We should continue the petition and we should, as John Wilson suggested, ask the petitioners for their views on how to move forward.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
National Bird (PE1500)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- David Stewart Lab 8
- Jackson Carlaw Con 4
- Jim Eadie SNP 2
- Anne McTaggart Lab 1
- David Torrance SNP 1
- Angus MacDonald SNP 1
- John Wilson Ind 1
The record
18 contributions
link
I am happy to go with the recommendations.
The next petition is PE1500, by Stuart Housden OBE, on behalf of RSPB Scotland, on the golden eagle as the national bird of Scotland. Members have a note by the clerk and the submissions. I invite contributions from members.
I am open to clarification, but I recall that a precedent was set with regard to the Scots pine, when the Forestry Commission conducted a consultation. I would be happy to go along with John Wilson’s suggestion that we contact the RSPB to see whether it is willing to undertake a consultation, and then we can bring it back.
We have received what I regard as a most commendable further letter from the Minister for Environment and Climate Change, who has reiterated—very sensibly, I think—the point that I tried to make at a previous meeting. That point is that the case has not been proven regarding the general adoption of national symbols for this, that and the next thing, and regarding the question whether, if there were to be a bird as a national symbol, a decision should be made in favour of any particular species. Given that we have now had two letters from the minister in which he has emphatically made that point, I suggest that we close the petition.
I note that there is some consideration of whether a broader consultation might validate a subsequent opinion on the matter. However, I am not persuaded that the reach of RSPB Scotland or its resource thereby is adequate. We have just had a public consultation that engaged 3.6 million people; I am not altogether sure that a consultation that manages to engage a few thousand people is representative of anything.
I am concerned about the point that the minister makes twice regarding the debate about the general adoption of national symbols. There must be some agreed conclusion on that before we start to consult on what specific individual symbols might be.
I have no strong views on the subject.
I take your point, Mr Carlaw. I am not sure whether you are suggesting that we should have had two questions in the referendum a few weeks ago.
Jackson, do you wish to come back on that point?
That was clearly a missed opportunity.
I do, because that is what the minister said and maybe we have to write it into the record. He said:
“There is also a wider discussion to be had about national symbols generally—what do we want of them, and what other types of national symbols might we want to consider. I recognise that we now have a national tree, the Scots Pine, however I feel that choosing these symbols is more than just an environmental or ecological question.
It was for this reason that I expressed the hope that we might get a more rounded picture by asking other Parliamentary committees for their views. I appreciate that you have done this and received some responses, but I would still prefer that we find a way of getting a considered view from the Parliament about the value and purpose of national symbols and hopefully avoid the potential for ending up with national symbols proposed and designated on what is essentially an ad hoc basis.”
That is a clear recommendation that goes beyond the scope of the immediate petition, which is why I believe that the petition should be closed, although it is an interesting argument for Parliament to consider.
RSPB Scotland is a very large—if not the largest—membership organisation, and I feel strongly that if it was to carry out a consultation, as it has asked to do, it would be done very well. John Wilson wants to add some comments.
I understand that, but I am trying to get some consensus, because the majority of the committee wants to defer and ask the RSPB for its view. If we wrote to the RSPB and it said that it could do a consultation, not just of its members but of the Scottish public, and within a timescale that the Government was happy with, is that not something that we could facilitate? If we get a positive note back, we could discuss it again at a future meeting.
I declare my membership of RSPB Scotland. Jackson Carlaw paraphrased the minister’s letter, which actually states:
“However I am not convinced that a persuasive case has yet been assembled in favour of Scotland having a national bird or for the golden eagle to be that national bird.”
The minister goes on to say:
“you will be aware of the procedure that was devised for the Scots Pine designation. That process did involve some public consultation, and I believe that involving the public would be a vital part of any future procedure”.
As the convener has indicated, RSPB Scotland is currently one of the largest membership organisations in Scotland, if not the United Kingdom. It might be useful to keep the petition open and to contact the petitioner to seek his views on the minister’s letter, with a view to asking whether the RSPB would be prepared to carry out a full consultation of its members, along with other organisations, to determine whether the golden eagle could be designated as a national bird.
I am reminded of the debate on the Scots pine, in which the minister, although he originally indicated that he was not in favour of the Scots pine as a national tree, did, after considering a member’s motion that was before Parliament, agree to the designation. So, a similar issue has been raised in the past, and the minister has taken a view and then relented on his original position.
It may be useful for us to write to the petitioner and seek his views, and to ask whether or not the RSPB would be prepared to carry out the necessary consultation, as outlined by the minister.
I am obviously in the minority. I do not see how that suggestion addresses the question whether we want national symbols, which seems to be the minister’s caveat prior to consideration of adopting any particular symbol for any particular thing. That goes beyond the scope of the petition. Even if the RSPB were to say that it would carry out a consultation, I do not see how that would get us beyond the minister’s consideration of whether we want national symbols.
I ask other members for their views—I will invite Mr Carlaw back in later if he wishes to respond.
Sure. I make one final plea for consensus. If the RSPB does come back on a positive note about running a consultation, and the Government is happy with the type of referendum that it is running, would that resolve the issue that you are raising? That is what happened with the Scots pine.
It is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.
Yes. I am conscious of time; we could probably keep the discussion going for a while. I note Jackson Carlaw’s opposition and I understand it, but a majority wants us to defer the petition and to ask the RSPB whether it is able to run a consultation. Once we get its response, we should check with the Scottish Government on its views and take it from there.
In this meeting
Everything on 30 Sep 2014 →- 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 34
- 10:30 New Petitions Petitions · 43
- 11:00 New Petitions Petitions · 19
- 11:15 Current Petitions Petitions · 19
- 11:15 Current Petitions Petitions · 18
- 11:15 Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- 11:15 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 12:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 12:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- 12:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 12:00 New Petitions Petitions · 3
- 12:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- 12:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- 12:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.