Parliament Workbench

Question thread · 4 questions

On what basis the cost of the Forth Replacement Crossing was previously estimated by the Minister for Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change to be £4 billion and on what basis this was later reduced to £2 billion.

Started with S3W-18821 on 11 Dec 2008; latest 23 Jan 2009. Each later question says it follows up an earlier answer.

Follow-ups
3
longest chain 1 step
Span
43 days
11 Dec 2008 to 23 Jan 2009
Answered
4 of 4
by Stewart Stevenson
Asked by
2
MSPs

The thread, in order

Each answer’s opening lines; open a question for the full text
  1. S3W-18821 11 Dec 2008 Jeremy Purvis LD Answered

    To ask the Scottish Executive on what basis the cost of the Forth Replacement Crossing was previously estimated by the Minister for Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change to be £4 billion and on what basis this was later reduced to £2 billion.

    Stewart Stevenson, 14 Jan 2009: The new estimate of £1.7 billion to £2.3 billion is based on the same elements as the previous estimate of £3.2 billion to £4.2 billion. The significant reduction in costs can be attributed to the reduced width of the bridge, made possible by utilising the existing Forth Road Bridge for public transport, cyclists and …
  2. S3W-19910 16 Jan 2009 Alison McInnes LD Answered

    Whether the reduction in the cost estimate for the Forth Replacement Crossing is wholly attributable to the reduced width of the bridge, the use of ITS and more refined estimating in light of further detailed surveys, investigations and design development.

    Stewart Stevenson, 6 Feb 2009: The new proposals come within an outturn price range of £1.7 billion to £2.3 billion, an average saving of around £1.7 billion on the previous estimate of £3.2 billion to £4.2 billion. This has come principally from: 1. the reduced cost for the new bridge, which with the use of the existing bridge for public transport…
  3. S3W-20159 23 Jan 2009 Jeremy Purvis LD Answered follows S3W-18821

    Why no reference was made to cost savings claimed as a result of the funding mechanism.

    Stewart Stevenson, 30 Jan 2009: In response to question S3W-18821, I explained that the reduction in the cost estimates could be attributed to the reduced width of the bridge, made possible by utilising the existing Forth Road Bridge for public transport, pedestrians and cyclists. I explained that further reductions have been secured through the use…
  4. S3W-20169 23 Jan 2009 Jeremy Purvis LD Answered follows S3W-18821

    And in light of the comments by the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth in the Parliament on 15 January 2009 (Official Report c. 14088), for what reasons no reference was made in the answer to the reduced costs associated with the funding mechanism.

    Stewart Stevenson, 30 Jan 2009: The Cabinet Secretary referred to the reduction of exposure to risk. A different form of procurement option would increase this exposure but given our clear commitment to the use of a design and build contract, it was not necessary to mention this in the answer.

How this thread is put together

Follow-up
A question whose text says it is “further to the answer to question …” (or reply, response, or asks for a “substantive answer” to an earlier question). The question it names is its parent.
Several citations
When a question cites more than one earlier question, the most recent one we hold is used as the parent; the others are listed as “also cites”.
Thread
Follow parents back to the first question; every question that leads back to it is in this thread. Branches are shown in date order.

All question threads