The next petition is PE1497, by Ellie Harrison, on behalf of Say No to Tesco, on supermarket expansion on local high streets. Members have a note by the clerk.
Patrick Harvie has a strong constituency interest but was unsure about whether he would be able to come today. Sandra White also has an interest in the issue, but she is currently at the Justice Committee and sends her apologies for her inability to attend.
We have two choices on the petition: we can close it on the basis that we have explored the issue as far as we can within the policy areas that are devolved to the Scottish Parliament, or we can ask the Local Government and Regeneration Committee to consider the petition in the context of its scrutiny of the Community Empowerment (Scotland) Bill. My preference is for the latter option.
I am certainly loth to close the petition; it has some merit, in particularly in respect of the claims that major retailers are riding roughshod over independent retailers in some areas. I would certainly prefer to refer the petition to the Local Government and Regeneration Committee to allow it to incorporate it in the work that it is doing on the Community Empowerment (Scotland) Bill.
Thank you for that. Patrick Harvie has just arrived, and I know that he has a strong constituency interest in the petition. Do you want to address the committee on your support for the petition?
David StewartLabThe Convener · Highlands and Islands
Thank you very much, convener. I apologise for just making it here by the skin of my teeth, and slightly out of breath.
I am aware that this is not a full evidence session on the petition, so I thank you, convener, for giving me the opportunity to speak briefly to it. I simply want to put on the record again the strong interest in the issue—of which I am sure members are aware—throughout the country, including in my region, which is Glasgow. In the few months since the committee last considered the petition, I have become aware of even more small independent businesses that have roots in the communities that they serve having gone out of business in areas where supermarket expansion is continuing. That flies in the face of the stated intentions to encourage retail diversity, and vibrant and diverse high streets and shopping areas.
I encourage the committee to take seriously the conflict that exists between the stated objective of treating all applicants equally and the objective of encouraging retail diversity. An equality policy that treats everybody equally does not achieve genuine equality because people have different needs, so the policy of treating all applicants equally, regardless of their identity, of the nature of the retail offer that will change the situation, and of what we know very clearly about the economic impact of supermarket expansion will not achieve the stated planning objective of encouraging retail diversity. Again, I encourage the committee to look as creatively and as open-mindedly as possible at the petitioner’s case.
It is not extra work, convener. I remain to be convinced that the Community Empowerment (Scotland) Bill is sufficient to deal with the issue that the petitioner has raised. We have been told in submission after submission that planning alone cannot deal with the issue. The question is whether or not the text of the section of the bill that is specified in our papers for today’s meeting is sufficient to allay the fears of the petitioner and of other communities around Scotland.
Another issue is the Government’s view on additional powers, and whether any aspects of the bill as it is currently drafted could be amended to take account of the concerns that the petition raises.
I am not sure whether the original petitioner, Ellie Harrison, has responded to any of the points that have been raised in the responses that the committee has received. It would have been useful to have received a written submission from the petitioners to indicate their views on the responses to date, and how they think we should progress the issue.
The original request was to look at the planning legislation and to find out how local authorities could, through their planning powers, tackle the issue of the footprint that is being left by some major retailers in our town centres. The question was whether the bill as drafted can allow local authorities and others to raise reasonable objections or concerns about a major multinational company siting itself on the corner or centre of the high street.
David StewartLabThe Convener · Highlands and Islands
You missed my comments about our options on the petition. We boiled it down to two, which are to close the petition on the basis that we have explored the issues as far as we can, and to refer the petition to the Local Government and Regeneration Committee because it is scrutinising the Community Empowerment (Scotland) Bill. The latter option might be more appealing to you. What are your views on the options?
David StewartLabThe Convener · Highlands and Islands
Thank you for that. With regard to your first point, the petitioner has not responded. I agree that it would have been useful to have had that information.
The complexity with the petition is that some elements of it are reserved to competition policy, which makes things quite difficult. I accept the point about planning. I am quite encouraged by the Community Empowerment (Scotland) Bill as it contains some sensible ideas, but you are probably right to say that it will not be a magic wand in relation to the petition.
I just feel that, as the Local Government and Regeneration Committee is examining the bill, there might be an opportunity for that committee to do a bit more work on the petition. I take Jackson Carlaw’s point: the petitioner has done a lot of work in submitting evidence, and I want to ensure that the evidence goes before another committee that can look at it with fresh eyes.
If those are the only two options, then you will perhaps not be surprised to learn that I encourage the committee to refer the petition on. The on-going mismatch between the stated objectives and what is happening on the ground, not just in Glasgow but around the country, requires further consideration.
I merely note that if the committee wishes to pass the petition to the Local Government and Regeneration Committee for further consideration, the timetable for examination of the bill is very heavy and it may be difficult to add to that reasonable consideration of the petition if we want the issues that it raises to be given full justice.
If committee members are so minded, the Local Government and Regeneration Committee will take the petition on board, but there is a question about whether or not it has the time. We on that committee have already diarised the dates for our evidence sessions and our work ahead. This committee can by all means pass on the petition, but we should not expect a full and detailed examination of the issues that it raises.
David StewartLabThe Convener · Highlands and Islands
To prove that I am not a complete curmudgeon, I am happy to support the latter option. I do so for two reasons. First, I am aware that the petitioners feel very strongly that we have not done justice to the considerable volume of work that they produced, although as you will know from my previous contributions on the petition I am not entirely sympathetic to supporting the conclusion that the petitioners wish for. In addition, to give balance to Mr Harvie’s intervention, I have become aware, in the time since the committee last considered the petition, of areas and towns in Scotland where the opening of a local convenience store on an otherwise derelict high street has led to the prospering of additional new businesses adjacent to it. We must be very careful that we do not mount an unsubstantiated crusade against local convenience stores simply because they are being operated by national retail multiples.
Thank you for that. I would never accuse you of being a curmudgeon. I invite other members to give their views on the petition. Are we happy to refer it to the Local Government and Regeneration Committee?
I have spoken, convener; I said that I am loth to close the petition because it has some merits, especially in taking into account the view that major retailers are riding roughshod over independent retailers in certain areas of the country.
Thank you. We are agreed by majority that we will refer the petition to the Local Government and Regeneration Committee so that it can look at the issues as part of its scrutiny of the Community Empowerment (Scotland) Bill. I thank Patrick Harvie for coming along and making his submission, and I thank the petitioners for all the work that they have done on the issue.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.