Written Question · S2W-14168 · Session 2
Further to the answer to question S2W-12959 by Tavish Scott on 28 January 2005, what its policy is in relation to provisions to allow crimi…
The question
To ask the Scottish Executive, further to the answer to question S2W-12959 by Tavish Scott on 28 January 2005, what its policy is in relation to provisions to allow criminal convictions on the evidence of a single witness, in particular what criteria it uses to determine to which offences such provisions should apply, and whether the single witness provisions of the Game (Scotland) Act 1832 are consistent with this policy.
The answer
The Law of Scotland provides that no person can be convicted of a crime or statutory offence unless there is evidence of at least two witnesses implicating the person accused with the crime or offence with which he is charged. The rule does not require every circumstance of the crime or offence with which the accused is charged to be proved by two witnesses. The basic requirement is that the crucial features of the crime or offence, namely that the crime or offence was committed and that it was committed by the accused must be established by evidence from at least two sources.
There are, however, several Acts of Parliament which provide that persons accused of contravening their provisions may be convicted on the evidence of one credible witness. These include the Game (Scotland) Act 1832 Act. In those circumstances it was thought at the time the offence was created that the public interest was best served by waiving the usual rules of corroboration. There are a number of more modern Acts where a similar conclusion has been reached, for example section 21 of the Road Traffic Offenders Act 1988.
On each occasion where consideration is being given to disapplying the normal rules of corroboration, it is for those responsible for the introduction of the statute to demonstrate why it is in the public interest that this should be done. There is no set list of criteria as the public interest will have to be considered in the particular circumstances concerned.
Any review of the Game (Scotland) Act 1832 will provide an opportunity to examine the continuing requirement for this waiver.
There are, however, several Acts of Parliament which provide that persons accused of contravening their provisions may be convicted on the evidence of one credible witness. These include the Game (Scotland) Act 1832 Act. In those circumstances it was thought at the time the offence was created that the public interest was best served by waiving the usual rules of corroboration. There are a number of more modern Acts where a similar conclusion has been reached, for example section 21 of the Road Traffic Offenders Act 1988.
On each occasion where consideration is being given to disapplying the normal rules of corroboration, it is for those responsible for the introduction of the statute to demonstrate why it is in the public interest that this should be done. There is no set list of criteria as the public interest will have to be considered in the particular circumstances concerned.
Any review of the Game (Scotland) Act 1832 will provide an opportunity to examine the continuing requirement for this waiver.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S2W-14168 by reference.