I congratulate my colleague Paul Martin on securing this important debate and I wish Broagan McCuaig a full and speedy recovery.
The motion rightly recognises that the Control of Dogs (Scotland) Act 2010 was a major step forward in tackling the problems that are experienced in many of our communities. The Control of Dogs (Scotland) Bill, which Christine Grahame introduced, sought to ensure that it was not the breed but the actions of a dog that constituted an offence, recognising that it can be difficult to establish the breed, as Christine Grahame said, and that in the right—perhaps that should be “wrong”—circumstances, almost any dog can become out of control and cause problems.
We have read in our newspapers and heard during the debate many harrowing stories about dog attacks on children—young people whose minds and bodies are scarred because a dog was out of control. The fact that there have been so many instances in the past years suggests that the legislation perhaps does not go far enough or is not being resourced to the level that would make it as effective as it could be.
I accept that no legislation, however robust it is, can entirely remove the possibility of someone being bitten by a dog. However, we must ensure that we have done everything in our power to reduce as far as possible the threat that out-of-control dogs pose.
Let me say that I am a dog lover, like most other members. I regret very much that the lifestyle of my household is such that it is not sensible for us to have a dog. Indeed, it would be downright selfish of us to own a dog, because our working hours are such that there is rarely anyone at home and we could not provide a dog with the amount of exercise or attention that it would need. However, some people seem to see a dog as a status symbol, a fashion accessory or, frankly, a sign of how tough they are, and give little thought to whether the environment and life that they can offer a dog will meet its needs. The consequences of having a frustrated, angry or out-of-control dog are all too obvious.
Paul Martin is absolutely right to call for all dogs to be microchipped and their owners’ names and addresses to be registered on a database that can be checked by the police, or by dog wardens, who now have the prime responsibility in this area. Let me demonstrate briefly why I think that a register is needed. Last year, a constituent of mine was out walking her daughter’s small dog in her local area. Out of the blue, a larger dog, which lived at the home of her neighbour, ran out of its owner’s garden, grabbed my constituent’s dog and savaged it to such an extent that the vet had to destroy it an hour or so later.
However, the story does not stop there. My constituent and her daughter were distraught and reported the incident to the police. That is when the problems really began, because the people who owned the house where the dog was on the day in question denied that they were its owners. It belonged to their son. When questioned by the police, the son also denied ownership and claimed that the dog belonged to his partner. She, in turn, said, “No, it’s my uncle’s dog.” The upshot was that it became difficult to identify the owners, which made my constituents’ experience even more difficult than it was already.
We need to have a way in which dogs can be easily identified and in which their owners can be traced with some certainty. Microchipping dogs at the point at which they are sold or exchanged should be compulsory. I accept that there are problems attached to that but we can legislate in this country for the movement of livestock so surely it is not beyond the will of parliamentary draughtsmen to put in place something that would work.
As I have said, when we consider the way in which some dogs are trained or bred to be violent or are denied the amount of exercise or stimulation that they need, it is perhaps no wonder that they sometimes go wrong. In previous times, all dogs had to be licensed but that system did not work either. Perhaps we now need to consider licensing the owners but only after they have proved themselves to understand their dog’s needs and are committed to training their dogs, and looking after them, as befits their breed type and the owner’s home circumstances.
For now, at least, let us get the dogs microchipped and have a real debate around the very welcome consultation that the Scottish Government has undertaken to ensure that we put in place a regime that is not only robust and properly resourced but of which we can be proud, and which gives us some certainty that we have done everything that we can do, as legislators, to try to resolve the issue.