Let me offer another quotation from Brian Keighley, from the same “GMS” interview. Johann Lamont does not want to accept this, but he said:
“Clearly my target is not the current Cabinet Secretary, my target is the political classes in Scotland.”
The point that he was making was that health resources are under pressure because of rising demand. He accepted that we have done everything that we can, under the constraints of the Barnett formula, to protect the national health service.
I think that we are entitled to ask whether that would have been done if the Labour Party had been in power over the past seven years. We know that it would not have been done in 2007, because Jack McConnell said that the NHS would just have to cut its coat to suit its cloth and would not have access to the Barnett consequentials. We doubt that it would have been done in 2011, either, because the Labour Party refused to commit to the resources in real terms.
If we want evidence of the Labour Party in power, we should just look to Wales, which is suffering the same stresses as Scotland under the Barnett formula but is, on every measurement, turning in a worse health performance.
Does Johann Lamont accept the connection between the resources that are available to us under the Barnett formula and the ability to fund the national health service to the degree that Brian Keighley and all of us would want? Is not that an argument for our having access to Scotland’s resources, so that we can deliver that desirable outcome? [Applause.]