I start by thanking those MSPs who supported my motion and enabled it to be debated today.
The British Medical Association’s your GP cares campaign emphasises that general practice is the cornerstone of the national health service and is at the heart of every community. The service provided by general practitioners and primary healthcare teams—from professionals covering vast remote areas to those working in large city practices—is appreciated the length and breadth of the country and admired across the chamber.
Amid a wealth of specialisms and the involvement of departments across the health service and beyond, GPs are often the only constant during a patient’s care, identifying symptoms, assessing needs, signposting to other services and co-ordinating a joined-up approach to the patient’s care. That continuity means that GPs are capable of developing the most acute understanding of individuals’ overall health.
Providing more than 24 million consultations each year, GPs are integral to improving Scotland’s health and wellbeing and to the objective to shift the balance of treatment and care away from hospitals towards primary settings.
The your GP cares campaign highlights the need for that patient shift to be accompanied by an appropriate transfer of resources to and investment in primary care team personnel and practice infrastructure. It draws our attention to the challenges posed by patients’ changing needs.
In the gallery today is Dr Alan McDevitt, chairman of the BMA’s Scottish GP committee. He tells us:
“There are more patients to see, more test results to read and more paperwork. Yet there are still the same number of hours in the day and many GP surgeries are simply overwhelmed.”
ISD Scotland data shows that the number of patient contacts with GPs and practice nurses has increased by 10 per cent during the past decade. Twelve per cent of registered patients now visit their local practice 10 or more times a year. The intense workload can, in part, be attributed to our growing ageing population and the need to support people who are living longer with complex, chronic or multiple health conditions. Long-term conditions already account for the majority of consultations, but the prevalence of conditions such as dementia will soar as the number of people aged over 75 doubles during the next 20 years.
The demands on general practice are particularly acute in my own North East Scotland region, and there is real concern that they are affecting GPs’ ability to best care for their patients. Official statistics show that six of the biggest 20 practices, by patient list size, are in the north-east. Many serve areas with burgeoning populations and two possess more than 20,000 patients. Facilities are already creaking and yet the third national planning framework, which was published this week, reminds us the north-east’s population will grow by 23 per cent by 2035.
A question mark still hangs over the provision of a medical centre for the new town of Chapelton—a development that will provide up to 8,000 homes. That has caused my constituents to fear that the nearby Portlethen medical centre, which is already one of the busiest in the country, could soon be overwhelmed. Elsewhere, staff at Ellon health centre are striving to provide for a growing community, but they are hampered by premises that are no longer fit for purpose, having been built when the town was a fraction of its current size. NHS Grampian says that it will be “some years” before it is replaced. Such situations are common across Scotland.
The Scottish Liberal Democrats believe that communities know best how to run locally responsive services. It would therefore be remiss of me not to note that the Scottish Government seized control of health boards’ capital budgets, stripping them of powers to tackle infrastructure problems as they see fit. This year, NHS Grampian will receive less than 2 per cent of non-formula capital spend for specific projects.
This week, the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing confirmed to my colleague Jim Hume that the proportion of the NHS budget that is spent on primary medical services has fallen under this Government. It peaked at 9.1 per cent under the Liberal Democrat-Labour Administration and has fallen to 7.5 per cent this year.
General practice is the gateway to the wider NHS. Clinical decisions that are made in general practice commit more than half of total NHS expenditure. The Scottish Government must therefore ensure that general practice is sufficiently resourced to take the right decisions and that opportunities to build relationships with patients, understand their needs and effectively communicate what is happening are enhanced, not diminished, as care shifts from acute to primary settings.
Indeed, GPs’ workloads have already soared as the profession struggles to attract and retain talent. Young doctors appear to be pursuing other specialisms. In the Aberdeenshire community health partnership, the number who are working part time has increased by 9 per cent in the past five years alone. Worryingly, I have been told that early retirements are up, with more than a third of staff in their 50s. Others are emigrating in search of a better work-life balance.
This morning, The Scotsman reported that more than 30 practices across Scotland are operating an “open but full” policy and are accepting registrations on a limited basis only. However, Dr McDevitt has told us that many practices
“wouldn’t be able to take on a new doctor even if they wanted to.”
The Scottish Government must therefore intensify its efforts to attract and retain GPs and reverse the losses that have been experienced during the past three years.
We cannot expect GPs and practice staff to spend more time with patients and provide more appropriate care closer to home without sufficient resources, additional staff or appropriate facilities. As the nature of primary care changes, it is imperative that health boards and GPs are capable of responding to local needs and demands. They must be empowered to provide integrated and sustainable primary health services that are rooted in communities, focused on every aspect of patients’ health, delivered in a fitting environment and of the highest quality.
I would be grateful if the minister could therefore tell us whether he considers the current distribution of total NHS expenditure to be appropriate. Will he hand back some power over capital spending to boards or ensure a fairer allocation? I would welcome details of how he intends to attract and retain the staff who are required to deliver shared objectives, including those of enhancing preventative care, reducing hospital admissions, tackling the unacceptable number of delayed discharges and integrating adult health and social care services.