I welcome this opportunity to make a statement to the Parliament on the use of armed officers within the routinely unarmed Police Service of Scotland, of which we are rightly so proud. I take this opportunity to thank the Police Service for its contribution to what has been the best-ever Commonwealth games. It made its contribution in a friendly and welcoming manner, like the city of Glasgow, and two officers even played a cameo role in the opening ceremony.
Scotland is rightly proud that its police officers conduct their daily business unarmed. That has always been the case, and I make it clear to the Parliament that that is how we intend it to remain. Armed officers have for a considerable time provided support for police colleagues and security for citizens. However, the public should be assured that the number of officers who are authorised to carry weapons is low and limited. Only 275 of the 17,318 officers who are employed by Police Scotland are deployed on firearms duties—that is less than 1.6 per cent of our police force. It should also be made clear that those officers operate on a shift system and are subject to extraction and indeed holiday entitlement, so only a fraction of that already low number will be on duty at any one time.
Gun crime in Scotland is rare, but in Police Scotland’s first year, specialist firearms units attended 1,300 incidents across the whole of the country, including more than 100 in the Highlands. It is not just gun crime and firearms incidents that they deal with, as they are also called out to deal with incidents where there is a significant threat. Those can involve knives, samurai swords, machetes or even broken bottles. The presence of those officers in such situations is necessary for the safety of colleagues and the public alike. It is therefore essential that the chief constable has the operational flexibility that he needs to properly protect the public and ensure the safety of his officers.
The decision on the deployment of armed officers and the granting of standing firearms authority within a police force that is recognised as one that goes about its day-to-day business unarmed is therefore an operational matter for the chief constable. That has always been the case. That is how it was before the inception of Police Scotland, and that is how it remains. The current standing firearms authority was given by the chief constable after a range of factors were assessed, including evidence and intelligence. The authority is not new. Three of the former constabularies—Strathclyde Police, Tayside Police and Northern Constabulary—had endorsed that position prior to the inception of the service, and the approach is taken in 42 of the 43 services in England and Wales.
When we debated the Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill in the Parliament a couple of years ago, it was clear that operational independence was paramount. It was made clear by members in all parts of the chamber that our democratic structures require that the chief constable has operational independence and is free from political interference. However, given police officers’ powers and the need to ensure that citizens’ rights are protected, safeguards were built in. First, to ensure the separation of powers between Government and the police, the Parliament established the Scottish Police Authority, and it is for that authority to appoint the chief constable and hold him or her to account. The Scottish Police Authority has a broad membership with a wide range of experience.
Secondly, the Parliament decided that, as we were moving to a single service for Scotland, it was appropriate that the Scottish Parliament had oversight. It is for that reason that the Justice Sub-Committee on Policing was established, and it is able to scrutinise all aspects of policing.
As well as those safeguards, additional checks and balances have been built in. First, the Police Investigations and Review Commissioner was established under the Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Act 2012 to deal not simply with any complaints against the police but with actions of the police, and any use of a firearm will automatically be remitted to him.
Secondly, we have Her Majesty’s inspectorate of constabulary for Scotland, which is long established and which has great experience of advising not just the service but the Government on the quality of policing and the nature of police activities. HMICS is independent from the chief constable and from Government and is able to advise without fear or favour. The inspector provides a further level of scrutiny of police officers and the decisions that they take, irrespective of rank. That includes all aspects of operational decisions, including standing firearms authority.
Thirdly, a standing firearms authority is reviewed quarterly, which ensures a regular and contemporary basis for the granting of what is exceptional authority for a police officer in a routinely unarmed constabulary. The next review is due next month. The chief constable has already confirmed publicly that, in addition to considering available information and intelligence, he will take on board views and representations that have been made. I welcome that commitment by the chief. I welcome the fact that further assurance will be provided by HMICS on this occasion. As normal, the report of HMICS will be published and available to the Parliament.
I believe that the public understands and accepts the need for a small number—I stress that it is small—of police officers to be authorised to carry firearms and for the chief constable to have operational independence over their deployment and use. However, I also understand the concern of the public that we do not slip into a situation where officers become armed as a matter of routine practice, which would clearly go beyond the operational into matters of policy. I give the Parliament and the public my assurance that that will not happen.
Following discussion with the chief constable, I can confirm that he has agreed to provide quarterly reports to the SPA and the parliamentary sub-committee on the number of officers who are deployed on firearms duties. As an additional measure and reassurance to Parliament, I can announce that, should the number of officers who are deployed on firearms duties routinely exceed 2 per cent of the total number of officers in Scotland, the chief constable will notify the SPA and the Cabinet Secretary for Justice of that fact. There may of course be specific occasions when there is a need to increase numbers on a short-term basis to respond to specific risks and threats. We fully support the chief constable’s operational duty to take immediate decisions that reflect any such threats.
In conclusion, I once again state that we should be proud of the fact that our police officers are routinely unarmed, despite the challenges and dangers that they face on a daily basis. However, I believe that, in the world in which we live, it is necessary for the safety of officers and members of the public to have a very limited number of officers who are capable of providing firearms and Taser support.
Armed officers do a difficult job of which we should be proud. In a democracy, it is right that their deployment should be a decision for the chief constable and not for a political minister or party. However, it is also important that there should be sufficient safeguards and checks and balances. It is for that reason that we have the Scottish Police Authority, the Justice Sub-Committee on Policing, the Police Investigations and Review Commissioner, Her Majesty’s inspector of constabulary for Scotland and a standing firearms authority that is reviewed quarterly.
I hope that Parliament will join me in thanking the officers not just for their service during the Commonwealth games but for the job that they do on a daily basis in their communities the length and breadth of Scotland.