To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01800)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 5
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Tricia Marwick 1
The record
11 contributionsI have engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
The Scottish Government’s white paper compares Scotland’s growth rate with the growth rates of a selection of independent countries. If it were proved that Scots would be better off now had we matched the growth of those nations over the past 30 years, would that be a compelling reason to vote yes?
The compelling reason to vote yes is that we could mobilise the natural and human resources of Scotland to create a prosperous and just society in this country. That is the compelling reason to vote yes.
So, it is not the compelling reason that the First Minister had in his own white paper. That is interesting.
The First Minister’s white paper says that Scots would be better off, if we take the period 1977 to 2007. We asked the Scottish Parliament’s financial scrutiny unit to look at the past 30 years for which figures are available. The same comparison, examined over the past 30 years, actually shows that each and every Scot would be nearly £2,500 worse off. What made the First Minister hand pick the 30-year period from 1977 to 2007 rather than use the most up-to-date figures that are available?
Let us take the most up-to-date figures—figures that are part of the “Government Expenditure and Revenue in Scotland” statistics, which are generally accepted and officially noted by Government. They show that over the past five years, Scotland would have been £12 billion better off had we managed our own resources than we were under the London Government. That £12 billion is a great deal of money that could have been invested in the Scottish economy to promote Scottish jobs, to borrow less—which would have been a good thing—or to start the proceeds of an oil fund, as our colleagues across the North Sea in Norway did.
The belief that those resources would not have been used to the benefit of Scottish society is most extraordinary. As that information comes forward in the referendum campaign, people will see the opportunity to create a more just and prosperous society for an independent Scotland.
That is just so much noise—the First Minister did not answer the question that I asked him. With respect, his white paper chose those dates. It is incumbent on the First Minister to explain why so much of his prospectus is based on an argument that bears no scrutiny.
The First Minister is asking the people of Scotland to trust his white paper. However, it has only one page on Scotland’s finances and it projects finances for just one year. It looks back to a period that favours the First Minister’s case, when the overwhelming evidence is that we would, over the past 10, 20 and 30 years, have been worse off. In his own words, he said that we would be £900 better off, but the truth is that over the past 30 years, by his own rationale, we would have been £2,500 worse off.
That, of course, is the case where there are figures. Where, however, are the price tags for renationalising the Royal Mail, for transformational childcare or for his high-speed rail proposal? No one is suggesting that those are bad things. [Interruption.] Even in the real world, no one thinks that childcare and a rail link are bad things. However, we think that we need to know how we are going to pay for them. Every family in the country understands that. So, I say: “Go on. Don’t just tell us what you are going to propose. Give us just one—one!—of those price tags and let us see whether it is real.”
No one will suggest that those are bad things, but on the basis of its school meals vote, Labour would vote against them anyway.
Let us take any time period that Johann Lamont wants. It is estimated that over the period 1980 to 2011-12—the most recent period for which figures are available—the United Kingdom ran an annual net fiscal deficit of 3.2 per cent of gross domestic product. With our share of Scotland’s resources and North Sea revenue, Scotland would over that period have run an average annual net fiscal surplus of 0.2 per cent of GDP. Those are the figures for the years since 1980; I have already given Johann Lamont the figures for the past five years.
According to the latest figures that we have available, Scotland’s relative fiscal surplus in 2011-12 was £4.4 billion, or £824 per head. That is the amount by which we would have been better off had Scotland been running its own resources.
Johann Lamont says that she does not think that the white paper is ambitious enough, including on childcare, in particular. The white paper is ambitious because it wants to transform childcare in this country, which would in a parliamentary session cost £700 million. The white paper argues that that can come about because of the revenues that will grow from increasing female participation in the workforce by 6 per cent. If we stay within the UK, we will never be able to afford that because the money will go to George Osborne in the London Treasury and—believe me—he is not thinking of giving extra money to Scotland. He, as Margaret Thatcher did before him, is working out how to take money away from Scotland—as long as nobody finds out.
First of all, if we are going to look at this week’s vote, one can only presume that the Scottish National Party Government did not want transformational support for childcare, because it voted it down.
Secondly, whatever figures the First Minister has just quoted, he is no longer defending his own approach justifying support for independence in his white paper. I did not say that the challenge for the white paper is that it is not ambitious enough; I said that it does not match its claims with any figures to make it credible and believable.
The First Minister did not answer the question on prices, but what the Government cannot price the Parliament can. It would cost £1.16 billion for Royal Mail and £1.2 billion for childcare, but there is no explanation of how that would be paid for. As for the rail link, even the Scottish Parliament information centre cannot price that. For those of us who live in the real world, a shopping list without a price list is just a wish list, and according to the First Minister’s own figures we would have even less money to spend on those things. The First Minister has asked us to publish an alternative to his white paper, but is it not the case that the real alternative to the white paper is called the truth? [Interruption.]
Order!
Right. Let us try again with regard to childcare. The white paper outlines that in the first parliamentary term there will be a transformation in childcare with 1,100 hours for three-year-olds and four-year-olds. We believe that that will increase female participation in the workforce by 6 per cent, which will bring us to Scandinavian levels. We also point out that it would release to the Scottish exchequer £700 million, because as people come back into the workforce they will pay income tax, national insurance and VAT. That fund will accrue to the Scottish exchequer, whereas right now it goes down to London. That is why under a fixed budget it is difficult to afford these things.
Johann Lamont should know that, because earlier this week she lodged an amendment that could not be afforded. Her amendment would have cost £100 million when £100 million would not be available in either year to pay for it. She then said that, in order to finance it, she would not go ahead with free school meals; she would deprive the people of Scotland of free school meals for primaries 1 to 3. I have not even mentioned the cuts in business rates, but they were overtaken by Iain Gray’s denial of them. Many of us think that that was a fundamental mistake by the Labour Party that will cost it dear.
I accept—as I did when I looked at the blank faces on the Labour back benches and saw how worried they were about the votes on Tuesday—that, when I say that, I am, of course, being partial. Therefore, let us hear an impartial commentary.
“But despite this win-win situation, Scottish Labour leader Johann Lamont still opposed the move”
on school meals.
“Labour now find themselves opposing a move welcomed by just about anyone with anything to say about education and the eradication of poverty.
Labour are now at loggerheads with charities and campaigners like the EIS teaching union, the STUC, the Unison union and Save the Children, not to mention the Child Poverty Action Group.”
That is yesterday’s Daily Record editorial, which just about sums up the “something for nothing” position of Johann Lamont.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 9 Jan 2014 →- Autumn Budget Statement (Barnett Consequentials) Questions · 11
- Renewables Obligation (Scottish Parliament’s Powers) Questions · 4
- Next-generation Broadband Questions · 8
- Police Scotland (Meetings) Questions · 5
- Common Agricultural Policy Budget 2014 to 2020 Questions · 4
- Food Banks Questions · 4
- Cromarty Bridge Questions · 6
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Serious Sexual Offences First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Economy (Impact of United Kingdom Budget Reductions) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- National 4 and 5 Qualifications First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Childcare Provision First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Dog Control Legislation Members’ business · 27
- City of Edinburgh Council (Portobello Park) Bill: Preliminary Stage Bill debate · 17
- Title Conditions (Scotland) Act 2003 Debate · 34
- Decision Time Decision time · 2
- Point of Order Procedure · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.