Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Tinkers’ Heart of Argyll (PE1523)

Tuesday 30 September 2014 Public Petitions Committee About 10:00–10:30 Petitions 34 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

34 contributions
Jess Smith
link

Thank you, convener.

In 2010, I was informed that the Tinkers’ Heart of quartz stone, at the junction of Hell’s Glen and the road to Strachur, was almost destroyed due to neglect and cattle trampling over it. My husband and I went to see for ourselves and when I saw the state of the place a knot formed like a stone in my stomach. It was like witnessing the death knell of an entire culture.

The Travelling folk whose families came from the area, and many of those who had left, believed that the Heart was indestructible—a living monument—and that nothing and no one would interfere with the place. Locals were proud to say that it was in their part of Argyll, and it served as a church to those who went there: some to baptise babies, others to get married and others to remember those who had died. The little Heart was all the Travellers had. It is an ancient place, and nobody has discovered its roots.

It is believed that the lads of the Cowal who did not return from the battlefield of Culloden moor were remembered by their families placing white quartz stones in the shape of a heart on the ground overlooking Loch Fyne. There are those who say that it was appropriate to place the stones there because it is believed that on that ancient spot had stood a Celtic church. A standing stone is supposed to have towered on the spot, but it was destroyed and the stones were arranged to indicate where it stood. We really do not know its history.

In 1808, at the construction of roads, the Heart lay there undisturbed. The builders worked around it, making certain that they did not interfere with it. In 1928, at a meeting of the Cowal district committee, Lady George Campbell protested against any interference with the Heart, which at times became covered in grass:

“that patch, she held, was of historical and sentimental interest, as it was known from time immemorial to have been the place where the wedding ceremony of Tinkers took place.”

The Rev John MacCorkindale, from Lochgoilhead, officiated at ceremonies there. Travellers—some with horses and carts, others with small prams—and foot soldiers visited year after year, and they knew him well. It was their place to go to be reinstated with the earth. There was also a tramp man who built a small hut down the road part ways to Cairndhu, and it is said that he watched over the Heart for many a year.

Allow me to read a letter to you. It was addressed to the headmaster of Ferryden primary school, near Montrose, whose name was Mr Whyte. He had written to Betsy Whyte, congratulating her on the publication of “The Yellow on the Broom”, and this is her reply:

“Dear Mr Whyte,

Your letter was a delightful surprize. Of course we remember you, but can hardly believe that you are retired. The years have slipped past so stealthily.

One of my most pleasant memories of Ferryden was of you.

It was the day of the queen’s coronation and the weather had become rather nasty so the children’s fancy dress parade was held in the scouts hall.

I was standing behind you and the other officials, and I heard you say, ‘I think the sheik and his wife are the best dressed bairns.’ However the councillor said to you, ‘Och, but that’s the tinks. You cannae pick them.’ The children were my daughter and her cousin. I turned away, feeling rather depressed, to think that those educated men had so little sense.

Then imagine my surprize when I heard you say (I can remember your exact words), ‘I don’t think anyone can dispute that the sheik and his wife are the best dressed children.’ I truly admired your courage, and during your stay in Ferryden there was no discrimination nor segregation of the traveller children.”

You might ask what the Traveller culture has to do with Celtic history or any other piece of Scottish history. Well, as the battle of Culloden was in 1746, you may want to read Robert Burns’s “Address of Beelzebub” to the head of the Highland Society, who wanted a certain Lord Glengarry, who was successful in murdering and scattering 500 Glengarry Highlanders. When the pye-coated gentlemen of Edinburgh invited him to pen the poem, Burns—who was the great-grandson of Walter Campbell of Lorn, a strong Jacobite—spat fire when he said:

“yes, I’ll write it but not frae me, only the devil would sup wha sic a chiel. I’ll dae him the honour.”

The poem was penned in 1786, long before the clearances and only 40 years after Culloden. Here is an extract:

“Get out a horse-whip, or a jowler,

The langest thong, the fiercest growler,

An’ gar the tatter’d gipseys pack

Wi’ a’ their bastarts on their back!”

Burns’s ancestral roots were so strong that he followed his heart, and he showed immense courage.

When she took on the Cowal district committee, Lady Campbell, too, showed courage. I can imagine the look of surprise on the faces of those councillors: she may have thumped the table and insisted that the old Heart be protected. There is no doubt that her request would have seen eyebrows raised when she demanded:

“No, let the Tinkers keep their Heart.”

That was a very courageous gesture from such a prestigious Argyllshire lady.

When the Rev John MacCorkindale ignored the might of the Church of Scotland, carried his Bible under his arm and gave his time to baptise the Traveller baby, give comfort to the relatives of the deceased and bless the union of a young couple heading on their journey of marriage, he too showed courage. That is what he portrayed, because if his masters had discovered that he was officiating outside the house of God, he may well have lost his position and his manse.

Every day that young Travellers step inside school, they know that at any time they could be subjected to bullying. They are aware that their right to an education is theirs—a gift from the country of their birth. Their parents and grandparents suffered the same discrimination. The youngsters could take the easy way out and stop schooling—who could blame them?—but they desperately want an education so that they can go to university and fulfil their dreams. So they bite their tongues and live with verbal and physical abuse, and that takes a lot of courage. To those young people, the Heart is so much more than a monument. It is an indicator of what they believe is their culture. It represents a future—a place to visit and say, “We are part of this country and we can make a difference.”

Let us remain proud of our ancestors, because they kept our dreams for equality alive. They travelled to this little place in all weathers. We would like to say thank you, and the only way we know how is to fight for the Tinkers’ Heart of Argyll to be scheduled and protected by Historic Scotland, which we now invite to show some courage.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I thank Mike Russell very much for that, which expresses both the philosophy and helpful practical steps. From a personal viewpoint, I am going to Argyll and Bute during the upcoming recess, and I will certainly make sure that I visit the Heart when I am there. Thank you for drawing it to the attention of both me and the committee.

With regard to the practical steps, it would be useful if you could get Historic Scotland to classify the monument as a scheduled ancient monument—to use the technical term—and to consider restoration and preservation.

Can you describe your approaches to Historic Scotland so far?

10:15

Michael Russell SNP Argyll and Bute
link

I met Kate Howe on one occasion to discuss the matter. To be fair to her, she says that she is very keen to ensure that the monument is preserved, and the local historical society makes the same statement. However, with the best will in the world, they do not have the skills to maintain such a monument—it is simply impossible for them—and nor do they have the resources to maintain the monument or its setting.

In all those circumstances, and taking what she said at face value, I hope that she will co-operate with Historic Scotland and the Royal Commission on the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Scotland. We should have mentioned RCAHMS, because it has been positive and its enthusiasm has really pushed forward the issue. Those bodies need to come in and make it happen.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

As I said, it is interesting that the site was, in effect, a public highway. The reason why the Tinkers’ Heart was there is probably because of the access routes from different parts of Argyll for people travelling there and settling for short periods of time. It would be interesting if we could get Historic Scotland or whoever to find out what conditions apply when public land or public highways come into private ownership.

As Mike Russell indicated, it is quite clear that the old road that passes through the site would give some access to it, and to parking, without too many problems, but it is worrying that the site is currently fenced off so that it is not readily accessible at all times by the community that would want to use the Tinkers’ Heart.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you very much. That was a very interesting presentation, and I really appreciate your coming along and talking to the committee today.

I now ask Mike Russell to add his contribution.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

I am glad to hear that Jess Smith is keeping the oral traditions of the community alive and well, as well as putting many of the stories down in writing. The people of Scotland should be proud of the tradition, and they should be well aware of the struggles and history of Travelling people in Scotland. As Jess Smith says, some of them have moved to other lands, but their hearts remain in Scotland. That is the whole issue about the Tinkers’ Heart.

Ms Smith stated in the background information on the petition that

“The Historic Scotland rep said they would not go against the wishes of the landowner.”

It worries me that an ancient monument has clearly been identified, but Historic Scotland, despite its powers and authority, does not wish to go against the landowner’s wishes. That type of statement frightens me, because it clearly indicates that Historic Scotland is failing to understand its role in preserving the history of Scotland, in particular its physical history, because of the wishes of a landowner.

Mr Russell referred to the landowner saying that she will do things to preserve the site, but do you understand that to include continued access to the Tinkers’ Heart? For me, one of the main issues is about continued access to the site for not only the Travelling community but others who might wish to visit.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

That was a touching story, and it is quite nice to be asked to consider a monument that is a source of joy rather than one where people were sacrificed. I very often find that we are asked, rather luridly, to do that.

In essence, it does not seem to me that a huge financial demand underpins the request, which is encouraging, but I am a little bit worried that we might evolve an exaggerated expectation that there is a unique tourism opportunity. I take it that, rather than frightening the horses slightly with talk of a major centre or something of that character being built on the site, Jess Smith sees the site more as one of a number of things in the immediate community around Loch Fyne and elsewhere that could attract tourism. It seems to me to be important that we do not polarise the debate and completely alienate the landowner in the process.

Do you see the proposal as an effort to underpin and preserve something that would be there to see and appreciate when people are in the community and the area, and for us to do all that we can to encourage the Government and Historic Scotland, with the authority of Parliament, to pursue the request with a little bit more enthusiasm and resolve?

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

I agree with that approach, convener, but I imagine that what has been said is slightly anecdotal. When we write to the council, we should be a little bit cautious in relation to ownership of the road and the land. We should ask the council for its best information about that rather than assert a position as having been validated.

Michael Russell SNP Argyll and Bute
link

Thank you very much, convener—I also thank the committee for hearing the petition.

I start by paying tribute to Jess Smith, who I am very proud to call a friend now. We have been working on the petition for a number of years and I am quite certain that it will have success. It will do so not only because of her determination but because of all the people behind her—some are here today—who feel very passionately that it is about time that we recognise the contribution of the Travelling people of Scotland to our nation in two ways: by recognising the historic contribution that they have made, which Jess has outlined strongly; and by reconciling that contribution with the modern day. The Tinkers’ Heart of Argyll is the only physical artefact that we can associate with the Travelling people; there is no other physical artefact in Scotland with that association. In those circumstances, the Heart forms a unique contribution to our heritage, both tangible and intangible.

The Convention for the Safeguarding of the Intangible Cultural Heritage was adopted by the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization—UNESCO—in October 2003 and came into force in 2006, but successive United Kingdom Governments have still not ratified it. However, the convention makes an important contribution to our understanding of this whole issue: history is not just about places and buildings, but about the intangible and cultural contribution that comes from groups in the community. The remarkable artefact that is the Heart brings those two aspects together. It does not matter too much whether it has always been in exactly the same place or whether, as the committee’s briefing paper indicates, it might have had more stones in it at one stage; it is a vitally important symbol of the contribution to Scotland of a very important group. In those circumstances, we should do everything that we can to preserve it and to enhance its meaning and availability. I make that point very strongly.

At the moment, the monument—I want to call it a monument—is not scheduled, but it should be. Scheduling can happen—I do not think that Historic Scotland has given enough weight to the convention on intangible heritage. I think that Historic Scotland could make an exception and schedule the monument.

In the circumstances, the campaigners want—proactively and along with others, including Argyll and Bute Council—to bring into the situation the landowner, who really needs to be focused on and involved in it, and the community, which similarly needs to be focused and involved, to do three important things.

The first is to improve physical access to the monument. It stands in a field at a very awkward road junction where parking is dangerous. A piece of old road is available next to it, which could provide access and parking.

Secondly, significant signage is required. At present, there is one very small, inadequate sign, and the landowner and their family have proposed the provision of further information at a community information point that is 3 miles distant. However, that is contrary to all good practice; there should be good, substantial, well-designed signage on the site that explains the significance of the spot and its significance to the Travelling people, including Jess Smith, whose grandmother was born not so far from it. Am I right about that, Jess?

Jess Smith
link

We met Historic Scotland once at the council building in Kilmory. We were there to discuss the Heart, but I felt that, given the way in which the meeting proceeded, the person from Historic Scotland had already made up his mind and was a bit negative. I would have loved to have got into conversation with him, because we need to educate people about what has, until the present day, often been kept among oral traditionists who shared stories and songs. Hamish Henderson could have told you about that. The history of Scotland went from campfire to campfire, but it was never written down. I have attempted to write down as I much as I can in six books, but we need a lot more history. We need the young to be involved and to get back some respect for their culture before it drifts away into the mists of time.

Jess Smith
link

The landowner has stipulated that she does not want to make any changes. To stop cattle tramping over it and destroying it, a big black cage has been put round the Tinkers’ Heart, but that is temporary. The cattle are big Highland cattle with big horns and they will break it down—in fact, the cage is already dented. She said that she wanted only small signage on the gate. When a suggestion was made to have a sort of little kissing gate for the entrance, she decided against that. She will look after the Tinkers’ Heart as it is, in a cage in a field with cattle and with no access for anyone. Old people cannot visit if they cannot climb the gate. She wanted the gate to be locked, although I do not think that that is allowed under Scottish access rights. After all, it is part of the roads system that at one time belonged to the public, although it is now derelict. I found that she did not want to change anything. That is really why I am here today; we will all die, so we need another body to protect the Tinkers’ Heart and look after it.

Jess Smith
link

Absolutely. Ideally, I would love to see the landowner come on board. I would love the landowner—if, indeed, it is her land—to say, “Gosh! This is my land. What an honour that I have it.” I would love to see everything positive. We are not asking for kelpie horses; we are just asking for a wee dyke around the area. We want a nice little ornamental place with a little path into it, and for people to know that it exists from the map of Scotland and that this country respects the Travelling culture to the extent that it went to the bother to do that and to say, “Yes, we believe in the Travellers. We know what they’ve given this country.” Hamish Henderson lived in and out of the Stewarts of Blair, gathering the ballads, singing the songs and enjoying all that. The school of Scottish studies is packed with all those stories and visions from the past. He said that the Travelling people are the roots of the music of Scotland. My sister could sing 20 to 30 verses of ballads at the age of seven because that was the natural thing to do.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Yes. That is a sensible point.

Jess Smith
link

It was my mother.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

So it would be helpful for the committee to submit—if it agrees to do so—a very strong representation to Historic Scotland and perhaps to the Scottish Government. It would also seem sensible to contact Argyll and Bute Council and the landowner. Would those be sensible and practical steps?

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

You referred to the fact that the site where the Heart stands is on what was a public road. I am a bit bemused. If it was a public road, why does it now belong to a private landowner?

Michael Russell SNP Argyll and Bute
link

If I might uncharacteristically praise Jackson Carlaw, he has put things particularly well on this occasion. There is an existing partnership to look after the monument. That is a partnership of the landowner, her cousin Christina, who runs Here We Are, which is where the interpretive material is, the Noble family and the community in Cairndow. I have said previously in a letter to the local paper that all that is being asked for is that that partnership admit two new members.

One of those would be Historic Scotland, which needs to be part of the partnership, as it has the expertise and the money, although not a great deal of money is involved. Historic Scotland has indicated that it would put something towards the monument. The other partner would be the Traveller people of Scotland. At a time when we are looking at different ways of doing things, and at more participation, they must be involved in decision making about the site, which is theirs. Whatever the title deeds say or do not say, the site is theirs, and they need to be part of the partnership.

If those two additional partners can join in, we will get a much-enhanced site. It will not be the Disneyland of Cowal by any manner of means, but it will be a place at which some people will want to stop. They will be able to stop safely—the site is currently unsafe—and find out more about the site. As they stand at the top of Loch Fyne and look down at a magnificent view to the shore and the loch, they will reflect on a number of things, including the role of Travellers in Scotland, and they will learn from that.

The proposal is modest in scale and scope, but it has huge significance. The Travellers have to be part of that.

10:30

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

If we are writing to Historic Scotland, I suggest that we ask it to clarify what exactly its role is in preserving historic sites and monuments. It is clear that, if the site is a historic one that we are being asked to preserve, we should get a more rounded picture of how Historic Scotland sees its role in relation to such sites. I would hate to think that, when we write to it, it will give us a response about the site; I would prefer to get a more in-depth response about the wider aspects of Historic Scotland, how it sees its role in preserving sites, and with whom it engages.

Michael Russell SNP Argyll and Bute
link

Jess’s mother was born on the shore down below the monument. That should be in the story that needs to be told about how people and Travellers lived in Argyll.

The third thing is maintenance. An arrangement needs to be put in place to clean up the monument. It is presently surrounded by a metal container, which, although an improvement on what was previously there, is by no means best practice. The monument should be maintained and looked after in a way that speaks of its importance.

I have been delighted to work with Jess and others on the issue. It is unfinished business for Travelling people, but also for Argyll. It would draw many people to a part of Argyll that does not draw as many as it should, so that they can understand the importance of the Travelling community.

When I was very much younger, I saw Traveller families living on the shores of Loch Fyne. That no longer takes place, but the area is redolent of the very productive, positive contribution of the Travelling people of Scotland. I feel extremely strongly that that should now be recognised properly by the landowner, Historic Scotland, the Scottish Government and all of us as a community so that we can move forward.

Jess Smith
link

Yes. I have been fighting and campaigning on the issue for four years, with the help of a lot of other people, but I have found that the landowner seems to have made up her mind that nothing will progress and that she will look after the monument. With all due respect, as I have said to the landowner, she will die and I will die—we will all die—but the monument, like all the other monuments in Scotland, such as the war memorials, must be preserved. The monuments must live on, because they are not about the living but about everybody. We really have to look after them.

The landowner may want to keep the little cage there and allow access, but the position could change at any minute. Protection has to be cemented.

Jess Smith
link

There is a lady in the gallery who has gone to great lengths, including freedom of information requests, but she cannot find out when that public road changed ownership. In fact, we do not know for sure who owns it. We have gone to great lengths and looked at the register of sasines and the land register, but we do not know. There is a family called Noble. Christina Noble owns one estate in the area and her nephew owns another one, Ardkinglas. Kate Howe owns the neighbouring one, which is Ardno. We really do not know who owns the road.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

That is a very sensible point that goes back to Jess Smith’s initial contribution. We need to ask Historic Scotland what the decision-making process is to make the site a scheduled ancient moment, because that is the trigger under the legislation. It would then have a requirement to follow that through. I presume that that is a delegated power to the officers rather than a ministerial power; Mike Russell can probably identify whether that is incorrect. I would certainly want that action to be taken, as that process triggers powers under the legislation that open up all sorts of other opportunities. We need to be clear on that.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

As Mike Russell said, it is a great opportunity to develop tourism in Argyll and Bute, which is such a beautiful area.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you for that. As no other member wishes to ask questions, the next step is the summation. We will look at next steps for the petition.

I think that I suggested at the start that we clearly need to send a note to Historic Scotland and to make representations on the petitioners’ behalf to the Scottish Government. If the committee agrees to do that, it seems sensible also to write to Argyll and Bute Council. I think that it would also be a good step to take to ask Argyll and Bute Council and the landowner about ownership of the road. Those are four practical steps; the committee may have others. Does the committee agree that we should take those four steps? Is there anybody additional whom we should approach?

Jess Smith
link

We have to press forward the recognition of the culture, because not enough people in authority in Scotland recognise the culture, its history and how long we have been here. Tinkler Johnstone—I use the word “tinkler” with respect—is recorded in the A K Bell library in Perth as being a hammerman in the 12th century. We are told that the Travellers came here in the 1500s, but they have been in Scotland for a lot longer than that.

When the Duke of Argyll was invited in 1913 by a Mr O’Neill, who was a historian from Dublin, to speak on the clans, Mr O’Neill asked, “Can you trace them?” The Duke of Argyll said, “Oh, aye. I can trace them right back to the first seed, but don’t ask me to trace the cairdrage”—the subclans. He said, “I cannot.” Another word for tinker in Scotland is cairdrage.

Jess Smith
link

Yes. Being an author, I have spent time in many parts of the world such as Australia, Nova Scotia and New Zealand. The people from my culture who moved several generations ago have not taken off their birth coat and are very proud of who they are. They want to come to Scotland: they say, “We want to go back to Scotland, the place of our ancestors’ birth, but where do we go?” They know that their ancestors travelled round Argyll and Perthshire and that they were very much like the clans, but they want to know where they went.

I believe that Argyll and Bute Council could show a little bit of foresight. It could say, “Let’s think about this. We could get a wee car park. We could get tourists in and let them have a look and enjoy Loch Fyne—and they would spend their money in other parts of Argyll, too.” If the tourism industry took that on board, the Heart could become quite an asset for Argyllshire.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

We sometimes overuse the word “unique”, but I think that the site is unique, and we should remember that.

Do members of the committee agree to that course of action?

Members indicated agreement.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Agenda item 2 is consideration of four new petitions. The committee has invited petitioners to speak to three of the petitions.

The first new petition is PE1523, by Jess Smith, on giving the Tinkers’ Heart of Argyll back to the Travelling people. Members have a note by the clerk, the briefing from the Scottish Parliament information centre and the petition. I welcome Jess Smith. I also welcome Mike Russell, the constituency MSP for Argyll and Bute, who has had a great interest in the petition.

I ask Jess Smith to speak to the petition for a maximum of five minutes. That will be followed by a contribution from Mike Russell. I will then kick off with some questions, after which I will invite my colleagues to ask questions. I will then summarise the discussion, and thereafter we will look at the next steps for the petition.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Funding is available, which could be accessed.

Thank you both for your evidence. I throw open the discussion to questions from my colleagues.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

As Jess Smith has heard, we are obviously very enthusiastic about the petition. We will keep her up to date with developments, and the clerks will let her know when it is scheduled to be considered again. She may want to come to sit in the gallery on that particular day. We will certainly pursue the matter, and we will obviously keep Mike Russell up to date, as well, because I know that he is very interested in the petition.

I thank you very much for coming to the meeting and thank all your colleagues for all the work that they have done on the petition, which is very interesting.

Jess Smith
link

I thank you all on behalf of the Travelling people.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Not at all.

I suspend the meeting for two minutes to allow our witnesses to change round.

10:33 Meeting suspended.

10:35 On resuming—

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

That was an excellent presentation from Jess Smith and Mr Russell.

I must admit, to my shame, that I was not aware of the Tinker’s Heart until I saw the petition. I must also admit that I was touched by Jess Smith’s heartfelt plea for proper recognition of the site.

I have read the briefing that members received prior to the meeting. It is unfortunate, to say the least, that the landowner, Kate Howe, seems to be less than supportive. Some issues have been raised by the convener, but have either of you, or any local politicians, had face-to-face meetings with Ms Howe?

Jess Smith
link

I have written to her, and have even included stamped addressed envelopes, but she refuses to reply. Mike Russell has met her.

  1. 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 34
  2. 10:30 New Petitions Petitions · 43
  3. 11:00 New Petitions Petitions · 19
  4. 11:15 Current Petitions Petitions · 19
  5. 11:15 Current Petitions Petitions · 18
  6. 11:15 Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  7. 11:15 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  8. 12:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  9. 12:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  10. 12:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  11. 12:00 New Petitions Petitions · 3
  12. 12:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  13. 12:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  14. 12:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.