Parliament Workbench

Question thread · 11 questions

What discussions it has had with Her Majesty’s Government regarding its proposed review of the Game Acts, as reported in The Times on 12 October 2004; whether such a review is planned for the Game (Scotland) Acts and, i…

Started with S2W-11675 on 25 Oct 2004; latest 10 Sep 2007. Each later question says it follows up an earlier answer.

Follow-ups
10
longest chain 2 steps
Span
1,050 days
25 Oct 2004 to 10 Sep 2007
Answered
11 of 11
by Tavish Scott, Lewis Macdonald, Michael Russell
Asked by
2
MSPs

The thread, in order

Each answer’s opening lines; open a question for the full text
  1. S2W-11675 25 Oct 2004 Rob Gibson SNP Answered

    To ask the Scottish Executive what discussions it has had with Her Majesty’s Government regarding its proposed review of the Game Acts, as reported in The Times on 12 October 2004; whether such a review is planned for the Game (Scotland) Acts and, if so, how, and when, it intends to bring forward any proposed changes to these Acts.

    Tavish Scott, 6 Dec 2004: The Scottish Executive is in regular contact with the UK Government on a wide range of issues, including the proposed review of the Game Acts, and is presently considering this issue.
  2. S2W-12957 9 Dec 2004 Rob Gibson SNP Answered

    Whether it has now reached a conclusion in respect of whether there will be a review of the Game (Scotland) Acts and, if so, what that conclusion is.

    Tavish Scott, 20 Jan 2005: The Executive is stillconsidering whether to conduct a review of the Game (Scotland)Acts.
  3. S2W-12958 9 Dec 2004 Rob Gibson SNP Answered follows S2W-11675

    Whether it considers the Game (Scotland) Acts to be consistent with the EU Directive on the Conservation of Birds; whether the European Commission has expressed any view on this matter, and how this issue will be addressed in any review of the Game (Scotland) Acts.

    Tavish Scott, 20 Jan 2005: The Game (Scotland) Actsall predate the obligations placed on Scottish ministers by Council Directive79/409/EEC, but they are not inconsistent with those obligations. Scottish ministers havereceived no formal communication from the European Commission in relation tothis matter. Any review of the Game Actswould take fu…
  4. S2W-12959 9 Dec 2004 Rob Gibson SNP Answered follows S2W-11675

    What powers are granted to landowners, occupiers, gamekeepers and servants under the Game (Scotland) Act 1832 and whether these powers are consistent with its criminal justice policies and the European Convention on Human Rights.

    Tavish Scott, 28 Jan 2005: The Game (Scotland) Act 1832 makes it an offence for any person entering or being, in the daytime, upon any land, without leave of the proprietor, in search or pursuit of game, or woodcock, snipe, wild ducks or conies (rabbits). Landowners, occupiers, gamekeepers, or any servants or any person authorised by them may r…
  5. S2W-14165 4 Feb 2005 Rob Gibson SNP Answered follows S2W-12957

    How long it expects its consideration of whether to conduct a review of the Game (Scotland) Acts to last and when it will announce its conclusion.

    Tavish Scott, 1 Mar 2005: No timescales have been setfor this activity. This issue is still under on-going discussion with the UKGovernment, and at the conclusion of these discussions a decision on any reviewapplying to Game Acts on Scotland will be made.
  6. S2W-14166 4 Feb 2005 Rob Gibson SNP Answered follows S2W-12958

    What correspondence or discussions, either formal or informal, it has had with the European Commission or the UK Government in relation to references to game birds in the DG Environment press releases on 29 January 2004 (IP/04/128) and 15 July 2004 (IP/04/933) and what legislative changes are required in Scotland to address these matters

    Tavish Scott, 7 Mar 2005: Issues arising from legal action proposed by the European Commission against member states are confidential. Therefore no information can be provided at this time.
  7. S2W-14167 4 Feb 2005 Rob Gibson SNP Answered follows S2W-12959

    What its policy is in relation to the undertaking of criminal prosecutions by private individuals and whether the power for a landowner or occupier, as well as the procurator fiscal, to prosecute an alleged offender under the Game (Scotland) Act 1832 is consistent with this policy.

    Tavish Scott, 10 Mar 2005: The sole public prosecutor inScotland is the Lord Advocate. He is represented locally by the Procurator Fiscal.The question of prosecution by a private individual is a matter of law rather thanpolicy. The authority vested in landownersand others by virtue of the Game (Scotland) Act 1832 can be distinguished from priva…
  8. S2W-14168 4 Feb 2005 Rob Gibson SNP Answered follows S2W-12959

    What its policy is in relation to provisions to allow criminal convictions on the evidence of a single witness, in particular what criteria it uses to determine to which offences such provisions should apply, and whether the single witness provisions of the Game (Scotland) Act 1832 are consistent with this policy.

    Tavish Scott, 7 Mar 2005: The Law of Scotland provides that no person can be convicted of a crime or statutory offence unless there is evidence of at least two witnesses implicating the person accused with the crime or offence with which he is charged. The rule does not require every circumstance of the crime or offence with which the accused …
  9. S2W-14169 4 Feb 2005 Rob Gibson SNP Answered follows S2W-12959

    What levels of fine may be levied for breaches of the Game (Scotland) Act 1832; what punishments are available for any non-payment of such fines; whether these punishments have been amended since 1832, and whether they are consistent with its criminal justice policies.

    Tavish Scott, 1 Mar 2005: The levels of fine which maybe levied for breaches of the Game (Scotland) Act 1832, and the punishments which are availablefor non-payment of fines are set out in the table below. Breach of Game (Scotland) Act 1832 | Level of Fine | Maximum Amount of Fine | Maximum Penalty for Non-Payment of Fine Trespass in pursuit o…
  10. S2W-16124 21 Apr 2005 Rob Gibson SNP Answered follows S2W-12957

    Whether it has reached a conclusion on whether to conduct a review of the Game (Scotland) Acts and, if so, when the review will commence, what its timescale will be and what opportunities will be available for stakeholders to make a contribution.

    Lewis Macdonald, 3 May 2005: These matters remain under active consideration and an announcement will be made shortly.
  11. S3W-04151 10 Sep 2007 Rhona Brankin Lab Answered follows S2W-11675

    When it expects the review of the Game Acts to be completed and when it will announce its proposals for reform.

    Michael Russell, 20 Sep 2007: Scottish ministersare aware that the Game Acts would benefit from review. The timing of any suchreview is being considered alongside other priorities.

How this thread is put together

Follow-up
A question whose text says it is “further to the answer to question …” (or reply, response, or asks for a “substantive answer” to an earlier question). The question it names is its parent.
Several citations
When a question cites more than one earlier question, the most recent one we hold is used as the parent; the others are listed as “also cites”.
Thread
Follow parents back to the first question; every question that leads back to it is in this thread. Branches are shown in date order.

All question threads