Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

Written Question · S2W-14167 · Session 2

Further to the answer to question S2W-12959 by Tavish Scott on 28 January 2005, what its policy is in relation to the undertaking of crimin…

Answered Asked by Rob Gibson SNP Lodged 4 Feb 2005

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive, further to the answer to question S2W-12959 by Tavish Scott on 28 January 2005, what its policy is in relation to the undertaking of criminal prosecutions by private individuals and whether the power for a landowner or occupier, as well as the procurator fiscal, to prosecute an alleged offender under the Game (Scotland) Act 1832 is consistent with this policy.

The answer

Answered by Tavish Scott on 10 Mar 2005 · 34 days after it was lodged, 6 days after it was due

The sole public prosecutor inScotland is the Lord Advocate. He is represented locally by the Procurator Fiscal.The question of prosecution by a private individual is a matter of law rather thanpolicy.
The authority vested in landownersand others by virtue of the Game (Scotland) Act 1832 can be distinguished from private prosecution.
A person may apply to the HighCourt of Justiciary for authority to bring a private prosecution in relation toa crime at common law or a statutory offence for which imprisonment without optionof a fine is competent. Such a person must establish that he or she has a substantialinterest to do so and that the Lord Advocate has refused to prosecute. The petitionermust state that the Lord Advocate has not only refused to prosecute but has alsorefused to concur in a private prosecution. In considering whether to concur ina private prosecution in any case the Lord Advocate will have regard to whetherit is in the public interest in view of the facts and circumstances of the case.Such prosecutions have only been authorised by the High Court twice since 1900.
In contrast, section 2 of theGame (Scotland) Act 1832 is a specific statutory provision which provides that atrespasser who has been required to quit land and give his or her name and abodebut refuses to do so may be arrested and brought before a justice of the peace and,on summary conviction, at the instance of the owner or occupier of the land or theProcurator Fiscal may be required to pay a financial penalty of not more than levelone on the standard scale. It would be inappropriate for a person to be prosecutedtwice for the same offence and therefore, in practice, any person seeking to prosecutea trespasser for this offence should ensure that no other proceedings are in contemplationor have been taken.
We are not aware of any casesin recent times in which a private individual has initiated a prosecution in termsof section 2 of the act but records held indicate that a very small number of offenceshave been reported to procurators fiscal.
Any review of the Game (Scotland) Act1832 will provide an opportunity to examine
the situation and consider amendments.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S2W-14167 by reference.