I am pleased to be here to discuss the Bunchrew land declaration, and I congratulate Rhoda Grant on bringing the debate to the chamber. I will say more about why I think it is the right time for this debate.
The Bunchrew land declaration by Community Land Scotland in March this year tells an interesting story, as we have heard. It also tells a story that brings us almost full circle.
The international human rights community has been debating community land rights for some time now. That debate, to date at least, has been driven by a recognition in many developing countries, where communities have already exercised collective ownership of land and have managed the land sustainably in the interests of the whole community, that those collective rights have had to give way to modern individual property rights.
In those countries, property rights have often been taken up by large interests wanting to own and extract mineral wealth. In the process they have displaced local communities, dispossessing them of both their land and, importantly, their futures. In an endeavour to start to protect community land rights, the international community has been drawing up guidelines to help encourage countries to take action where communities are losing those collective rights.
This international story has resonance here in Scotland, and I believe that Scotland has a lot to offer to the debate—a point that Rhoda Grant made earlier. Many of Scotland’s crofting communities will relate to the current stories unfolding in the developing world. They have a long history of struggle, and legislative changes from the late 19th century through to the present day have resulted in a succession of legislative reforms and in security of tenure. That serves to protect the interests of their inhabitants and, more widely, their communities. I hope that colleagues across the chamber will agree with me that that reform has made a real difference.
There have also been rights established for other rural communities throughout Scotland. Some of them—such as the community right to buy, to which a number of members have referred—are innovative and can make a real difference to the futures of communities that use them.
The determination of communities in Scotland to own and manage the land on which they live and work has led to roughly half a million acres of land in community ownership today. In the past year alone, more than 38,000 acres have come under community ownership. There are another 100,000 acres in the pipeline at the moment, which is very encouraging.
Scotland is not the only country that is working to restore community land rights. Where examples exist, there is growing evidence that community landowners place a far greater emphasis on sustainability and the environment. These really are key drivers to community, as well as national, success and prosperity. New Zealand is another prime example of where that happens.
I would like Scotland’s community landowners, with their rich and long experience of rural and community development, to be willing to share their experience internationally, and to help communities in other countries at the start of their struggle.
I am already aware that the 1 million acre target set by the First Minister in June 2012, which would see us move from around 2 per cent to around 5 per cent of Scotland’s land coming into community ownership, is being held up as an example in the international debate on community land rights. Therefore, I again thank Rhoda Grant for lodging her motion, record my agreement with the motion and congratulate Community Land Scotland on the publication of the Bunchrew land declaration.
I made it clear that this Government is committed to progressing land reform in Scotland when I spoke at the Community Land Scotland conference in June and also when I appeared before the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee. I take this opportunity to reiterate that commitment. My vision is for a fairer, wider and more equitable distribution of land in Scotland that provides communities and individuals with the access to land they need to fulfil their aspirations and needs and, in turn, contributes to the sustainable economic development of Scotland and to its social and environmental gains.
We have a target of 1 million acres, or 5 per cent, of land in community ownership by 2020. It is certainly an ambitious target but it is also a really inspiring one. All Scotland should be engaged in achieving that target. We need communities to think about whether community ownership of land or an asset would make a real difference to their community and its success. We need the public, private, third and community sectors to work together to make sure we get the best from our land.
The target of 1 million acres in community ownership is sometimes portrayed as pro community and anti private ownership, but that is not the case. As the concentration of ownership decreases there will be room for more community owners and more private owners.
I agree with Claudia Beamish that it is also clear that land reform in Scotland is not something solely for the Highlands and Islands or for rural Scotland; it is for the whole of Scotland. We need to take land reform into urban areas. There are already numerous examples where community ownership of land has made a real difference in such areas. We want to encourage urban communities and those in our larger rural settlements to become involved and fulfil their potential.
We also want urban and rural communities to be able to tackle abandoned and neglected land, which is a real hindrance to the sustainable development of land to which communities have a connection. The Community Empowerment (Scotland) Bill will propose some key steps that can make a real difference, but further action is needed, which is why I have announced that I will seek to introduce a land reform bill during the current parliamentary session.
I have said it before—and other members have referred to this—that we might not design a system in which 432 landowners, or 0.008 per cent of the population, owns half of the privately owned land in Scotland. That is not to denigrate the individuals who own that land; this is not about the politics of envy. However, we are not aware of any other modern democracy in which such a pattern of land ownership pertains.
In the time I have left, I will refer to some of the points that have been raised by members. In response to Rhoda Grant, I say that we look to work with Community Land Scotland and others to implement the agenda. Rob Gibson referred to Scotland being a hydro nation. That is an important principle and, to an extent, we all depend on land for our wellbeing, as does the environment.
Malcolm Chisholm talked about the concentration of ownership of forestry. It is true that we have a highly concentrated pattern of forestry ownership, but we are implementing initiatives such as wood lots to explore how communities and individuals can lease forests to manage. Indeed, the Forestry Commission Scotland national forest land scheme is a means by which we can transfer ownership of forests to communities.
Jean Urquhart made a fair point about the pattern of how the land has been disposed of. We are exploring means by which we can have smaller packets of land for sale. That happened most recently in the sale of Rannoch barracks, which gave opportunities for smaller plots to be bought.
Alex Fergusson raised a point about community empowerment and I welcome his support for that. I hope that there are aspects of the Community Empowerment (Scotland) Bill that the Conservatives can support, and we look to work with Alex Fergusson and his colleagues on finding common ground where we can.
Dave Thompson called for unity with the Opposition parties. I genuinely believe that we can achieve that unity on land reform, and I certainly look forward to working with the Labour Party and others in due course. I agree with Claudia Beamish’s point about the support systems that HIE produces. They have been very influential in promoting community land projects in the Highlands and Islands.
My aim is for land reform to address the situation that we face in Scotland by ensuring that patterns of ownership and use of land in this country deliver the maximum benefit to the people of Scotland. I hope—and I have expressed as much to our stakeholders—that the land reform review group’s report has given us the opportunity to take land reform away from the old, polarised arguments and into the 21st century.
Rhoda Grant is correct to say that we will have many opportunities to debate the issues in due course. The Scottish Government looks forward to working with Parliament and having the support of parliamentary colleagues for the Community Empowerment (Scotland) Bill and a future land reform bill.
Meeting closed at 17:45.