rates, which are also set on a progressive basis.

I consider that the rates and bands demonstrate clearly that the Scottish Government has placed fairness, equity and the ability to pay at the very heart of the first decisions that we have taken on national tax rates.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

Thank you, cabinet secretary. One reason why this session started about 45 minutes later than scheduled is that we have taken evidence from a number of witnesses on these items.

I will ask you one or two questions before I open out the session to colleagues around the table. In evidence that was presented to us earlier this morning, Homes for Scotland and the Scottish Property Federation advised us that the band restriction of 5 per cent from £250,000 to £325,000 is likely to lead to market distortions for more expensive properties, particularly those in the £325,000 to £400,000 range. Homes for Scotland would like to see the band widen to £250,000 to £500,000. Some evidence suggests that there has been an adverse impact on transactions in the £325,000 to £400,000 range as a result of the announcements that have been made. What is your view on that?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

The only published data that we have is Registers of Scotland’s data for the fourth quarter of 2014 on property transactions and property prices, and the volatility in the market and around the issues with which we are wrestling only crystallised for a limited time during that period.

I set out the rates in October, but the UK Government’s changes were announced in early December, so we do not have a particularly reliable period of analysis. Nothing in the data strikes me as indicating a particular change in the pattern of property transactions. We will consider carefully the statistics for quarter 1 of 2015 from Registers of Scotland as they become available.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

The Scottish Property Federation raised concerns about the non-residential rate. It said that the 4.5 per cent rate, as opposed to the 4 per cent rate in the rest of the UK, would have a detrimental effect on the likelihood of decisions being made to invest in Scotland. I put that concern to you some months ago, when you said that it would not make any significant difference, but the Scottish Property Federation’s representative said that his personal experience is that the rate is having an impact on investments in the £6 million to £8 million range. Does the Scottish Government have any detailed information on whether that is the case, or does it believe that it will be the case?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

No detailed information—or any information—has come to me on that point. I think that we discussed the issue at the Finance Committee meeting on the Isle of Arran, in your constituency, when I set out some of the scenarios that would be relevant. For a £10 million transaction, the increase in the tax charge would be £40,250, which is 0.4 per cent of the total transaction value. I consider that a change of that level is at the margins of the assessment of such a transaction, and I am not aware of any information that in any way contradicts what I said to you when we discussed the issue in your constituency.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

Thank you. I will now open out the session to colleagues. The deputy convener will be first, followed by Richard Baker.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

Good morning, cabinet secretary. The Chartered Institute of Taxation commented on sub-sale development relief and the term “significant development”—if a significant development happens within five years, tax is not payable. Are you happy that the term “significant development” will not lead to a lot of wrangles and court cases?

12:00

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

We have set out a definition of “significant development” in paragraph 7 to schedule 10A of the order:

“‘significant development’ means development that is significant having regard to, among other things, the nature and extent of the subject-matter of the qualifying sub-sale and to the market value of that subject-matter.”

There are a couple of points that I would make about that. The first is that we have defined as clearly as we can what we would consider to be significant. That takes into account the market value of the subject matter and the nature and extent of the development. In an example in which planning consent had been given for the building of 100 houses in a development and only one house had been built, that would clearly fail the test of significant development. If the committee will forgive me, however, I will not start to police where the line should be deployed.

That brings me to my additional point. The wording of the definition says:

“having regard to, among other things”.

That is designed to give flexibility to Revenue Scotland to look reasonably and credibly at a situation. If 99 houses had been built, I would say—without creating a precedent in the committee today—that that would feel to me as if significant development had been undertaken; if only one had been built, clearly that would not be the case. Revenue Scotland would have to make a judgment in that range, taking into account market conditions and other factors.

We do not wish to prescribe, and I think that prescription is the next place that we could go to in that definition. We have tried to give as much clarity as possible.

Of course, these matters will ultimately be subject to debate and determination by Revenue Scotland, but I think that we have set out enough detail to inform that judgment.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

CIOT made another point that is linked to that. It asked whether, if there were external events that were outside the control of the developer during the five years, it would be able to apply for an extension of that period.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

Sorry, convener, could I ask another question?

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

I am sorry; I thought that you were winding up, but in fact you were just getting fired up.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

That was just my introductory bit.

The question of competitive advantage or disadvantage has been raised by a number of witnesses. I got a slightly confusing picture from the witnesses, because some seemed to say that the tax was extremely important and would affect a development going forward and others said that the tax was only one part of it. How significant do you see LBTT being with regard to whether a residential development goes ahead? Do you think that it is other factors that will cause a development to go ahead?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

LBTT will be one factor in the judgments that are made. I do not think that it will be the central factor; I think that it will be a marginal factor. Much more significant will be questions of the capacity to raise the capital to fund the development and, implicit in all of that, how likely it is that that capital will have to be held on to before it is replenished by sales. All of those factors are much more material to the judgment about whether a development proceeds than the rate of LBTT.

In principle, LBTT is a marginal consideration in whether developments are taken forward. It is certainly not a central factor. In terms of where we are more competitive or less competitive—to use that terminology—the difference in the levels that we are setting out is a marginal factor in the judgments that would be made.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

We had evidence from SFHA about mid-market rent. Most of us in the committee are sympathetic to the concept of mid-market rent, whereby it is a bit more affordable than the rent would be in the completely private sector. The suggestion was that, in order to encourage mid-market rent, there should be further reliefs to those who are seeking to make that kind of development. I wondered whether, if we are helping that kind of sector, it is better to do it by tax relief or by a direct grant.

We have had a similar debate on whether to encourage eco-friendly housing by relief or subsidy. I am not asking you to commit to supporting mid-market rent, but if we were to do it, what would be the best way of doing it?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

I have read the SFHA evidence and I saw some of the dialogue that the committee had with it this morning. Obviously, the Government will always give consideration to propositions and suggestions that are advanced, but I would apply a couple of caveats to that.

One is that I was clear with Parliament and the committee that we did not want to create a relief-strewn bill, if I could call it that. I felt that, throughout the process of the bill, I had firm support from the committee in the judgments that I was arriving at. I was clear with the committee that, when relief was required, genuinely necessary and had firm purpose, it should be granted, but we should not replicate all the reliefs that were available under SDLT, for example, because that would simply replicate some of the difficulties and challenges that existed with SDLT on tax compliance.

We have been going through a debate in the United Kingdom on tax compliance and avoidance. As the committee knows, the Government has decided to take the strongest possible stance on tax avoidance. Of course, the more reliefs that we have, the more ground is opened up to potential practices that we might not have envisaged at the conception of the legislation.

Therefore, one caveat is that I am naturally cautious about extending reliefs. That is why, when I was in front of the committee at earlier stages, I was reluctant to go into the territory of sub-sale relief. I have been persuaded of the merits of that argument by the industry and we have gone into that in a fashion that I think is consistent with the legislation. We have to be careful about how much we open up the process.

The second caveat is the point that Mr Mason raised that, when we are trying to solve a challenge such as improving the availability of mid-market rent properties, we need to take the most effective intervention to do that. We should not take another intervention because a piece of legislation happens to be in front of Parliament and it seems a good idea to advance the issue, when that may not be the most effective mechanism for stimulating mid-market rent properties.

I would much prefer us to take forward a policy on a more direct financial support mechanism. For example, the national housing trust, which aims to deliver properties for mid-market rent, has been very successful. It involves a very low level of Government financial support and it relies on the private market, but it has been very successful in the delivery of mid-market rent properties. When we have such mechanisms, we should do all that we can to ensure that they are successful.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

Have you definitely finished now? Laughter.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

We will move to questions from Richard Baker.

Richard Baker Lab North East Scotland
link

My questions also relate to multiple dwellings relief and the evidence from the Scottish Federation of Housing Associations on homes for mid-market rent, which enable more people to get the housing that they need, so that is a big issue for the progressive approach. We welcome the fact that you have sought a progressive approach through the legislation. However, in three areas, the SFHA says that the changes that are being made are detrimental to schemes for mid-market rent. The costs for housing associations will be higher than those under stamp duty for transactions on homes for mid-market rent, for the purchase of land through back-to-back sales from a developer and for the purchase of multiple properties.

Given that you said that you want the order to bring more progressivity to the provisions, why did you not ensure that such an important scheme for housing provision would not have a detrimental impact and would, preferably, encourage more mid-market-rent homes to be built? There seems to be a danger that such developments would be largely discouraged if the order goes through as proposed.

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

I challenge some of the evidence that has been put in front of the committee. For example, Mr Baker posits a particular scenario of land purchases from a developer, but that is one scenario. It does not have to be the scenario by which land becomes available to or is accessed by a housing association to develop mid-market-rent properties.

We have to be careful about the positing of particular scenarios that become arguments for suggesting that somehow a disadvantage is being created, because Parliament has taken the general view that it wants to minimise the risk of tax avoidance. We have to be careful about some of that evidence.

The Government has set out a progressive approach to the delivery of the policy. It is designed to ensure that the payment of tax relates to the value and significance of developments. Some of the issues that Mr Mason raised are more material to whether a development takes it course than is the assumption that an action under LBTT—as I said in my response to the convener, that will be a marginal factor—has any effect on the decisions about taking forward a development.

Richard Baker Lab North East Scotland
link

The SFHA gives a clear example of buying 20 properties. The impact of LBTT on that might be marginal but, under the provision that you put forward, the cost to the housing association for the purchase of those properties will be greater than that under stamp duty. That seems to be going backwards, not forwards, in encouraging such developments.

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

LBTT will be a marginal factor in all this. I made the point to the convener that that is all in the marginal territory.

The tax charge might be higher not because of the absence of a relief but because of the proposed rate of 4.5 per cent. The committee has got to be careful where it goes here. If the committee believes that we should start to litter the legislation with reliefs—to provide exemptions—it will open up opportunities for tax avoidance. The committee would run that danger if it followed that line of argument.

We have related the rates much more closely to the size of transactions to encourage and motivate more activity by having a more competitive rate for the lower end of property transactions. That means that there is a higher rate on larger property transactions. If the committee tried to temper that by putting a relief in place, I caution it that it would be going into the territory that it expressly tried to avoid when it scrutinised the legislation some months ago.

Richard Baker Lab North East Scotland
link

I was not on the committee at that point, so it seems to me that I have carte blanche to litter the thing with reliefs as much as I want. However, I am not suggesting that; what I suggest is on a specific issue. Surely it is not beyond the wit of the Scottish Government, on an issue that involves a housing association—a clearly defined entity in law, which it is difficult to pretend to be, as we heard earlier—to ensure that the legislation is not just beneficial to such purchases but not detrimental to them, compared with the provisions that were in place under stamp duty.

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

That proposition can be advanced if people wish to advance it, but I am simply setting out to the committee the issues that it would have to consider if it wished to advance those arguments.

12:15

Richard Baker Lab North East Scotland
link

The Scottish Federation of Housing Associations says that there would be a strong case for an exemption from LBTT for housing associations that pursue such developments. That would be an important way of encouraging their development and it would not be a huge cost to the Scottish Government, given that it would apply in a specific area. What consideration have you given to that proposal? Has there been any dialogue with housing associations on it? I understand your caution, but would you be prepared to consider the idea for the future?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

As I said at the outset, the Government is always prepared to consider such issues. I will certainly consider the proposal. In the evidence that the committee heard this morning, no figure was given for the proposal’s financial impact. If we were talking about an exemption rather than just a relief, that would affect the estimates that I make about the tax take. That money has to come from somewhere.

The judgments that are being arrived at are about the tax charge that it is appropriate to apply to particular developments. There is flexibility in the legislation to determine whether the tax charge should be varied for one organisation or another. I am certainly happy to discuss that with the SFHA.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

Mark McDonald has a brief supplementary.

Gavin Brown Con Lothian
link

The cabinet secretary mentioned that the Scottish Fiscal Commission is doing some work on forestalling. Is there a timescale for that work to be completed and published?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

The discussions are on-going. We are carrying out further research work based on what the Fiscal Commission has requested of us. The commission will come to its own judgment; that is not a matter for me to get involved in. It would have to set out the timescale for that.

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

When the Chief Secretary to the Treasury appeared before the committee, he indicated that he expected the discussions on forestalling to go on into the start of the next financial year. That is later than I would like, but it takes two to have a negotiation. We will carry on the work that is being undertaken with the commission, but the management of that work and any determination that is made about it are matters for the commission.

Gavin Brown Con Lothian
link

When you gave evidence to us in December, just before the autumn statement, your view was that the LBTT rates that you were setting would have no behavioural impact. We then had the autumn statement, which changed things. Is it still your view that, had we not had the autumn statement, there would have been no behavioural impact at all? Do you put all the forestalling down to the autumn statement, or do you accept that some of it was down to the LBTT rates being different from the existing stamp duty rates?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

Individuals base their judgments about property transactions on a wide variety of factors. I do not think that the introduction of LBTT has led to a particularly significant behavioural response, but it is clear that the autumn statement had an additional impact on the market. That brought further uncertainty to the marketplace, which I suspect will be reflected in forestalling.

Gavin Brown Con Lothian
link

When you were asked about the impact so far, you said that the evidence that you had came from the quarterly house price index, which was published in February and related to quarter 4 of 2014. I was a bit surprised by that. Given that the Scottish Government deals regularly with Registers of Scotland, do you not have figures for January?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

I said that there is no published data. When it comes to the official output of Registers of Scotland, the published data is all that I can deal with. I take a close interest in the property market’s performance. I look at a range of information sources, but nothing indicates to me that there is any evidence to substantiate the claim that there has been a change in performance as a result of the introduction of LBTT.

Gavin Brown Con Lothian
link

We heard evidence earlier from witnesses who believe that, as a consequence of LBTT—if the proposed rates are set—activity at the higher bands of the property market will be depressed, which would have a detrimental impact on other steps of the ladder. That is their view; I assume that the Scottish Government takes a different view, but if they are correct—if that scenario plays out post-April—will the Scottish Government act?

Gavin Brown Con Lothian
link

If the Scottish property market is hit detrimentally as a consequence of the rates that you have set and if there is a different result from that in the north of England or the midlands, for example—I would treat London separately—will the Scottish Government act and change the rates to help the market to function?

Gavin Brown Con Lothian
link

Okay. I presume that the rates will be reviewed at budget time each year.

Gavin Brown Con Lothian
link

So your position is that you would do nothing prior to that.

Mark McDonald SNP Aberdeen Donside
link

My question was dealt with by Gavin Brown—he asked what I was going to ask about possible impacts. That is what I get for saying that he could go first.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

Is it that great minds think alike or fools never differ? I am not quite sure.

Motion moved,

That the Finance Committee recommends that the Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (Sub-sale Development Relief and Multiple Dwellings Relief) (Scotland) Order 2015 draft be approved.—John Swinney.

Motion agreed to.

Motion moved,

That the Finance Committee recommends that the Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (Tax Rates and Tax Bands) (Scotland) Order 2015 draft be approved.—John Swinney.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

The question is, that motion S4M-12346 be agreed to. Are we agreed?

Members: No.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

There will be a division.

For

Baker, Richard (North East Scotland) (Lab)

Chisholm, Malcolm (Edinburgh Northern and Leith) (Lab)

Gibson, Kenneth (Cunninghame North) (SNP)

Mason, John (Glasgow Shettleston) (SNP)

McDonald, Mark (Aberdeen Donside) (SNP)

Urquhart, Jean (Highlands and Islands) (Ind)

Against

Brown, Gavin (Lothian) (Con)

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

The result of the division is: For 6, Against 1, Abstentions 0.

Motion agreed to.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

We will suspend the meeting for one minute to allow for a changeover of witnesses.

12:22 Meeting suspended.

12:23 On resuming—

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 89
  3. 10:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 101
  4. 11:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 60
  5. 12:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 12

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.